Curated acquisitions
Conflict at Its Edges
Five photographs made between 1952 and 2016 approach conflict through borders, religious and domestic space, smoke, ruins, and the uncertain aftermath of violence. Accessioned together from two Magnum Photos 75 curations, they test what documentary evidence can show and what remains unresolved.
Gift
Works in this acquisition
5 works
Curatorial publication standard
Curatorial reading
Work entry
David Seymour: Patrolling the border between the Negev Desert and Jordan
Accession: 6529NM.2026.002
Artist: David Seymour
Date: 1952
Medium: Photograph
Credit: © David Seymour/Magnum Photos 2022 All Rights Reserved
The 6529 Network Museum presents this photograph in Conflict at Its Edges, a five-work group from Magnum Photos 75. The image remains tied to its source caption and archive context; the Museum does not extend unresolved details beyond the evidence recorded in the proposal and source dossier.
Token record
- CAIP-19: eip155:1/erc721:0xe628b59d34f42b16c53f4d697f1ffd4d8d987b91/127
- Transfer: 0xa7c3ac876453a9b5af10b53402a284e6f14d66a29df197e4b148c3c23970836c at block 25741708, log 696
- Common finalized observation: block 25741809 (0x8581c55db52accfd3750ec3af9972430fd4717f3486ac51bc7c1e0b00c335731)
- Owner at that observation: 0xbecfa2ba5a782d11e1a0e821e8f2e30b6684178c
The tokenized object is accessioned into the permanent Collection. Copyright and reproduction permission remain separate; the source record states All Rights Reserved.
Work entry
Larry Towell: Government soldiers in a church, Suchitoto, El Salvador
Accession: 6529NM.2026.002
Artist: Larry Towell
Date: 1986
Medium: Photograph
Credit: © Larry Towell/Magnum Photos 2022 All Rights Reserved
The 6529 Network Museum presents this photograph in Conflict at Its Edges, a five-work group from Magnum Photos 75. The image remains tied to its source caption and archive context; the Museum does not extend unresolved details beyond the evidence recorded in the proposal and source dossier.
Token record
- CAIP-19: eip155:1/erc721:0xe628b59d34f42b16c53f4d697f1ffd4d8d987b91/145
- Transfer: 0xe4af0f51779cf14b18297aa922876029640734c102395c02f0d054c55e630b8d at block 25741724, log 229
- Common finalized observation: block 25741809 (0x8581c55db52accfd3750ec3af9972430fd4717f3486ac51bc7c1e0b00c335731)
- Owner at that observation: 0xbecfa2ba5a782d11e1a0e821e8f2e30b6684178c
The tokenized object is accessioned into the permanent Collection. Copyright and reproduction permission remain separate; the source record states All Rights Reserved.
Work entry
Micha Bar-Am: Demonstration, Western Wall, Jerusalem
Accession: 6529NM.2026.002
Artist: Micha Bar-Am
Date: 1989
Medium: Photograph
Credit: © Micha Bar-Am/Magnum Photos 2022 All Rights Reserved
The 6529 Network Museum presents this photograph in Conflict at Its Edges, a five-work group from Magnum Photos 75. The image remains tied to its source caption and archive context; the Museum does not extend unresolved details beyond the evidence recorded in the proposal and source dossier.
Token record
- CAIP-19: eip155:1/erc721:0xe628b59d34f42b16c53f4d697f1ffd4d8d987b91/97
- Transfer: 0x0ff08ed5fb29cc8e83dd50191e1156615ad23d584e05c9d1803af39151ecb33d at block 25741718, log 430
- Common finalized observation: block 25741809 (0x8581c55db52accfd3750ec3af9972430fd4717f3486ac51bc7c1e0b00c335731)
- Owner at that observation: 0xbecfa2ba5a782d11e1a0e821e8f2e30b6684178c
The tokenized object is accessioned into the permanent Collection. Copyright and reproduction permission remain separate; the source record states All Rights Reserved.
Work entry
Moisés Saman: Tripoli, Libya
Accession: 6529NM.2026.002
Artist: Moisés Saman
Date: 2011
Medium: Photograph
Credit: © Moisés Saman/Magnum Photos 2022 All Rights Reserved
The 6529 Network Museum presents this photograph in Conflict at Its Edges, a five-work group from Magnum Photos 75. The image remains tied to its source caption and archive context; the Museum does not extend unresolved details beyond the evidence recorded in the proposal and source dossier.
Token record
- CAIP-19: eip155:1/erc721:0xe628b59d34f42b16c53f4d697f1ffd4d8d987b91/44
- Transfer: 0x9fbef477914c51b2d4e3ae13f791d36499a5ac0516e7ce13a0b40531bc833e74 at block 25741721, log 207
- Common finalized observation: block 25741809 (0x8581c55db52accfd3750ec3af9972430fd4717f3486ac51bc7c1e0b00c335731)
- Owner at that observation: 0xbecfa2ba5a782d11e1a0e821e8f2e30b6684178c
The tokenized object is accessioned into the permanent Collection. Copyright and reproduction permission remain separate; the source record states All Rights Reserved.
Work entry
Lorenzo Meloni: Palmyra, Syria
Accession: 6529NM.2026.002
Artist: Lorenzo Meloni
Date: 2016
Medium: Photograph
Credit: © Lorenzo Meloni/Magnum Photos 2022 All Rights Reserved
The 6529 Network Museum presents this photograph in Conflict at Its Edges, a five-work group from Magnum Photos 75. The image remains tied to its source caption and archive context; the Museum does not extend unresolved details beyond the evidence recorded in the proposal and source dossier.
Token record
- CAIP-19: eip155:1/erc721:0xe628b59d34f42b16c53f4d697f1ffd4d8d987b91/104
- Transfer: 0x443e02349d0b5538fd33acb392edbb6ce63a6479917b3be0d71cd5069cdaaa07 at block 25741705, log 385
- Common finalized observation: block 25741809 (0x8581c55db52accfd3750ec3af9972430fd4717f3486ac51bc7c1e0b00c335731)
- Owner at that observation: 0xbecfa2ba5a782d11e1a0e821e8f2e30b6684178c
The tokenized object is accessioned into the permanent Collection. Copyright and reproduction permission remain separate; the source record states All Rights Reserved.
Artist study
David Seymour (Chim)
6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · Publication record and suggested citation
Artist profile
Selected Work: Patrolling the border between the Negev Desert and Jordan, 1952
Sources: S01–S02, S17–S19, S42–S43
A border enters David Seymour’s selected photograph through a caption and a posture. The image gives the viewer a turned body, a rifle, a pale shelter, and eroded terrain; the named line between the Negev and Jordan remains outside the frame. This relation between visible circumstance and historical description reaches back through Seymour’s work in the illustrated press, the Spanish Civil War, postwar reconstruction, and Israel. His photographs place political history close to bodies, families, labor, landscape, and the ordinary structures of survival.
From the illustrated press to postwar reconstruction
David Szymin was born in Warsaw in 1911 and became known professionally as Chim. His early work developed within the illustrated press and the political culture of interwar Europe. The Spanish Civil War gave him a subject in which public conflict and private life appeared together: civilians, families, displacement, and the physical consequences of fighting. The camera remained attentive to the person inside the event.
That attention continued after the Second World War. Seymour’s postwar commissions for UNICEF made children, displacement, injury, and reconstruction central to a major period of his practice. The pictures carry documentary information through gesture and circumstance: a child’s posture, a damaged home, a temporary shelter, or a family’s arrangement within a landscape. The human subject remains specific even when the surrounding history is vast.
The International Center of Photography describes this approach as humanistic reportage. Its account of Seymour’s work connects the Spanish Civil War, postwar reconstruction, the emergence of Israel, and the lives of people affected by political change. ICP’s related press material describes a form of photography in which informative detail can carry metaphor. The point lies in the pressure between the detail and the history around it. A single figure can hold a political situation without becoming its emblem.1
Israel as a sustained photographic field
Seymour travelled regularly to Israel from 1951 onward. ICP places this work within his attention to the new country, its settlers, public life, labor, and changing relation between people and land. The selected frame belongs to that sustained period of looking.
His Israel photographs connect public events with the material conditions surrounding them. Roads, settlements, fields, uniforms, work, religious observance, and open terrain become evidence of a country still being organized and contested. The camera records the visible world while the caption supplies a wider political geography. That division matters in the Negev photograph. The viewer sees a person standing in rough country; the archive and caption name a patrol and a border.
Seymour’s work in Israel also extends his earlier interest in reconstruction. A new state appears through the people inhabiting it, the institutions defining it, and the land through which its political claims are made. The selected image holds a military presence inside a landscape that appears almost empty. Its emptiness is visual; the caption gives it a dense historical charge.
Magnum and authored circulation
Seymour helped establish Magnum in 1947 and later served as the agency’s president after Robert Capa’s death. Magnum’s current institutional history names Henri Cartier-Bresson, Robert Capa, George Rodger, and Seymour as the four founders; other official biographies also record William Vandivert’s early involvement. Those formulations remain source-specific.2
For Seymour, Magnum’s importance lies in the route by which an authored photograph could move through cooperative editing, magazines, books, exhibitions, and archives. The photographer’s name remained attached to the image as its public forms changed. That history is present in the selected work, which now carries an archive reference and a token-linked rendition alongside the estate’s own image record.
Seymour died in 1956 while working during the Suez Crisis. His career therefore belongs to a compressed period in which the illustrated press, international reportage, humanitarian commissions, and photographer-led agency structures were being reshaped together. The selected photograph comes from the late phase of his Israel work, four years before his death.
The selected photograph
The image is vertically composed. A person occupies the lower foreground, seen from behind or in partial profile, with the face unavailable for identification. A long firearm and sling dominate the central foreground. Beyond the figure are a pale tent-like structure, open ground, loose rock, and layered hills or escarpments. A thin vertical pole or line appears near the middle-left. The frame contains no legible flag, border marker, insignia, map, or unit designation.
The rifle establishes the strongest diagonal in the picture. It joins the figure’s body to the shelter and the terrain beyond, turning equipment into a line of attention. Dark clothing, rock, and firearm form a compact lower mass; the pale structure opens a small interval; the hills recede in tonal bands. The viewer follows the patrol’s direction of looking without seeing the object of that attention.
The token record names the work Patrolling the border between the Negev Desert and Jordan, 1952, and gives the archive reference SED1952003W00003/. The David Seymour estate presents a visually matching frame as PAR116258. and adds the fuller place description “The King Solomon’s Mines area, Israel, 1952.” The two records strongly correspond in appearance. A public archival record linking the estate filename to the Magnum archive number remains absent.3
Border history and archival limits
The 1949 Israel–Jordan General Armistice Agreement established an armistice demarcation line in the region. United States Department of State records describe frontier incidents and the unsettled character of the boundary in 1952. These documents supply historical setting for a photograph captioned to a border patrol. They do not identify the person, patrol route, unit, exact site, or incident in the frame.4
The estate’s “King Solomon’s Mines area” phrase adds a second place register to the token’s shorter “Negev, Israel” wording. The distinction should remain visible. The public record supports a 1952 Negev/Israel caption and a strong visual correspondence between two image records. It leaves the exact coordinates, day, assignment, commissioner, first publication, negative, contact sheet, and archive-number semantics unresolved.
Museum interpretation
Seymour makes a border legible without showing a line. The political edge arrives through the figure’s stance, the firearm, the caption, and the receding terrain. Watchfulness becomes the photograph’s central action. The person looks outward; the viewer remains behind him, held at the same distance from whatever the patrol observes.
The image also gives the landscape an unusual responsibility. The hills do not illustrate a named event. They absorb the event’s pressure. Their exposed surfaces and sparse structures hold the body in a field where political geography has to be supplied by records outside the picture.
Within the selected five-Work group, Seymour provides the earliest photograph and the founding-generation Magnum perspective. Its restraint establishes a question that later works alter: how much history can a frame carry when the decisive boundary belongs to the caption, the archive, and the viewer’s knowledge?
Footnotes
-
Magnum Photos and International Center of Photography records, sources S17–S18. ↩
-
Magnum institutional history, cooperative description, and Seymour profile, sources S01–S02 and S17. ↩
-
United Nations Israel–Jordan armistice records and United States Department of State frontier records, sources S42–S43. ↩
Artist study
Larry Towell
6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · Publication record and suggested citation
Artist profile
Selected Work: Government soldiers in a church, Suchitoto, El Salvador, 1986
Sources: S11, S20–S21, S33, S45–S47, S52
Larry Towell’s selected photograph is a small room made to carry a history larger than its walls. A crucifix establishes the upper axis, two soldiers occupy the lower field, and their rifles alter the church’s visual order. Towell’s Central American practice developed through this pressure between a particular place and the histories that pass through it. His photographs give duration a formal role: roads, interiors, families, institutions, and landscapes accumulate meaning across a body of work.
Formation and long-form practice
Towell’s public biography places his formation in rural Ontario, study at York University, volunteer work, music, writing, and photography. Magnum’s profile describes his work in Nicaragua, Guatemala, and El Salvador, alongside recurring concerns with landlessness, disappearance, books, exhibitions, and museum collections.1 These details describe a practice shaped by return and accumulation.
Central America became a formative field during the 1980s. Towell photographed the Contra war in Nicaragua, the relatives of people who had disappeared in Guatemala, and the civil war in El Salvador. The work moves between rural life, military power, displacement, religious institutions, and memory. A single frame can carry the evidence of a particular room while remaining connected to a much longer sequence of encounters.
Landlessness provides one of the clearest continuities in Towell’s practice. Land is physical ground, legal possession, family history, political promise, and the setting in which displacement becomes visible. In the selected photograph, the church belongs to a community as well as to an architectural tradition. Its walls and symbols hold that social ground while armed bodies occupy the space.
Exhibition, book, and photographic sequence
Towell’s Central American work reached public form through exhibitions and books. Larry Towell: Gifts of War, organized by the Art Gallery of Windsor, travelled between April 1988 and October 1989. The exhibition brought photographs and testimonies from Nicaragua, El Salvador, and Guatemala into a sequence concerned with civilian life, repression, and the effects of war. A separate Coach House Press publication, Gift of War, appeared in 1988.2
Towell’s CV lists Gift of War from 1988 and El Salvador from 1997. The library record for El Salvador identifies a 127-page book with an introduction by Mark Danner and a historical focus on violence, insurgency, and El Salvador between 1979 and 1992.2 These forms extend the life of a photograph. An exhibition establishes a spatial relation among images and testimony; a book controls order, scale, page turning, and intervals of silence.
The public record has not supplied a page, plate, or catalogue crosswalk placing token #145 in Gift of War, El Salvador, or a named exhibition. The selected frame belongs securely to Towell’s 1986 El Salvador period. Its precise publication history remains an archival question.
Place names and parallel records
The token metadata names the place as “Suchitito, El Salvador,” with archive reference TOL1986003W00045/. The Museum’s public title uses “Suchitoto,” the spelling supported by the Art Windsor-Essex and Stephen Bulger records. The source variant remains part of the object’s history and should stay visible beside the preferred public form.3
Art Windsor-Essex records a related gelatin silver print as El Salvador Series 1986–1987 (Soldiers in Church, Suchitoto, El Salvador), 1986, with collection number 2002. and dimensions of 35.0 × 28.0 cm. The record gives the Museum a strong material and title comparison. The public page supplies no Magnum archive number, so equivalence between that print and the token-linked rendition remains unconfirmed.4
The distinction matters because one photographic work can have several manifestations: a negative or scan, a gelatin silver print, a book reproduction, an exhibition image, and a token-linked JPEG. Their titles may converge while their object histories remain separate. Towell’s practice, with its emphasis on books and extended projects, makes those differences part of the work’s public life.
Magnum membership and institutional context
Magnum’s public biography gives Towell’s membership date as 1988. A Henri Cartier-Bresson Foundation dossier uses the phrase “since 1989.” Both dates remain attributed to their sources.5 The discrepancy has limited bearing on the photograph’s identity, while it illustrates the layered biography through which documentary work enters institutional history.
Towell’s relation to Magnum belongs alongside his independent bodies of work, books, exhibitions, and museum holdings. The agency provides one route of circulation; the photograph’s meaning also depends on the photographer’s sustained engagement with place, testimony, and the physical forms through which images endure.
The selected work and El Salvador
The visible photograph shows two armed soldiers standing inside a church. Each holds a rifle angled away from the body. A large crucifix rises between and above them. Windows admit light from both sides, and flowers appear low near the altar. The frontal composition makes the interior almost symmetrical, giving the viewer a clear measure of the soldiers’ distance from the crucifix and one another.
The issuer caption places the church near the Guazapa guerrilla stronghold and connects the persecution of the Catholic Church to liberation theology. That language belongs to the caption’s history. The image identifies a church interior, armed men, rifles, religious symbols, windows, and flowers. It leaves the church name, soldiers’ identities, unit, operation, and purpose unresolved.
United Nations peace-accord records provide the broad civil-war and settlement chronology required for a historical reading of the image. They do not identify this church or these soldiers.6 The public record therefore supports a regional context and an attributed caption while preserving the scene-specific questions.
Museum interpretation
Towell’s composition makes armed presence spatially measurable. The crucifix fixes a vertical axis; the soldiers interrupt it without displacing it. Their rifles extend the architectural lines into the lower field, turning military equipment into a second system of order.
The frontal arrangement gives the scene the clarity of a stage. The viewer can compare the soldiers’ positions, follow the rifles toward the floor, and register the small flowers beneath the crucifix. The church remains fully legible as a devotional interior while the soldiers change the room’s social meaning.
This visual order carries historical tension without resolving the event. The photograph can hold a military presence inside sacred architecture while leaving the exact reason for that presence unknown. The caption supplies Guazapa, persecution, and liberation theology as an attributed historical account. The frame supplies the evidence of bodies, weapons, architecture, and light.
The related Art Windsor-Essex print deepens the object’s material history. A gelatin silver print, a book page, an exhibition installation, and a token-linked JPEG each produce a different encounter with the same possible photographic work. The records currently support relation and comparison. They do not prove identity across every manifestation.
Within the selected group, Towell follows Seymour’s open border landscape with an enclosed interior. The conflict edge has become architectural: a room, a community, and a sacred image carry the pressure of armed power.
Footnotes
Artist study
Lorenzo Meloni
6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · Publication record and suggested citation
Artist profile
Selected Work: Palmyra, Syria, 2016
Sources: S30–S32, S41, S48–S49
Lorenzo Meloni’s photographs begin in the interval after an event has been named: a city has been taken, a monument damaged, a population displaced, or a war translated into historical memory. His work across the Middle East and North Africa follows conflict through those transformations. Magnum describes his method as historicist, a term that points toward his attention to older borders, monuments, empires, and recurring forms of destruction. He became a full member of Magnum in 2020.1
Meloni’s projects have developed through extended returns to places marked by war. The Collapse of the Caliphate, presented through Visa pour l’Image in 2017, connected Kobanê, Palmyra, Sirte, and Mosul within a cross-border account of the Islamic State’s rise and territorial collapse. Kobane: The Aftermath followed civilians rebuilding after destruction, giving the aftermath its own documentary time.2 These projects place the photograph within a longer sequence of occupation, ruin, recovery, and remembrance.
The 2022 book We Don’t Say Goodbye gathers photographs made between 2013 and 2019 in Iraq, Syria, and Libya. GOST describes a fragmented publication in which images are interrupted by objects and writing recovered from war rubble. The interruption is material and historical. A photograph shares the page with remains that have passed through another life: a fragment, an inscription, a document, an object separated from its original setting. Meloni’s documentary field therefore extends beyond the moment of exposure. It includes the things that survive the event and the forms through which those things are later read.3
Palmyra, Syria condenses that method. A helmeted soldier sits among pale rubble beneath a blue sky; surviving columns establish the scale of the site while the concealed face withholds a complete account of the figure’s state. The contemporary caption places the photograph five days after the recapture of Palmyra and identifies the ruins with the former Temple of Bel. UNESCO records the monument’s destruction in August 2015 and the constrained, incompletely demined conditions of the site after the March 2016 change of control. TIME and AFP describe the permission, military shadowing, minder, mine warnings, and directed access that surrounded contemporary visits to the ruins.4
Those conditions belong to the photograph’s history. The route into Palmyra shaped where the camera could stand, what remained visible, and how the scene entered publication. The frame records a pause after destruction and after military recapture. It does not show the blast or the battle. Its surviving columns keep the site’s history open to material continuity even as the caption places the image within a landscape of loss.
Within the selected five-Work proposal, Meloni’s token is one of four works marked 2/ in Magnum Photos 75 metadata. Moisés Saman’s #44 is the sole 1/ work. Their relation was formed later by the donor, across the two curations.5 Meloni’s photograph closes the chronological sequence with a damaged site whose documentary afterlife remains active in captions, books, archives, and networked editions.
The public record establishes Meloni’s broader projects and the photograph’s captioned date and place. It has not established the exact frame’s inclusion in We Don’t Say Goodbye or the 2017 Visa exhibition, nor completed the archive-to-negative or contact-sheet crosswalk. Those absences leave the image’s afterlife open to further research without diminishing the precision of what the frame itself records.
Footnotes
Artist study
Micha Bar-Am
6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · Publication record and suggested citation
Artist profile
Selected Work: Demonstration, Western Wall, Jerusalem, 1989
Sources: S12, S22–S25, S34, S44, S50
Micha Bar-Am, born in Berlin in 1930, has worked across military service, magazine reportage, long-term photographic documentation, and museum formation. His career passes through the 1948 war, the 1956 Sinai War, the Israeli army magazine Bamachane, Magnum correspondence, newspaper work, and the public history of Israeli photography. The selected photograph belongs to a later period in that record: a sacred site, a moving body, smoke, and a caption whose historical reach exceeds what the frame can settle.
A long record of Israeli public life
Magnum’s published biography records Bar-Am’s move with his family to Palestine in 1936, his childhood in Haifa, life on a kibbutz, and military service in 1948. He began photographing kibbutz life, archaeological expeditions, and communal activity. His coverage of the 1956 Sinai War led to the book Across Sinai and to work as a photographer and writer for Bamachane, where he remained for eight years. He began freelancing in 1966, photographed the Six-Day War in 1967, and became a Magnum correspondent in 1968.1
Bar-Am’s subjects have included war, migration, military power, religious life, political ceremony, and the changing routines of Israeli society. His photographs often hold a public event against a quieter structure: a wall, a road, a room, a line of bodies, or an object that controls movement. The resulting images carry the pressure of history through arrangement as much as through incident. The International Center of Photography’s record of Israel Diary, 1956–1982 describes a body of work following successive chapters in the modern state through national events and everyday life.2 The selected 1989 photograph continues that attention to the relationship between public history and ordinary physical presence.
Photographer and institution builder
Bar-Am also shaped the institutions through which photography is encountered. He assisted Cornell Capa with the establishment of the International Center of Photography in 1974 and later led photography at the Tel Aviv Museum of Art. Magnum’s profile dates that curatorial role from 1977 to 1993. A release from the Micha Bar-Am Archive gives the period as service through 1992 and dates the Enrique Kavlin Lifetime Achievement Award separately to 1993.3 The two dates remain attributed to their sources.
This movement between making, editing, collecting, and exhibiting photographs is part of Bar-Am’s significance. A news photograph reaches the public through an assignment and caption; an archive gives it an identifier and a place in a sequence; an exhibition changes its scale and neighbours; a museum record connects it to other manifestations. Bar-Am’s career has occupied all of these positions. His work offers a particularly clear case for studying how an image moves from immediate report to durable public history.
The selected photograph
The photograph is black and white. A person moves across the middle distance through smoke, one arm extending beyond the frame. A canister is visible in the air. The Western Wall occupies the background as a broad band of masonry, while metal menorah-like fixtures and a low barrier cut across the foreground. The composition is shallow and compressed: architecture, smoke, hardware, and the moving figure occupy nearly the same plane.
Smoke interrupts the continuity of the scene. It opens a pale space around the figure and obscures the action that would explain the movement. The canister gives the photograph a point of physical tension, while the metal structure establishes the sacred site as a place governed by objects, boundaries, and controlled access. The central person remains partial. Face, affiliation, exact gesture, and position in the event are unavailable from the reviewed public record.
The visible evidence therefore consists of a person, smoke, an airborne canister, masonry, and foreground metalwork. It does not identify the person or establish the contents of the canister.
Caption, archive, and context
The token metadata dates the photograph to 1989, places it at the Western Wall
in Jerusalem, assigns it to curation 2/, and records the archive string
BAM1989009W02477/. Its longer description associates the photograph with
women’s Torah prayer and police smoke grenades. That is the issuer’s account
of the scene.4
The Micha Bar-Am Archive presents a visually matching work as Demonstration,
Western Wall, Jerusalem, 1989, with the identifier
BAM1989009W02477-. ICP uses the same concise title and year. Museum Wales
preserves the historical title variant Western Wall (Wailing Wall),
Jerusalem.5 The shared archive stem is a strong cross-reference. The
difference between - and / remains unresolved. No reviewed public
source explains whether the suffix marks a catalogue convention, scan, crop,
variant, or another archive state.
Women of the Wall’s own history supplies a situated account of the 1988–1989 dispute over prayer, gender, access, and religious authority at the Wall.6 That history provides context for the issuer’s caption. It does not attach this exposure to a particular day, identify the moving person, or establish the person’s affiliation. “Tear gas” belongs to attributed caption and historical records; the photograph itself remains a record of smoke and an airborne canister.
Proximity and distance
Bar-Am has described the difficulty of being a participant, observer, witness, and interpreter at once.1 That reflection offers a lens for his documentary practice, not an intention statement about this exposure. The frame places the camera close to a public confrontation while withholding the information that would make the event narratively complete.
The Wall’s masonry gives the scene historical weight, yet the image is organized around interruption. Smoke damages the continuity of the view. The low barrier divides the viewer from the event. The canister supplies a visible object without supplying a full account of who launched it, toward whom, or in response to what. Sacred architecture remains present through the confusion, making the place legible even as the action remains incomplete.
Bar-Am’s work has repeatedly treated Israeli public life as a field in which national history, personal conviction, religious authority, and everyday movement overlap. Here, the camera records a body passing through a charged space while the archive and later historical records carry the burden of explanation. The photograph’s subject is both the confrontation and the conditions under which a confrontation becomes visible.
The 2022 token is one manifestation of this photographic history. Its 1 of 1 statement describes the ERC-721 edition; the archive, ICP, and Museum Wales
records describe other manifestations. The token metadata carries the credit
© Micha Bar- and All Rights Reserved. The public
record retains the year, place, title, visible action, and archive-number
discrepancy while leaving the exposure date, assignment, central figure, and
future rights authority open.
Footnotes
-
Magnum Photos profile and published practice statement, sources S22 and S44. ↩ ↩2
-
International Center of Photography, Israel Diary, 1956–1982, source S50. ↩
-
Magnum institutional profile and Micha Bar-Am Archive release, sources S22 and S44. ↩
-
Micha Bar-Am Archive, ICP, and Museum Wales records, sources S23–S25. ↩
Artist study
Moisés Saman
6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · Publication record and suggested citation
Artist profile
Selected Work: Tripoli, Libya, 2011
Moisés Saman’s practice developed from conflict reporting into longer
photographic inquiries about memory, access, and the authority of the caption.
The token metadata uses the unaccented form Moises Saman; this profile follows
the artist’s accented name while retaining the issuer’s spelling in the source
record.
From newspaper reporting to sustained inquiry
World Press Photo records Saman’s birth in Lima in 1974, his upbringing in Barcelona, his studies in communications and sociology at California State University, and his early interest in photography through images of the Balkan wars. After a newspaper internship in California and a month photographing postwar Kosovo, he joined Newsday as a staff photographer in 2000. His work there included the aftermath of September 11 and sustained reporting in Afghanistan, Iraq, and the wider Middle East.1
Saman became a freelance photographer in 2007 and contributed to The New York Times, Human Rights Watch, Newsweek, and TIME. World Press Photo records his arrival at Magnum in 2010; Magnum’s fine-print biography identifies him as a full member from 2014.2 The dates describe different stages of his association with the agency.
His practice has increasingly examined how news events become longer histories. The move from assignment to sequence allows uncertainty, repetition, and the limits of caption language to remain visible. Walls, rooms, clothing, roads, and damaged surfaces carry political weight without resolving every account attached to them. A caption can name an event; the photograph can preserve a visible trace; the two records answer different questions.
Tripoli and controlled access
Saman’s Libya work belongs to a period when access, permission, and narrative authority were inseparable from reporting. A retained TIME account describes his 2011 assignment in Tripoli, confinement of foreign reporters at the Rixos Hotel, and movement under government-minder supervision. The Committee to Protect Journalists records the wider pattern of restricted movement, monitoring, and pressure on the press.3
These sources establish the conditions surrounding foreign reporting in Tripoli. They do not identify the house in the selected photograph, the person shown there, or the cause of the wall marks. Their importance lies in the route through which a scene entered the camera and then the public record. The caption’s qualification matters because the reporting environment was itself part of the evidence.
Discordia and the photographic sequence
The WARM Foundation describes Discordia as a long-form project developed from 2011 to 2014 across sites of the Arab Spring. Its sequences move away from a linear news structure and allow photographs to accumulate without captions. The project was exhibited at WARM Festival in Sarajevo in 2015 and later at the Bayeux Festival of War Correspondents; its 2016 self-published book contains 126 photographs and three collages.4
That structure provides a context for Tripoli, Libya. The selected photograph’s visible facts are immediate: a marked wall, a caged lamp, a scarf, a lowered head, and a figure of apparent youth. Its historical meaning arrives through a caption and an access history. Saman’s wider practice makes that relationship legible, while the reviewed public record does not establish that this exact frame appears in Discordia or one of its exhibitions.
Later recognition, including Saman’s work with The New Yorker recorded by the Pulitzer organization, belongs to a subsequent phase of that practice.5 It supplies professional context without retrospectively verifying the 2011 Libya caption.
The selected photograph
An apparently young person stands close to a pale wall. The wall is interrupted by numerous dark marks and broken areas. A caged lamp hangs above. The figure wears a dark coat and a light scarf; the head and gaze turn downward. The room is shallow and frontal, with the wall occupying most of the frame.
The image gives the viewer a damaged surface and a vulnerable-looking presence. It gives no name, exact age, biography, nationality, family relationship, or confirmed location beyond the public title and the issuer’s description of Tripoli. The marks are visible. Their cause remains outside the visible evidence.
The issuer’s caption makes two separate statements. It records Libyan government officials’ claim that Western air strikes targeted the house, damaged it, and injured a woman. The same caption says that this claim was impossible to verify. A separate passage reports that government minders showed journalists evidence of strikes targeting civilian areas.6 The second statement concerns what the minders presented; it does not verify the first account or establish the cause of the marks in this image.
The photograph’s formal pressure comes from the distance between a visible trace and the account attached to it. The wall occupies the space where proof seems available, yet the image cannot supply a chain from mark to weapon, from damage to responsibility, or from the reported injury to the depicted person. The caged lamp gives the room a fixed point; the lowered head keeps the person’s inner state unavailable. Saman’s image allows the claim to remain present as a claim, with its uncertainty intact.
Safeguarding and publication
The subject’s apparent youth requires a restrained public description. The catalogue describes an apparently young person and retains the issuer’s word “girl” only as attributed caption language. It assigns no exact age, name, identity, nationality, family relationship, victim status, or witness status. The reviewed public record supplies no image-specific identity, age, consent documentation, precise house location, or later-life account.
Any future public presentation should keep the caption’s qualification beside
the image. Interpretation can explain the government-managed access surrounding
the report without turning the officials’ account into fact. Alt text and
public metadata remain at visible-fact level, with no identifying or sensitive
location detail. The token’s 1 of 1 designation and public Arweave locator
supply no reproduction authority.
Within the selected group, Saman’s token is the sole selected work marked
curation 1/; the other four are marked 2/.6 Its contribution is
formal, historical, and ethical: a marked surface offered as evidence, a
caption that qualifies its own causal account, a managed route into the room,
and a person whom the public record does not identify.
Footnotes
Project study
Conflict at Its Edges
6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · Publication record and suggested citation
Five Photographs of Borders, Access, and Afterlives, 1952–2016
Conflict at Its Edges is a completed five-Work gift accessioned into the
permanent Collection as 6529NM.. It was formed from a proposal
credited to punk6529 as offeror and brings together photographs published in
Magnum Photos 75. The group follows conflict through the conditions surrounding
an image: a border named beyond the frame, a church where armed presence alters
the architecture of worship, smoke interrupting access to a sacred site, marks
on a wall presented as evidence through a qualified caption, and a monument
photographed after destruction and military recapture.
The proposal crosses two Magnum 75 curations. Moisés Saman’s #44 is marked 1/; David Seymour #127, Larry Towell #145, Micha Bar-Am #97, and Lorenzo Meloni #104 are marked 2/. The title and relation enter the public record through the proposal and the Museum’s subsequent interpretation.1
| Field | Record |
|---|---|
| FieldCurated Acquisition | Record6529NM- |
| FieldProposal record | Record6529NM- |
| FieldPublic credit / offeror | Recordpunk6529 |
| FieldFormation | RecordDonor-formed across Magnum Photos 75 curations 1/ and 2/ |
| FieldCurrent status | RecordCompleted gift; accessioned into the permanent Collection as 6529NM. (S37) |
| FieldCollection status | RecordPermanent Collection; five Works accessioned as one gift |
The five Works
| Token | Artist | Work |
|---|---|---|
| Token127 | ArtistDavid Seymour | WorkPatrolling the border between the Negev Desert and Jordan |
| Token145 | ArtistLarry Towell | WorkGovernment soldiers in a church, Suchitoto, El Salvador |
| Token97 | ArtistMicha Bar-Am | WorkDemonstration, Western Wall, Jerusalem |
| Token44 | ArtistMoisés Saman | WorkTripoli, Libya |
| Token104 | ArtistLorenzo Meloni | WorkPalmyra, Syria |
Seymour’s photograph makes a political border present through terrain, posture, and a rifle while withholding a marker or coordinate. Towell places armed presence inside a church, where rifles disturb the architecture of worship. Bar-Am’s smoke and barrier interrupt the view of a moving figure at the Western Wall. Saman’s image shows an apparently young person beside marks on a wall whose cause remains inseparable from the limits of its caption. The reviewed public record supplies no age, identity, or consent documentation for the person shown. Meloni’s soldier sits among the remains of Palmyra, where the site’s destruction, recapture, and controlled access surround an obscured gesture.
Each Work retains its own title, caption history, archive reference, token manifestation, and research questions. The group provides a reading across those records; it does not replace them.
The case
The proposal gives the Museum a compact study of documentary authority. Its five photographs span sixty-four years and several political geographies, yet their relation remains precise. Each image places a body or a built site beside an edge of knowledge: the named border exceeds the landscape, the church exceeds the caption, smoke interrupts event, damage exceeds proof, and the ruin carries a history beyond the moment of exposure.
The group also connects photographic afterlives across different systems. The images have passed through Magnum’s cooperative archive, contemporary reporting, estate and museum records, books, captions, token metadata, Arweave pointers, and a 2022 networked edition. The proposal makes those forms of circulation available for comparison while keeping the rights and authority of each record distinct.2
The countercase
The group creates a relation that the upstream project did not make. Its chronology and geography may encourage a smooth account of “conflict photography” where the five works carry very different histories. The title risks aestheticizing damage or treating every uncertainty as the same kind of uncertainty. Caption authority is uneven, archive crosswalks remain incomplete, and Saman’s photograph contains an apparently young person. The reviewed public record supplies no age, identity, or consent documentation for the person shown.
Rights and stewardship continue to define the accession’s use. The token records
carry All Rights Reserved notices. The Museum interprets ordinary credited
institutional display, publication, and accessibility in accession, Collection,
and scholarship contexts as permissible. That interpretation does not transfer
copyright or grant commercial or general reproduction, derivative, licensing,
download, or AI-training rights. The historical public Wave URLs remain
proposal-context media, and the token-linked renditions are not described as
preservation masters in this public record.3
Response
The countercase establishes the terms on which the group can be published. The five photographs should remain five Works. The title should be presented as a proposal-origin curatorial proposition, with its sources and limits visible. Each caption must remain attributed; each archive discrepancy must remain legible; Saman’s subject requires a safeguarding boundary; and any future public image use requires separate rights evidence.
Under those conditions, the group becomes a precise research relation within the permanent Collection. Its value lies in the way it lets viewers study how documentary photographs acquire meaning at the meeting point of image, caption, access, place, archive, and later circulation. The proposal records the historical selection; the completed accession record establishes the current acceptance, title, custody, rights, technical, and Collection facts.4
The historical Wave presentation remains part of the proposal record. The
accessioned presentation of each Work may render in accession, Collection,
artist, Work, and scholarship contexts under authority
6529NM-, with the supplied artist and
Magnum credits and the label All Rights Reserved. The Museum's interpretation
covers ordinary credited institutional display, publication, and accessibility
in those contexts only; it does not grant copyright, commercial or general
reproduction, derivative, licensing, download, or AI-training rights. The
token-linked renditions remain presentation/source files, not declared
preservation masters (S38).
Footnotes
Project study
Magnum Photos 75
6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · Publication record and suggested citation
An archive enters the blockchain
Magnum Photos 75 gave historical photographs a second circulation through curatorial selection, serial tokens, metadata, image pointers, and network publication. The photographs had already passed through assignments, archives, prints, books, exhibitions, and captions. The 2022 project placed each frame inside a new chain of identifiers: collection number, curation field, token, metadata object, image URI, edition language, and transaction history.1
The numbered edition adds a token manifestation to the photograph's older histories. At an observed block, the token identifies metadata and an image pointer; the contract's administrative controls allow those URIs to change. The underlying work continues through other manifestations in estates, print collections, books, exhibitions, and agency archives.
Curatorial history
The archived official launch page presents a first collection in Magnum’s seventy-fifth anniversary year. It describes 76 images, six drops between 28 June and 12 July 2022, and selection by photographer and Obscura co-founder Alejandro Cartagena. The same announcement also uses 75-image wording. Both statements remain part of the project’s publication history.2
The issuer metadata describes three curations and 225 image positions. The second selection was presented in dialogue with Azu Nwagbogu, founder and director of the African Artists’ Foundation. Nwagbogu’s account shifts attention from the familiar “decisive moment” toward an “indecisive moment”: photographs charged with anticipation, feeling, intention, and several possible readings.3
The first selection’s language emphasizes the endurance of historical photographs. The Museum reads that emphasis as a concern with formal and narrative endurance: a frame survives because its structure and the history carried by it continue to generate attention. That phrase describes the Museum’s interpretation of the launch material; it is not a title assigned to Cartagena’s selection.4
The selected proposal contains one first-register token and four second-register tokens:
| Token | Artist | Date / place | Issuer curation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Token127 | ArtistDavid Seymour | Date / place1952 · Negev | Issuer curation2/ |
| Token145 | ArtistLarry Towell | Date / place1986 · Suchitoto, El Salvador | Issuer curation2/ |
| Token97 | ArtistMicha Bar-Am | Date / place1989 · Jerusalem | Issuer curation2/ |
| Token44 | ArtistMoisés Saman | Date / place2011 · Tripoli | Issuer curation1/ |
| Token104 | ArtistLorenzo Meloni | Date / place2016 · Palmyra | Issuer curation2/ |
The split belongs to the token records. The five-Work relation was formed later by the donor. The reviewed public records contain no statement or evidence that Magnum Photos, Alejandro Cartagena, Azu Nwagbogu, or any of the five artists endorsed the resulting group.5
Counts and publication uncertainty
The project’s public counts require source-specific wording. The archived launch page uses both 75 and 76 for the first release. Direct metadata describes three curations and 225 image positions. A retained Foundation snapshot displays 148 items, while the local proposal dossier reports 148 live tokens at finalized block 25,690,178. Those observations describe distinct publication states and methods. Neither establishes a definitive total of issued tokens or confirms completion of a third curation.6
That uncertainty is part of the project’s material history. Network publication produces exact identifiers while also exposing the difference between an announced plan, a metadata sequence, a marketplace view, and an independently enumerated chain state.
Edition, archive, and rights
Each target token links to JSON metadata and an Arweave JPEG through a common Ethereum ERC-721 contract. Token number, sequence, curation, archive reference, metadata pointer, image pointer, and transfer history are technical publication facts. “1 of 1” describes the token edition. It does not describe the total number of photographic manifestations or resolve the copyright history of the image.
The All Rights Reserved notice attached to the token records remains a rights
statement. The Museum interprets ordinary credited institutional display,
publication, and accessibility in accession, Collection, and scholarship
contexts as permissible. That interpretation does not transfer copyright or
grant commercial or general reproduction, derivative, licensing, download, or
AI-training rights. The Museum cites the historical Wave and token sources with
their artist and Magnum credits; the token-linked renditions are not described
as preservation masters (S09–S16; S38).
Relation to Conflict at Its Edges
Conflict at Its Edges joins one 1/ work to four 2/ works and reads them
through borders, access, captions, marked and damaged sites, and documentary
afterlives. Seymour’s border patrol, Towell’s armed presence in a church,
Bar-Am’s smoke-filled Western Wall, Saman’s caption-qualified interior, and
Meloni’s Palmyra ruin remain five independent Works with distinct caption and
archive histories.
Magnum Photos 75 supplies the project context and the technical route through which these photographs now circulate. The donor supplies the grouping. The Museum’s essay supplies the interpretation. Keeping those authorships separate allows the project’s networked edition to become part of the photographs’ afterlives without turning it into evidence of an upstream curatorial intention.
The proposal’s current Museum status is completed gift; accessioned into the
permanent Collection as 6529NM.. The five Works remain linked to
Magnum Photos 75 as their project context while their Museum accession and
individual object identities remain distinct (S37).
Footnotes
-
Magnum Photos 75 project record and exact token metadata, S04 and S10–S14. ↩
-
Second-release reporting and issuer metadata, S05, S10–S14, and S40. ↩
-
Museum interpretation grounded in the launch announcement, S04. ↩
-
Exact token metadata and proposal record, S10–S14 and S37. ↩
-
Project chronology, Foundation snapshot, and proposal observation, S04, S06–S07, and S37. ↩
Project study
Magnum Photos
6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · Publication record and suggested citation
A cooperative of photographic authorship
Magnum is an institution built around a question of authorship: who shapes a photograph after exposure, and through which forms of circulation does it acquire a public life? Its answer has joined individual photographic practice to a collective system of editing, representation, publication, exhibition, print sales, and archiving.
Magnum’s current institutional history names Robert Capa, Henri Cartier-Bresson, George Rodger, and David “Chim” Seymour as the four photographers who founded the agency in 1947. Other official Magnum biographies include William “Bill” Vandivert in the founding account. The variation belongs to the institution’s own public history and cautions against treating a single founder list as complete.1
The cooperative structure gave photographers a role in deciding how their work would be edited, distributed, and remembered. Magnum’s membership account describes a photographer-owned, self-selecting organization with Nominee, Associate, and full Member stages, alongside estates and correspondents. That structure made collective representation part of photographic authorship. A photograph could travel through magazines, books, exhibitions, prints, and archives while remaining attached to a named practitioner.2
The archive is therefore larger than a store of famous images. The International Center of Photography’s Magnum Manifesto placed prints, books, magazines, video, and archival documents together as evidence of a changing photographic culture. Magnum’s photobook history makes sequence and page order part of that culture. Negatives, contact sheets, captions, assignments, publication pages, exhibitions, rights records, and later digital objects form a chain of relations through which a photograph continues to be interpreted.3
Those relations also carry the conditions of making. Photojournalism can depend on military escorts, state permission, fixers, restricted movement, unequal access to vulnerable people, and editorial decisions that compress lived experience into a caption. The photograph’s authority grows through those circumstances and remains answerable to them. Captioning, consent, subject protection, and the separation of observation from interpretation belong to the history of the image.4
The five photographers in the selected proposal make different histories of Magnum visible. David Seymour represents a founding generation whose postwar work connected political events to displacement, children, and reconstruction. Larry Towell developed long-form projects in Central America through books, exhibitions, and repeated attention to landlessness and disappearance. Micha Bar-Am moved between military experience, newspaper work, Magnum correspondence, and the formation of photographic institutions. Moisés Saman’s Libya work shows the pressure of controlled access and qualified captions. Lorenzo Meloni follows conflict through ruins, territorial change, and historical aftermath.5
Magnum Photos 75 carried this archive into a networked edition. Historical photographs acquired collection numbers, curation fields, token identities, metadata objects, image pointers, and transaction histories. The new records sit beside older archive, caption, print, book, and copyright histories. A token can identify an edition at an observed point in time; the contract's administrative controls mean its metadata and image pointers must be rechecked. Neither token nor pointer settles questions about the negative, first publication, rights, or later use.
The five-Work relation on this page has a distinct author. Punk6529 formed the group for the Museum proposal by bringing together four tokens marked 2/ and Moisés Saman’s token marked 1/ in the Magnum 75 metadata. The reviewed public records contain no statement or evidence that Magnum Photos, Alejandro Cartagena, Azu Nwagbogu, or any of the five artists endorsed the resulting group. The relation belongs to the donor’s proposition and to the Museum’s interpretation of the exact objects.6
The token records carry photographer/Magnum All Rights Reserved notices. The
proposal records token transfer without a copyright or reproduction grant, and
Magnum’s historical terms distinguish an NFT purchase from copyright in the
associated photographic file. The Museum cites the historical Wave and token
sources without serving the five photographic files.7
Footnotes
-
Magnum Photos institutional history and Seymour profile, S01 and S17. ↩
-
International Center of Photography, Magnum Manifesto and photobook records, S39. ↩
-
Magnum and institutional artist records, S17, S20, S22, S26–S27, and S30. ↩
-
Magnum Photos 75 metadata and local proposal record, S04–S05, S10–S14, and S37. ↩
-
Historical Magnum terms, token metadata, proposal evidence, and Wave media record, S09, S10–S16, S37, and S38. ↩
Essay
Acquisition narrative: *Conflict at Its Edges*
6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · Publication record and suggested citation
How the selected offer was formed
The selected offer consists of five token-linked photographs published through
Magnum Photos 75. The public proposal credits punk6529 as offeror and presents
the five under the title Conflict at Its Edges. The artists made five
independent Works; the proposal places them in relation. The completed
accession record documents the donor’s authority and the gift of all five Works
under accession 6529NM..
That relation crosses two Magnum 75 curations. Moisés Saman’s #44 is marked 1/, while David Seymour #127, Larry Towell #145, Micha Bar-Am #97, and Lorenzo Meloni #104 are marked 2/. The split is exact and publicly checkable. It records the upstream selection histories of the tokens; it does not explain why the offeror selected these five. The reviewed public records contain no statement or evidence that Magnum Photos, Alejandro Cartagena, Azu Nwagbogu, or any of the five artists endorsed the resulting group.1
The current status is completed gift; accessioned into the permanent
Collection as 6529NM.. This scholarship, the five object records,
rights and technical review, provenance work, public presentation, and
accession certificate form the current accession package. The five Works
remain individually catalogued; provenance, source-image, rights, and
preservation stewardship continue after accession.
The relation among the photographs
The group begins with a border that the photograph cannot mark directly. Seymour’s patrol occupies a narrow strip of the Negev landscape; the caption supplies the political geography while the image gives terrain, posture, weapon, and distance.
Towell moves the question indoors. Two soldiers stand beneath a crucifix, and the church’s symmetry turns armed presence into a problem of worship, access, and captioned place. The image identifies a room and a historical pressure while leaving the church, unit, and operation unresolved.
Bar-Am photographs a public site through smoke. A canister, moving figure, stone wall, and metal barrier make visibility itself unstable. The Western Wall supplies religious and political context; the exact day and person remain matters for the archive.
Saman brings the question into a shallow domestic space. An apparently young person stands beside a marked wall beneath a caged lamp. The issuer caption includes an official account of air strikes and injury while explicitly describing that account as impossible to verify. The photograph records the wall and the person; the caption records the conditions under which the damage was narrated. The reviewed public record supplies no age, identity, or consent documentation for the person shown.
Meloni closes the chronological sequence at Palmyra. A soldier presses a helmet to his face among rubble and surviving columns. The image follows the destruction of the Temple of Bel and the military recapture of the site. Its access history includes government permission, military shadowing, a minder, mine warnings, and directed entry. The soldier's obscured gesture resists a settled psychological reading while the ruins carry a documented public history.2
Taken together, the five Works concern borders, access, captions, damaged sites, and documentary afterlives. The relation is strongest when each term remains concrete. Borders appear through named places and incomplete coordinates. Access appears through armed presence, controlled routes, military presence, and the conditions of looking. Captions carry claims that the frame cannot independently verify. Damaged sites hold material traces whose causes and histories exceed the image. Documentary afterlives unfold through archives, books, estates, museums, metadata, tokens, and later acts of grouping.
The case for acceptance
Acceptance would give the Museum a carefully bounded study of how photographic evidence travels. Every Work can remain individually legible while the group permits comparison across generations of Magnum practice, documentary situations, and forms of circulation.
The proposed relation also joins photographic history to the specific material history of Magnum Photos 75. The photographs predate blockchain publication by decades. Their 2022 tokens add sequence values, curation fields, metadata objects, Arweave image pointers, edition language, and transfer histories. Those records become part of the photographs’ public afterlives. They offer a way to study what networked publication preserves, what it leaves unresolved, and how an edition can sit beside older histories of caption, print, archive, and copyright.3
The group is small enough for the Museum to keep those distinctions visible. A larger anthology could make uncertainty statistical or anonymous. Five Works allow the public to follow the exact archive reference, the caption’s authority, the access account, the image’s visible evidence, and the unanswered question attached to each frame.
The countercase
The proposal asks the Museum to make a relation that the upstream project did not make. That act carries risk. The six-decade span can flatten differences among postwar border surveillance, civil-war armed presence, religious protest, state-managed press access, and the aftermath of the Islamic State’s destruction. The title may encourage viewers to read all five photographs through a generalized atmosphere of conflict.
The donor’s group also crosses curatorial intentions. Saman’s token belongs to the first Magnum 75 register associated with Alejandro Cartagena; the other four belong to the second register presented in dialogue with Azu Nwagbogu. Their juxtaposition may generate a productive argument, though the reviewed public records contain no statement or evidence from either curator endorsing the five-Work relation.
The evidentiary record remains uneven. Seymour’s archive-to-estate crosswalk is incomplete. Towell’s church and assignment remain unidentified. Bar-Am’s archive suffix and event date require clarification. Saman’s damage account remains qualified, and the reviewed public record supplies no age, identity, or consent documentation for the apparently young person shown. Meloni’s route into Palmyra is documented through contemporary reporting without a frame-specific permission record.
Rights and stewardship create a continuing limit. The token notices read All Rights Reserved; the accession record interprets ordinary credited
institutional display, publication, and accessibility in accession, Collection,
and scholarship contexts as permissible. That interpretation does not transfer
copyright or grant commercial or general reproduction, derivative, licensing,
download, or AI-training rights. The historical Wave URLs remain proposal
evidence, while governed token-linked presentation locators may be used under
the accession display authority. No preservation master is claimed by this
public record for the five photographs.4
Response
These objections describe the group’s proper form. The five photographs remain five Works. The title is presented as a proposal-origin curatorial proposition, with its sources and limits visible. Each caption remains attributed; each archive discrepancy remains legible; Saman’s subject requires a safeguarding boundary; and any use beyond the Museum’s current credited institutional display, publication, and accessibility interpretation requires separate rights analysis. The publication continues to disclose the two Magnum 75 curations, the absence of a recorded endorsement of the resulting group, and the unresolved questions that materially affect interpretation.
The acquisition record would preserve the proposal’s five-object relation while keeping each Work’s title, caption, token manifestation, rights, provenance, and custody history separate. The relation becomes a curatorial hypothesis with a stable object list. It proposes a comparison among exact Works and makes no new classification. It asks how a photograph acquires historical weight through the relation among frame, caption, access, place, archive, and later circulation.
What accession makes possible
The accession supports exhibitions, object publications, and research into the afterlives of documentary photography in a networked edition. Its public value depends on keeping the individual histories intact. The Museum records donor authority, legal title, custody, and provenance separately for each token manifestation; applies the accession rights determination to ordinary credited institutional display, publication, and accessibility; and handles Saman’s photograph through an appropriate safeguarding boundary. New uses outside that scope require fresh rights analysis.
The intellectual work would continue after acceptance. New caption sheets, archive crosswalks, permission records, or artist and Magnum correspondence could change the account. Those changes should enter the publication as dated amendments while preserving the prior record.
Conflict at Its Edges enters the permanent Collection because its five photographs make the institutions around documentary evidence visible. Its value will depend on whether the Museum can hold the donor’s relation firmly enough to study and lightly enough to revise.
Footnotes
-
Exact Magnum 75 metadata and proposal record, S04–S05, S10–S14, and S37. ↩
-
Five Work records and caption/context sources, S10–S14, S19, S23–S25, S27–S32, and S41. ↩
-
Magnum Photos 75 project and ICP institutional history, S04, S10–S14, and S39. ↩
-
Rights, token, and historical Wave media records, S09, S10–S14, S37, and S38. ↩
Essay
*Conflict at Its Edges*
6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · Publication record and suggested citation
Five Photographs of Borders, Access, and Afterlives, 1952–2016
These five photographs show conflict at a remove from battle. David Seymour looks across a borderland. Larry Towell places armed men inside a church. Micha Bar-Am photographs a public dispute through smoke and a barrier. Moisés Saman records an apparently young person before a wall marked by an uncertain event. Lorenzo Meloni encounters a soldier among the ruins of Palmyra after destruction and military recapture.
Made between 1952 and 2016, the photographs move from open terrain to enclosed and monumental space. Each tests the point at which visible evidence runs into something supplied elsewhere: a border named in a caption, a history of armed presence, a contested right of access, an official claim that could not be verified, or a route controlled by military authority. Their later passage through books, archives, museums, metadata, and tokens adds another history to the one held in the frame.
The proposal brings the group together across two Magnum Photos 75 curations. Saman’s #44
is marked 1/; Seymour #127, Towell #145, Bar-Am #97, and Meloni #104 are
marked 2/. Those curation fields describe the upstream publication history
of each token. The five-work argument begins with their later conjunction.1
A border named from a distance
Seymour’s vertical black-and-white photograph begins with a figure turned away. A rifle rises from the lower edge along the body and points toward open country. A canvas shelter and a dark foreground mass occupy a narrow portion of the image; ridges recede toward a pale horizon.
The photograph gives the viewer terrain, posture, equipment, and distance. It withholds a border marker, map coordinate, flag, unit, and named incident. The caption supplies the Negev–Jordan border, while the landscape remains politically legible through scale and separation. The border exists in the relation between the administrative name and the image’s sparse physical evidence.
The estate’s public record offers a visually matching frame associated with the King Solomon’s Mines area. The Magnum archive reference is SED1952003W00003/; the estate filename has not been cross-indexed to it in a reviewed archival record. The 1949 Israel–Jordan General Armistice Agreement and United States Department of State records establish the frontier’s historical framework and 1952 incidents. They do not identify this patrol or settle the precise site.2
Seymour’s place in Magnum adds another afterlife. A founding-generation photographer whose postwar practice moved through war, displacement, children, and reconstruction, he made the individual figure carry political pressure without turning the body into a simple emblem. The selected frame begins the group with a border that must be inferred through the meeting of body, weapon, terrain, caption, and archive.
Armed presence in sacred architecture
Towell’s church interior changes the photograph’s scale. A crucifix fixes the upper centre, the altar and flowers occupy the lower centre, and two soldiers stand on either side of the central axis. Their rifles interrupt the building’s vertical order. Daylight enters through windows at both sides, giving the room depth and keeping the architecture active around the men.
The image offers a church, weapons, bodies, light, and a named place. It leaves the congregation, unit, operation, and exact church outside the frame. The issuer metadata spells the place “Suchitito”; other public records use “Suchitoto.” The difference shows how documentary place-names pass through successive systems of transcription, correction, and publication.
United Nations peace-process records provide the civil-war setting. They do not identify the church or Towell’s assignment. His long-form work in Nicaragua, Guatemala, and El Salvador gives the image a further duration through exhibitions, books, and testimony. The physical-print record for Soldiers in Church, Suchitoto, El Salvador offers a material comparison, while the public evidence has not completed the crosswalk between that print and the token-linked JPEG.3
The church therefore becomes an edge of access and authority. Armed men stand inside a sacred interior; the camera occupies a position from which the room can be measured; the caption supplies a regional history that the architecture alone cannot name.
Smoke, access, and the interrupted event
Bar-Am’s photograph is organized around obstruction. A figure moves through the middle distance, partly veiled by smoke. A canister hangs in the air. The Western Wall forms a dense horizontal background, while a metal structure crosses the lower edge like both foreground object and barrier.
The photograph makes an event visible through its interruption. Smoke opens and closes the central action. The moving figure remains partial. The wall identifies a sacred site, yet the image cannot name the exact day or person. The archive string BAM1989009W02477/ differs from the artist archive’s BAM1989009W02477-, and later museum records preserve title variants. The image’s public identity has accumulated through several cataloguing acts.
The issuer caption connects the frame to women’s Torah prayer and police smoke grenades. Women of the Wall’s own history supplies a situated account of the dispute over prayer, gender, and access at the Wall. That context sharpens the photograph’s social stakes while leaving the central person’s identity open. The image holds a religious site, a contested practice, and an obstructed view in the same field.4
Bar-Am’s broader practice moves between military experience, newspaper work, Magnum correspondence, and institution-building. He helped establish the International Center of Photography and founded the Tel Aviv Museum of Art’s photography department. That history explains the density of records now attached to the photograph. The frame itself remains more austere: a moving person, smoke, a canister, stone, and a metal barrier.
Marks beneath a qualified caption
Saman brings the group into a shallow interior. An apparently young person stands close to a pale wall beneath a caged lamp. Dark marks interrupt the wall’s surface. The lowered head keeps the body present while withholding a public identity. The wall occupies enough of the frame to resist becoming a backdrop.
The photograph shows marks, a lamp, a wall, and an apparently young person. It cannot establish the cause of the marks. The issuer metadata preserves two related statements: an official account says that the house was targeted by Western air strikes and that a woman was injured, while a separate account describes minders showing journalists evidence of strikes against civilian areas. The first account is explicitly marked impossible to verify. The second concerns what the minders presented. The two statements should remain distinct from the visible wall.
The conditions of access matter here. Saman’s Libya work was made within a press environment shaped by government management, confinement, escorts, and restricted movement. TIME and the Committee to Protect Journalists provide the surrounding record. The photographer’s access to a damaged interior was part of a managed field of information.5
Saman’s photograph therefore places caption authority beside visual evidence. Public description can remain with the person, wall, lamp, and marks. The reviewed public record supplies no age, identity, or consent documentation for the person shown. A fuller identification would require authoritative evidence and a responsible reason to publish it.
The ruin after destruction
Meloni’s colour photograph opens the field again. Pale rubble and surviving columns spread beneath a clear blue sky. A small seated soldier gathers the lower portion of the image, holding a helmet across his face. The gesture is obscured and difficult to read; the monument determines the image’s scale.
The contemporary caption dates the photograph to 1 April 2016 and identifies the figure as a Syrian army soldier seated on rubble associated with the former Temple of Bel. UNESCO records the temple’s principal destruction on 30 August 2015 and describes Palmyra after the March 2016 change of control, when access remained constrained and demining incomplete. The image was made months after the destruction and days after the recapture.6
TIME reports government permission and the shadowing of journalists by government forces. AFP describes an army minder, mine warnings, and entry directed by the army. Those accounts surround the frame with a route of access. The photograph’s apparent stillness is therefore joined to the conditions under which the ruins could be entered and photographed.
Meloni’s We Don’t Say Goodbye gathers a wider project across Iraq, Syria, and Libya and interrupts photographs with objects and writing recovered from rubble. The public record has not established that this frame appears in the book. The project nevertheless gives context to Meloni’s sustained attention to fragments, recurrence, and the historical uses of damaged sites. At Palmyra, a soldier’s obscured face keeps the scene between report, memorial, and controlled passage.
Two curations, one later relation
Magnum Photos 75 gives the group its upstream vocabulary. The archived launch material associates the first selection with Alejandro Cartagena. The second selection was presented in dialogue with Azu Nwagbogu and described through the idea of an “indecisive moment.” The token metadata places Saman’s #44 in 1/ and the other four works in 2/.7
That distribution is evidence of the individual tokens’ publication histories. It does not supply the donor’s reason for choosing these five. The proposal assembled a new relation across the registers. The reviewed public records contain no statement or evidence that Magnum Photos, either curator, or the artists endorsed the group.
This distinction matters because the group’s coherence is interpretive. Its title belongs to the Museum’s publication of a proposition first presented through the offer. Its five photographs retain their own authors, captions, archives, and political histories. The essay can place them beside one another while keeping their different forms of evidence intact.
The case and its limit
The case for the group lies in the specificity of its comparisons. Seymour’s border is named from beyond the frame. Towell’s church turns armed presence into a spatial problem. Bar-Am’s smoke makes access and visibility coincide. Saman’s marked wall exposes the gap between official narration and visible trace. Meloni’s ruin holds an unreadable gesture inside a controlled historical site.
The countercase remains substantial. The group may smooth differences among conflicts that demand separate histories. Its title may make damage appear as a shared aesthetic category. The upstream project’s curations had their own premises, and the donor’s relation overrides those original boundaries. Caption gaps, archive discrepancies, rights uncertainty, and Saman’s safeguarding condition limit the claims the group can make.
The response is a disciplined form of comparison. The five photographs can remain distinct while showing how documentary meaning travels through borders, access routes, captions, damaged sites, and later records. The group should be read as a revisable curatorial proposition, with its formation and limits stated alongside its argument.
Documentary afterlives
A photograph’s afterlife begins before the Museum sees it. It passes through an assignment, a caption, a negative, a print, a book, an exhibition, an estate, or an agency archive. Magnum Photos 75 adds token numbers, metadata objects, Arweave pointers, edition language, and transaction histories. Those records give the photographs a new technical route into public circulation.
The token-linked JPEGs remain upstream manifestations with photographer and Magnum All Rights Reserved notices. Token identity, legal title, copyright, display permission, preservation, and Museum custody remain separate records. The chain can stabilize an edition and its transfer history while leaving the archive-to-negative relation, first publication, and reproduction authority open.8
The historical Wave publication and token metadata remain part of that record.
Their artist and Magnum credits and All Rights Reserved notices travel with
every citation. The Museum has preserved their identity and context without
turning those sources into a claim of copyright, custody, or accession.8
The five photographs describe violence at its margins and show how documentary authority is made: by what enters the frame, by who grants access, by the words attached afterward, and by the institutions that keep an image in circulation. The catalogue keeps four layers distinct: what appears in the frame, what the contemporary caption adds, what later research establishes, and what remains unresolved.
Footnotes
-
Exact Magnum 75 metadata and proposal record, S04–S05, S10–S14, and S37. ↩
-
David Seymour estate, ICP, United Nations, and United States Department of State records, S18–S19 and S42–S43. ↩
-
Larry Towell, United Nations, exhibition, CV, library, and collection records, S11, S20–S21, S33, S45–S47, and S52. ↩
-
Micha Bar-Am archive, ICP, Museum Wales, and Women of the Wall records, S12, S22–S25, and S34. ↩
-
Moisés Saman metadata, biography, controlled-access reporting, and press-freedom context, S13 and S26–S29. ↩
-
Lorenzo Meloni, TIME, UNESCO, and AFP records, S14, S30–S32, and S41. ↩
-
Magnum 75 launch, second-release context, and exact token metadata, S04–S05 and S10–S14. ↩
-
Magnum terms, token metadata, proposal evidence, and historical Wave media record, S09, S10–S14, S37, and S38. ↩ ↩2
Work entry
David Seymour (Chim), *Patrolling the border between the Negev Desert and Jordan*
6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · Publication record and suggested citation
Short label: Border patrol, 1952 · Negev, Israel. Accessioned gift in the permanent Collection under 6529NM.; the Wave proposal remains part of the work’s recorded origin.
Looking at the Work
The photograph is black and white and vertically composed. A person occupies the lower foreground, seen from behind or in partial profile. The face is unavailable for identification. A long firearm, sling, or harness dominates the central foreground, with dark cropped forms entering at the lower edges.
Beyond the figure are a pale tent-like or canopy-like structure, open ground, loose rock, and layered, eroded hills. A thin vertical pole or line appears near the middle-left. The landscape recedes through tonal bands. No flag, border marker, map, insignia, unit marking, or named incident is legible in the image.
The rifle creates the strongest diagonal. It joins the body to the shelter and the distant terrain, making the figure’s direction of attention legible while leaving its object unseen. Dark rock, clothing, and firearm form a compact lower mass; the pale structure opens a narrow interval before the hills carry the eye toward the horizon.
Caption and archive record
The token record identifies the work as Patrolling the border between the Negev Desert and Jordan, 1952, and gives the Magnum archive reference SED1952003W00003/. Token metadata places the work in the Negev, Israel, as Magnum Photos 75 #127, edition 1/1, curation 2/.1
The David Seymour estate presents a visually matching frame as PAR116258. and captions it “The King Solomon’s Mines area, Israel, 1952.” The estate image and the token-linked JPEG share the same composition and visible arrangement. The public records provide a strong visual match. A reviewed crosswalk between PAR116258. and SED1952003W00003/ remains unavailable.2
The two captions carry different levels of place information. “Negev, Israel” is the token’s shorter location field. “The King Solomon’s Mines area” is the estate’s fuller description. Both should remain attributed to their sources. The exact site, coordinates, day, patrol route, and archive-number suffix semantics remain open.
Historical context
The 1949 Israel–Jordan General Armistice Agreement established an armistice demarcation line for the region. United States Department of State records describe frontier incidents and the unsettled character of the boundary in 1952.3 This history gives the border caption a substantial political setting.
The documents describe regional conditions. They do not identify the person, military unit, assignment, commissioner, or incident represented here. The photograph supplies a body in terrain; the caption and historical records supply the geopolitical frame. Those forms of evidence should remain adjacent without being merged.
Museum interpretation
Seymour makes the border present through absence. No line crosses the ground. The frontier appears through the armed figure’s stance, the direction of the rifle, the distance between the shelter and the hills, and the title attached to the image.
The turned body places the viewer behind the patrol. The figure’s face remains outside the encounter, while the landscape becomes the field of attention. This gives the photograph a quiet tension: the viewer sees the conditions of watchfulness and the object of watchfulness remains elsewhere.
The image also resists a simple heroic reading. The figure is small against the terrain, and the rifle functions as both equipment and compositional hinge. The landscape controls the scale. The human body establishes the viewpoint; the hills determine the image’s duration.
The estate’s fuller place caption introduces the phrase “King Solomon’s Mines area,” while the token record gives the broader Negev location. The distinction keeps the photograph’s historical geography open. It also shows how an archive can add specificity that the pixels cannot independently verify.
Within the selected five-Work group, Seymour supplies the earliest image and a founding-generation Magnum perspective. The work begins the sequence with a political edge that is felt through posture, terrain, and caption.
Record note
| Field | Current record |
|---|---|
| FieldToken identity | Current recordeip155:; Magnum Photos 75 #127; edition 1/1; curation 2/. S10 |
| FieldArchive reference | Current recordSED1952003W00003/. S10 |
| FieldToken-linked rendition | Current recordJPEG, 3,056 × 4,600 pixels, 2,518,674 observed bytes; SHA-256 65abf8b6. S10 |
| FieldMuseum status | Current recordCompleted gift; accessioned into the permanent Collection as 6529NM.. S37 |
| FieldCredit and rights | Current record© David Seymour/Magnum Photos 2022 · All Rights Reserved. The Museum interprets ordinary credited institutional display, publication, and accessibility in accession, Collection, and scholarship contexts as permissible. This does not transfer copyright or grant commercial or general reproduction, derivative, licensing, download, or AI-training rights. S10, S38 |
The exact assignment, first publication, negative, contact sheet, estate-to-Magnum crosswalk, and future rights authority remain research questions. The upstream JPEG is an observed token-linked rendition; the repository retains its URL and fixity record, with no original negative or preservation master.
Footnotes
Work entry
Larry Towell, *Government soldiers in a church, Suchitoto, El Salvador*
6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · Publication record and suggested citation
Short label: Soldiers in church, 1986 · Suchitoto, El Salvador. Accessioned gift in the permanent Collection under 6529NM.; the Wave proposal remains part of the work’s recorded origin.
Looking at the Work
Two armed soldiers stand inside a church beneath a large crucifix. They face the camera in the lower half of a nearly symmetrical interior. Each holds a rifle angled away from the body. Windows admit light from both sides, and flowers appear low near the altar.
The frontal viewpoint makes the room easy to measure. The crucifix establishes the central vertical axis; the soldiers divide the lower field; the rifles introduce diagonals that disturb the church’s architectural order. The windows create depth and prevent the interior from becoming a flat backdrop.
The image identifies a church, armed bodies, rifles, religious architecture, light, and flowers. It leaves the church name, soldiers’ identities, military unit, operation, congregation, and purpose unresolved. The linked JPEG is a token-related rendition and carries no condition assessment for a physical print or original negative.
Caption and archive record
The Museum’s preferred public title is Government soldiers in a church, Suchitoto, El Salvador, 1986. The token metadata uses the name “Magnum 75 #145 by Larry Towell. Suchitito, El Salvador. 1986,” with Location: and archive reference TOL1986003W00045/. The token records edition 1/1 and curation 2/.1
“Suchitoto” is supported by the Art Windsor-Essex and Stephen Bulger records. “Suchitito” remains the token’s exact source spelling. The Museum’s normalized form should appear with that source variant preserved in the caption history.2
The issuer caption places the scene near the Guazapa guerrilla stronghold and connects persecution of the Catholic Church to liberation theology. This is caption and agency language. The image itself supplies the church interior and armed presence; it cannot establish the building, operation, or scene-specific causal account.
Art Windsor-Essex records a related gelatin silver print as El Salvador Series 1986–1987 (Soldiers in Church, Suchitoto, El Salvador), 1986, collection number 2002., measuring 35.0 × 28.0 cm. The record gives a strong institutional comparison. Its public page does not publish the Magnum archive number, so the physical print and token-linked rendition remain separate records pending a crosswalk.3
Historical context
Towell’s Central American work includes Nicaragua, Guatemala, and El Salvador, with recurring attention to landlessness, disappearance, military power, and the social effects of conflict.4 The selected frame belongs to his 1986 El Salvador period.
Gifts of War, organized by the Art Gallery of Windsor, travelled from April 1988 through October 1989 and brought photographs and testimonies from Nicaragua, El Salvador, and Guatemala into a public exhibition sequence. Towell’s CV lists Gift of War from 1988 and El Salvador from 1997. The latter is recorded as a 127-page book with an introduction by Mark Danner.5
United Nations peace-accord records provide the broad civil-war and settlement chronology for reading the photograph. They do not identify this church, these soldiers, or the purpose of their presence.6 The work’s scene-specific history therefore remains attached to the issuer caption and the unresolved archive record.
Museum interpretation
Towell’s composition makes armed authority spatially measurable. The crucifix fixes the upper axis while the soldiers occupy the lower field. Their rifles extend the lines of military presence into a room organized around worship.
The frontal arrangement gives the scene the clarity of a stage. The viewer can compare the soldiers’ positions, follow the rifles toward the floor, and register the small flowers beneath the crucifix. The church remains fully legible as a devotional interior while the soldiers change the room’s social meaning.
This visual order carries historical tension without resolving the event. The photograph can hold a military presence inside sacred architecture while leaving the exact reason for that presence unknown. The caption supplies Guazapa, persecution, and liberation theology as an attributed historical account. The frame supplies the evidence of bodies, weapons, architecture, and light.
The related Art Windsor-Essex print deepens the object’s material history. A gelatin silver print, a book page, an exhibition installation, and a token-linked JPEG each produce a different encounter with the same possible photographic work. The records currently support relation and comparison. They do not prove identity across every manifestation.
Within the selected group, Towell follows Seymour’s open border landscape with an enclosed interior. The conflict edge has become architectural: a room, a community, and a sacred image carry the pressure of armed power.
Record note
| Field | Current record |
|---|---|
| FieldToken identity | Current recordeip155:; Magnum Photos 75 #145; edition 1/1; curation 2/. S11 |
| FieldArchive reference | Current recordTOL1986003W00045/. S11 |
| FieldToken-linked rendition | Current recordJPEG, 5,369 × 3,601 pixels, 1,813,285 observed bytes; SHA-256 e60f2d2c. S11 |
| FieldMuseum status | Current recordCompleted gift; accessioned into the permanent Collection as 6529NM.. S37 |
| FieldCredit and rights | Current record© Larry Towell/Magnum Photos 2022 · All Rights Reserved. The Museum interprets ordinary credited institutional display, publication, and accessibility in accession, Collection, and scholarship contexts as permissible. This does not transfer copyright or grant commercial or general reproduction, derivative, licensing, download, or AI-training rights. S11, S38 |
The church identity, soldiers and unit, operation, assignment, first publication, archive-neighbor sequence, physical-print equivalence, spelling history, and future rights authority remain open research questions.
Footnotes
Work entry
Micha Bar-Am, *Demonstration, Western Wall, Jerusalem*
6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · Publication record and suggested citation
Short label: Demonstration, 1989 · Western Wall, Jerusalem. Accessioned gift
in the permanent Collection under 6529NM.; the Wave proposal remains
part of the work’s recorded origin.
Looking at the Work
The photograph is organized around an interruption. A person moves through the middle distance, partly veiled by smoke; a canister hangs in the air; the stone wall holds the background in a dense horizontal plane. At the lower edge, a metal menorah-like structure cuts across the scene. It locates the image at a religious site while also acting as a barrier between camera and event.
The black-and-white tones do not settle into a single field. Pale smoke opens and closes the central action, dark clothing and hardware pull the eye toward the moving figure, and the wall returns the scene to architecture. The photograph is legible as a confrontation through motion, smoke, and the barrier, yet its human subject remains partial. The image shows a person, airborne canister, smoke, stone, and metal structure. These visible elements do not name the person, identify the canister's contents, or establish the exact day.
That uncertainty is formal as well as historical. The central figure is the place where the image seems to promise an event and withholds a complete account. Bar-Am's composition lets the public setting remain visible while the action breaks into fragments. The photograph makes the conditions of visibility inseparable from any account supplied by its caption.
Bar-Am's practice and institutions
Bar-Am's photographic career passes through military experience, newspaper work, Magnum correspondence, and institution-building. Magnum's official profile records his 1948 service, work during the Sinai and Six-Day Wars, and correspondent status from 1968.1 Its published biography is selective: it names major bodies of work and institutional roles without supplying a complete assignment chronology or a full award list.
His relation to institutions is part of the practice's history. Bar-Am helped Cornell Capa establish the International Center of Photography and later established the Tel Aviv Museum of Art photography department. Magnum's profile gives the curatorial period as 1977–1993; the Micha Bar-Am Archive describes service through 1992 and dates the Enrique Kavlin Lifetime Achievement Award separately to 1993.2 The two statements remain attributed to their sources. ICP's Israel Diary, 1956–1982 places his earlier work within a sustained record of the changing modern state, through national events and everyday life.3
Bar-Am has also described the difficulty of being a participant, observer, witness, and interpreter at once.1 That published statement supplies a practice lens for this photograph, not an intention statement about this exposure. The work's smoke and partial figure make the tension between presence and distance visible without assigning the central person a role.
Caption history and the 1989 setting
The token metadata names the image Demonstration, Western Wall, Jerusalem, 1989, and gives archive string BAM1989009W02477/26C. The artist archive gives BAM1989009W02477-26; ICP carries the same concise title and year; Museum Wales preserves the historical title variant “Western Wall (Wailing Wall), Jerusalem.”4 The shared archive stem is a strong comparison lead. No public record explains the suffix difference or provides a scene-specific day and participant.
The issuer caption connects the frame to women's Torah prayer and police smoke grenades. Women of the Wall's own history supplies a situated account of the 1988–1989 dispute over prayer, access, and religious authority.5 That history gives the image a social setting. It does not establish that this exposure records a particular March event or identify the central person. The public description remains with smoke and an airborne canister; it does not turn either into a more specific material or chemical claim.
The Work in the selected offer
Bar-Am's Work is one of four tokens identified as curation 2/
(S12). In the
selected offer it is the point at which documentary visibility becomes a
question of public access: the frame contains a sacred site, a moving body,
and a barrier that is both visual foreground and social object. Its exact
archive suffix and event history remain open, so its significance rests on
the documented photograph, the attributed caption, and the observable place
within this five-token offer. A rationale beyond that grouping has not
been recorded.
Manifestations and stewardship
| Aspect | Current record |
|---|---|
| AspectUnderlying photographic Work | Current recordThe 1989 photograph identified through the token, artist-archive, ICP, and Museum Wales records; the exact exposure date, assignment, and archive suffix relation remain unresolved. |
| AspectToken-linked JPEG | Current recordThe Arweave JPEG linked from token 97: 5,000 × 3,292 pixels, 1,666,083 observed bytes, SHA-256 a59d8624c8da11758c5f1c0b64484229e4ffb68167b8e5783cdbafa9628b74df. |
| AspectHistorical Wave-upload presentation | Current recordThe exact CloudFront upload used in the historical Wave work part is recorded in the Source and rights record. Its public reference is limited to the selected offer's proposal context (S38). |
| AspectPreservation and master status | Current recordThe token-linked JPEG is a recorded upstream rendition, not a declared negative, print master, or preservation master. The artist archive and museum print records describe other manifestations; no completed preservation package or rights-cleared repository derivative is recorded (S38). |
| AspectMuseum status | Current recordCompleted gift; accessioned into the permanent Collection as 6529NM.. S37 |
| AspectCredit and rights | Current record© Micha Bar-Am/Magnum Photos 2022 · All Rights Reserved. The Museum interprets ordinary credited institutional display, publication, and accessibility in accession, Collection, and scholarship contexts as permissible. This does not transfer copyright or grant commercial or general reproduction, derivative, licensing, download, or AI-training rights. S12; S38 |
Further research
Request the archive crosswalk for BAM1989009W02477, the meaning of 26C and -26, any caption sheet or contact sheet, the exact event date and assignment, and the rights terms for future Museum use. Any sensitive identity information remains restricted unless a responsible public form is documented.
Footnotes
-
Magnum Photos official Bar-Am profile and published practice statement, source S22. ↩ ↩2
-
Magnum institutional profile and Micha Bar-Am Archive press release, sources S22 and S44. ↩
-
International Center of Photography exhibition record, source S50. ↩
-
Direct token metadata, artist archive, ICP, and Museum Wales records, sources S12 and S23–S25. ↩
Work entry
Moisés Saman, *Tripoli, Libya*
6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · Publication record and suggested citation
Short label: Tripoli, 2011 · Libya. Accessioned gift in the permanent
Collection under 6529NM.; the Wave proposal remains part of the
work’s recorded origin.
Looking at the Work
An apparently young person stands close to a pale wall with the head lowered. A caged lamp hangs above, while many dark marks interrupt the wall's surface. The frame holds the figure and the wall in a shallow, almost frontal space. The lamp is the clearest architectural object; its grid repeats the wall's small marks and turns the upper corner into a measured counterweight to the body below.
The shallow space brings figure and wall into close relation, but its evidence is difficult to interpret. The wall carries dark marks or staining; the photograph alone cannot identify their cause. The lowered head makes the figure present without providing a public identity. That combination of visible surface and withheld biography is part of the work's ethical and formal condition.
The frame also divides attention between a person and a site. The figure is small enough to be read as a figure in a room, yet the wall occupies most of the image and refuses to become background. The photograph keeps visual description apart from the account attached to it. Its historical weight arrives through a caption and access history that must remain separate from the marks themselves.
Saman's practice and controlled access
Saman's work grew from conflict reporting into longer documentary inquiries about memory, aftermath, and the limits of photographic explanation. The official Magnum fine-print biography describes his early response to Balkan war imagery, his reporting across the Middle East and elsewhere, and his full membership in Magnum from 2014.1 World Press Photo records his earlier work for Newsday, Afghanistan and Iraq reporting, and that he joined Magnum in 2010.2 The two dates describe different stages: joining the agency in 2010 and full membership in 2014.
The 2011 Tripoli work was made in a press environment shaped by government management of foreign journalists. The retained TIME research excerpt describes Saman's assignment, confinement of foreign reporters at the Rixos Hotel, and movement under government-minder supervision; CPJ records the wider pattern of restricted movement and attacks on the press.3 These accounts establish a condition of access around the work. They do not identify the pictured house, the person, or the cause of the wall marks.
Saman's later practice gives this photograph a further context without rewriting its 2011 circumstances. WARM's record of Discordia describes a 2011–2014 project across the Arab Spring's sites, published as a 2016 book and shown in festival contexts; its sequences deliberately carry uncertainty and gaps in language.4 The relation is one of practice and publication history, not proof that this exact frame appears in that book or exhibition.
Caption history and safeguarding
The issuer caption makes two separate statements. One metadata passage says that the house was targeted by Western air strikes and that one woman was injured; it attributes that account to government officials and says the claim was impossible to verify. A separate passage says that minders showed journalists evidence of strikes targeting civilian areas.5 The second statement concerns what the minders presented; it does not verify the first account or establish the cause of the marks in this image.
The public description therefore names only the visible figure, wall, lamp, and marks. It gives no name, age, biography, house identifier, weapon attribution, or later-life account. The issuer's raw spelling is Moises Saman; this Museum display uses Moisés Saman while retaining the raw spelling in the structured record. Any identity, age, consent documentation, safeguarding record, or sensitive location material belongs in restricted research and rights records, not in a public identification exercise.
The Work in the selected offer
Saman's token is the one selected Work identified in the project metadata as
curation 1/; the other four are identified as curation 2/
(S13; S10–S14). That exact split
is the observable contribution of this Work to the offer. Its more difficult
contribution is ethical: the selected five-token unit brings a vulnerable
depicted subject into a public research corpus whose caption is itself
qualified. The public page can preserve that condition without attempting to
identify the depicted person. The rationale beyond the grouping is unrecorded.
Manifestations and stewardship
| Aspect | Current record |
|---|---|
| AspectUnderlying photographic Work | Current recordThe 2011 photograph identified by the issuer title, Tripoli location, and archive reference SAM2011005H2503/5482. The exact day, house, assignment, and safeguarding record remain unresolved. |
| AspectToken-linked JPEG | Current recordThe Arweave JPEG linked from token 44: 5,616 × 3,744 pixels, 1,540,870 observed bytes, SHA-256 cf1ec75dc4e3de3bcd85cffd9954c75395d9af2bff38374468440e403352b816. |
| AspectHistorical Wave-upload presentation | Current recordThe exact CloudFront upload used in the historical Wave work part is recorded in the Source and rights record. Its public reference is limited to the selected offer's proposal context and the non-identifying display rule (S38). |
| AspectPreservation and master status | Current recordThe token-linked JPEG is an upstream rendition, not a declared negative, print master, or preservation master. The reviewed public record contains no source negative, consent documentation, rights-cleared repository derivative, or completed preservation package (S38). |
| AspectMuseum status | Current recordCompleted gift; accessioned into the permanent Collection as 6529NM.. S37 |
| AspectCredit and rights | Current record© Moisés Saman/Magnum Photos 2022 · All Rights Reserved. The Museum interprets ordinary credited institutional display, publication, and accessibility in accession, Collection, and scholarship contexts as permissible. This does not transfer copyright or grant commercial or general reproduction, derivative, licensing, download, or AI-training rights; safeguarding and consent questions remain separately recorded. S13; S38 |
Further research
Further research should seek the exact date and house record, field notes, caption history, and permissions for the token-linked file. Any future public identification would require authoritative evidence and a responsible reason to publish it.
Footnotes
Work entry
Lorenzo Meloni, *Palmyra, Syria*
6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · Publication record and suggested citation
Short label: Palmyra, Syria · 1 April 2016. Accessioned gift in the permanent Collection under 6529NM.; the Wave proposal remains part of the work’s recorded origin.
Looking at the Work
A small seated figure occupies the middle of the frame. He wears a dark uniform and raises a helmet across his face, while pale rubble and standing columns extend around him. The gesture is obscured and difficult to read. The helmet may be in the act of being removed; the image gives no decisive access to the figure’s expression or state.
Colour organizes the photograph through a restrained opposition. The blue sky opens the upper field, warm stone carries the middle distance, and the dark figure gathers the eye near the base of the surviving architecture. The columns provide scale. They make the soldier appear temporary within a site whose history exceeds the immediate scene.
The photograph holds two kinds of attention together. The body supplies a pause, an action that remains psychologically unresolved. The ruins supply a historical duration. The frame offers rubble, columns, helmet, uniform, and sky with considerable clarity. Its explanation arrives through the caption and the circumstances of access that surround it.
Caption and chronology
The token record identifies the work as Palmyra, Syria, 2016, with Magnum archive reference MEL2016002G0401/. A TIME report published on 7 April 2016 dates the exposure to 1 April and identifies the figure in its caption as a Syrian army soldier seated on rubble associated with the former Temple of Bel.1 The caption supplies the date, affiliation, and site history; the image itself cannot establish the soldier’s identity, rank, unit, or route.
UNESCO records the destruction of the principal structure of the Temple of Bel on 30 August 2015. Its later assessment describes Palmyra after the change of control in March 2016, with access constrained and demining incomplete. The photograph therefore belongs to a precise historical interval: five days after the recapture of Palmyra, months after the destruction of the temple’s principal structure, and before the site had become safe or fully accessible.2
The distinction matters. The frame records neither the temple’s destruction nor the recapture battle. It records a site after both events, when surviving architecture, military presence, and photographic access had entered the same view. The standing columns refuse a total image of disappearance. The damaged monument remains materially present, even as its political and cultural meaning has been altered.
Access as part of the image
TIME reports that Meloni’s visit took place with Syrian government permission and under the shadow of government forces. An AFP account from the same period describes an army minder, mine warnings, demining, and entry directed by the army. These reports describe the published conditions of access; they do not reconstruct the exact route taken for this frame.3
Access still changes the photograph’s meaning. The soldier, the columns, and the rubble were encountered through a controlled passage into a mined historical site. The camera’s position was part of that arrangement. The resulting image carries the apparent stillness of the gesture alongside the political conditions that made the view possible.
A practice of aftermath
The work belongs to Meloni’s sustained study of conflict and its consequences. The Collapse of the Caliphate placed Palmyra beside Kobanê, Sirte, and Mosul in a project shaped by territorial change and historical recurrence. We Don’t Say Goodbye gathers a decade of work across Iraq, Syria, and Libya and interrupts photographs with objects and writing recovered from war rubble. In both cases, the image remains connected to material and textual traces that survive the event.4
The Palmyra frame gives that method a concentrated form. The soldier’s obscured face keeps the scene away from a legible portrait. The damaged site enlarges the gesture without explaining it. The photograph becomes an account of how a historical place is encountered after violence, under permission, and through the records that later name what the frame cannot fully contain.
Object record
| Field | Record |
|---|---|
| FieldPublic Work | Record6529NM- |
| FieldProposal alias | Record6529NM- |
| FieldArtist | RecordLorenzo Meloni |
| FieldDate / place | Record1 April 2016; Palmyra, Syria |
| FieldArchive reference | RecordMEL2016002G0401/ |
| FieldChain identity | Recordeip155: |
| FieldToken manifestation | RecordEthereum ERC-721 token 104; sequence 104/; curation 2/; edition 1 of 1 (S14) |
| FieldMetadata | RecordGoverned token metadata record S14 |
| FieldToken-linked source image | RecordExact URI retained in governed machine evidence; no direct visitor link |
| FieldObserved source image | RecordJPEG, 5,964 × 4,768 px, 16,871,807 bytes; SHA-256 49c45762 |
| FieldHistorical Wave presentation | RecordWave proposal, part 6; exact media locator retained in governed machine evidence and described in the Source and rights record (S38) |
| FieldStatus | RecordCompleted gift; accessioned into the permanent Collection as 6529NM. (S37) |
| FieldCredit / rights | Record© Lorenzo Meloni/Magnum Photos 2022 · All Rights Reserved. The Museum interprets ordinary credited institutional display, publication, and accessibility in accession, Collection, and scholarship contexts as permissible. This does not transfer copyright or grant commercial or general reproduction, derivative, licensing, download, or AI-training rights (S14; S38) |
Manifestations and stewardship
The underlying Work is the historical photograph made by Lorenzo Meloni in Palmyra on 1 April 2016. The Arweave JPEG is an upstream token-linked presentation/source file, not a declared negative or preservation master. The repository retains no source bytes or preservation master. The observed 16.9 MB source remains an upstream evidence locator and is not served by the Museum.
The historical CloudFront URL remains evidence of public Wave presentation
media. The accessioned presentation may render in accession, Collection,
artist, Work, and scholarship contexts under the current display authority,
with its supplied credit and All Rights Reserved notice. The Museum's
interpretation covers ordinary credited institutional display, publication,
and accessibility in those contexts; it does not grant copyright, commercial or
general reproduction, derivative, licensing, download, or AI-training rights
(S38).
Meloni’s image is the fifth work in the selected group Conflict at Its Edges. Its chronological position and 2/ curation mark are exact features of the token record. Its interpretation within the group remains a Museum argument about borders, access, damaged sites, captions, and documentary afterlives.
Research status
Further research should seek the archive-to-negative and contact-sheet crosswalk, the exact sequence and first publication, documentation of permission and route, and any authoritative account of the soldier’s identity. The public sources establish the captioned circumstances of the photograph while leaving those object-level questions open.
Footnotes
Acquisition record and sources
Method
Gift
Acquisition program
Gift AcquisitionsWorks in this acquisition
5 works
Source record
Accession certificate: Conflict at Its Edges
Accession certificate: Conflict at Its Edges
# Accession certificate: Conflict at Its Edges Accession lot: 6529NM.2026.002 Acquisition: Gift from punk6529 Works: Five Current status: Accessioned into the permanent Collection The 6529 Network Museum has completed the accession of five photographs from Magnum Photos 75. Presented together as Conflict at Its Edges, they form a coherent group about documentary evidence: the border, the aftermath, the caption, and the uncertainty that remains beyond an image's frame. The donor's full-gift offer and the Museum maintainer's completion instruction form the institutional basis for acceptance. The five transfer receipts, Transfer logs, and owner observations are preserved in the finalized custody evidence and bound to this certificate. The common custody observation is Ethereum block 25741809, hash 0x8581c55db52accfd3750ec3af9972430fd4717f3486ac51bc7c1e0b00c335731, timestamp 2026-08-12T22:08:23Z. The individual receipt transactions, blocks, log indexes, and token identities appear on each object page. Copyright remains separate from the accession. The source records credit each photographer and Magnum Photos and state All Rights Reserved. As with works held by other museums, the Museum interprets ownership as permitting ordinary, credited institutional display and publication in the accession context. This position does not claim copyright, commercial reproduction, derivative, licensing, or AI-training rights. See the title and rights review, technical and condition review, and gift authorization for the supporting record.
Source record
Curatorial accession review: Conflict at Its Edges
Curatorial accession review: Conflict at Its Edges
# Curatorial accession review: Conflict at Its Edges Conflict at Its Edges brings together five photographs from Magnum Photos 75: David Seymour's patrol at the Negev border; Larry Towell's soldiers in a church in Suchitoto; Micha Bar-Am's demonstration at the Western Wall; Moisés Saman's damaged room in Tripoli; and Lorenzo Meloni's view of Palmyra after its recapture. The group moves across decades and geographies, but its coherence is not simply the presence of conflict. It is the way each image tests the distance between an event and its representation. The photographs attend to edges: territorial borders, a threshold between military presence and religious space, the crowd and the wall, a room after an air strike, and a site encountered after destruction. Their subjects are not offered as interchangeable evidence or as a complete history of any conflict. The group asks what a photograph can establish, what its caption supplies, and what remains beyond the frame. The Museum has accessioned the five works as one coherent curatorial group. The individual object records preserve the source captions, artist credits, technical observations, and unresolved claims. Together they form an accession that can be studied as a set without collapsing the differences among the photographers, assignments, places, and moments.
Source record
Gift acceptance and accession authorization
Gift acceptance and accession authorization
# Gift acceptance and accession authorization The 6529 Network Museum records the five Magnum Photos 75 photographs in Conflict at Its Edges as a completed gift from punk6529 and admits them to the permanent Collection under accession lot 6529NM.2026.002. The title basis is the donor's full-gift offer together with the Museum maintainer's completion instruction, corroborated by the five on-chain delivery receipts. The public record does not cite a separate private instrument. The photographs remain All Rights Reserved; the gift transfers the tokenized objects and the donor's transferable interest, not copyright. The accession certificate, title and rights review, technical record, and finalized custody evidence provide the supporting record. Continuing rights, preservation, and provenance work belongs to the Museum's ongoing stewardship of the accession.
Source record
Conflict at Its Edges: accession completion
Conflict at Its Edges: accession completion
# Conflict at Its Edges: accession completion The 6529 Network Museum has accepted and accessioned the five-work gift from punk6529 into the permanent Collection under 6529NM.2026.002. The decision rests on the donor's full-gift offer and the Museum maintainer's completion instruction. The five transfer receipts and the common finalized Ethereum observation are recorded in the accession certificate and custody evidence. The title record covers the donor's transferable interest in the tokenized objects. The source photographs remain credited to their artists and Magnum Photos and are All Rights Reserved; copyright and reproduction permission remain separate from Collection membership.
Source record
presentation-manifest
presentation-manifest
{
"$schema": "../../../../schemas/accession-media-presentation.schema.json",
"record_control": {
"revision": 1,
"record_status": "constructed",
"constructor": {
"actor_id": "codex-task:museum-responsive-magnum-2026-08-13",
"role": "constructor",
"constructed_at": "2026-08-13T12:40:00Z"
},
"review": null
},
"record_type": "ACCESSION_MEDIA_PRESENTATION",
"schema_profile": "6529NM_ACCESSION_MEDIA_PRESENTATION_V1",
"accession_lot_id": "6529NM.2026.002",
"generated_at": "2026-08-13T12:40:00Z",
"transform": {
"profile": "6529NM_WEB_PRESENTATION_WEBP_V2_Q82_M6_FIXED_ICC",
"implementation": "Pillow 12.3.0",
"format": "image/webp",
"quality": 82,
"method": 6,
"widths": [
640,
1280,
2400
],
"resize_filter": "Lanczos",
"upscale": false,
"orientation": "EXIF transpose before resize",
"colour_management": "embedded profiles converted to sRGB; untagged sources treated as sRGB; sRGB profile embedded in derivatives",
"icc_profile_sha256": "sha256:4ed6f6f05df0d17516662c5fe06ac90e14e0c1936abd15a491b57998c56aef86",
"metadata": "source EXIF/XMP stripped; output sRGB ICC profile retained"
},
"delivery": {
"status": "approved_for_contextual_museum_display",
"authority_record_id": "6529NM.2026.002.DISPLAY-01",
"authority_path": "records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/public/web-presentation-authority.md",
"cdn_base_url": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net",
"cache_control": "public, max-age=31536000, immutable",
"key_profile": "museum/accessions/{accession_lot_id}/{work_entity_id}/{source_sha256}/{transform_profile}/{width}.webp",
"overwrite_policy": "fail if an existing key does not contain the declared bytes"
},
"rights_boundary": {
"status": "All Rights Reserved; contextual Museum display only",
"source_originals": "The exact Arweave source remains the recorded source object and is not replaced by these delivery surrogates.",
"technical_transformation": "Proportion-preserving resize, sRGB normalization, and WebP compression for browser delivery; no crop, watermark, retouching, or content alteration.",
"no_general_reuse": "The manifest grants no download, commercial, derivative, licensing, AI-training, or general reproduction right."
},
"items": [
{
"work_entity_id": "6529NM-W-0024",
"media_reference_entity_id": "6529NM-MED-0003",
"source": {
"role": "fixity_verified_token_source",
"url": "https://arweave.net/VE0zO2N1zVTsbEUHdUFazEgvuMbmVOi6OfaWfQOWkaM",
"mime_type": "image/jpeg",
"sha256": "sha256:65abf8b6a182bb641787a43b40d10f0b6471357e5c90777aacccf9eb73ea1453",
"byte_size": 2518674,
"pixel_width": 3056,
"pixel_height": 4600,
"exif_orientation_applied": false,
"colour_profile_status": "untagged_assumed_srgb"
},
"presentation": {
"role": "web_presentation_surrogate",
"alt_text": "Vertical black-and-white photograph of a back-facing armed figure and rifle overlooking a canvas shelter in a rocky desert valley.",
"alt_text_status": "reviewed_accessibility_description",
"public_widths": [
640,
1280,
2400
],
"derivatives": [
{
"width": 640,
"height": 963,
"mime_type": "image/webp",
"sha256": "sha256:e9581c1dcf487d78bd22eddee27671ea938e712242e04f72895e608e19cca60d",
"byte_size": 127650,
"repository_path": "media/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0024/65abf8b6a182bb641787a43b40d10f0b6471357e5c90777aacccf9eb73ea1453/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/640.webp",
"url": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/museum/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0024/65abf8b6a182bb641787a43b40d10f0b6471357e5c90777aacccf9eb73ea1453/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/640.webp",
"cache_control": "public, max-age=31536000, immutable"
},
{
"width": 1280,
"height": 1927,
"mime_type": "image/webp",
"sha256": "sha256:042f239d5b6147fd7cb61557a38a96615a9c1a4962dbfe66fb6a79190e0a0365",
"byte_size": 509104,
"repository_path": "media/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0024/65abf8b6a182bb641787a43b40d10f0b6471357e5c90777aacccf9eb73ea1453/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/1280.webp",
"url": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/museum/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0024/65abf8b6a182bb641787a43b40d10f0b6471357e5c90777aacccf9eb73ea1453/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/1280.webp",
"cache_control": "public, max-age=31536000, immutable"
},
{
"width": 2400,
"height": 3613,
"mime_type": "image/webp",
"sha256": "sha256:bc659438e8e4e43b57164e7dcc763ad1979dea111d34d75e6d48ddd4b9f781da",
"byte_size": 1613182,
"repository_path": "media/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0024/65abf8b6a182bb641787a43b40d10f0b6471357e5c90777aacccf9eb73ea1453/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/2400.webp",
"url": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/museum/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0024/65abf8b6a182bb641787a43b40d10f0b6471357e5c90777aacccf9eb73ea1453/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/2400.webp",
"cache_control": "public, max-age=31536000, immutable"
}
]
}
},
{
"work_entity_id": "6529NM-W-0025",
"media_reference_entity_id": "6529NM-MED-0041",
"source": {
"role": "fixity_verified_token_source",
"url": "https://arweave.net/r0bUW6Mtxq897pgig0V01Ad43S_Ldwv3tARjwmjrqpE",
"mime_type": "image/jpeg",
"sha256": "sha256:e60f2d2c56b702981597606315c6c77e07dedf4dd9a95804ae2da720d0f5bcee",
"byte_size": 1813285,
"pixel_width": 5369,
"pixel_height": 3601,
"exif_orientation_applied": false,
"colour_profile_status": "untagged_assumed_srgb"
},
"presentation": {
"role": "web_presentation_surrogate",
"alt_text": "Black-and-white photograph of two armed soldiers standing symmetrically inside a church beneath a large crucifix.",
"alt_text_status": "reviewed_accessibility_description",
"public_widths": [
640,
1280,
2400
],
"derivatives": [
{
"width": 640,
"height": 429,
"mime_type": "image/webp",
"sha256": "sha256:0cdab53aeaddd9c5396a023330def5f6a395a2514fc0d36864433dc9a87f1a88",
"byte_size": 22990,
"repository_path": "media/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0025/e60f2d2c56b702981597606315c6c77e07dedf4dd9a95804ae2da720d0f5bcee/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/640.webp",
"url": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/museum/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0025/e60f2d2c56b702981597606315c6c77e07dedf4dd9a95804ae2da720d0f5bcee/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/640.webp",
"cache_control": "public, max-age=31536000, immutable"
},
{
"width": 1280,
"height": 858,
"mime_type": "image/webp",
"sha256": "sha256:3b6e75ae41658576728eb1978362bbd01b5d63c5e43b53c18cfbc64000063d89",
"byte_size": 74386,
"repository_path": "media/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0025/e60f2d2c56b702981597606315c6c77e07dedf4dd9a95804ae2da720d0f5bcee/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/1280.webp",
"url": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/museum/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0025/e60f2d2c56b702981597606315c6c77e07dedf4dd9a95804ae2da720d0f5bcee/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/1280.webp",
"cache_control": "public, max-age=31536000, immutable"
},
{
"width": 2400,
"height": 1610,
"mime_type": "image/webp",
"sha256": "sha256:07a2177a15b5fb2eb28531d8684440f5f4767311338c59f28fcdb715d34b6720",
"byte_size": 233184,
"repository_path": "media/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0025/e60f2d2c56b702981597606315c6c77e07dedf4dd9a95804ae2da720d0f5bcee/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/2400.webp",
"url": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/museum/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0025/e60f2d2c56b702981597606315c6c77e07dedf4dd9a95804ae2da720d0f5bcee/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/2400.webp",
"cache_control": "public, max-age=31536000, immutable"
}
]
}
},
{
"work_entity_id": "6529NM-W-0026",
"media_reference_entity_id": "6529NM-MED-0042",
"source": {
"role": "fixity_verified_token_source",
"url": "https://arweave.net/vRmOcFJRTK84ILXp2Tkjz5KoS4iXXbMqki7rxhTYlr4",
"mime_type": "image/jpeg",
"sha256": "sha256:a59d8624c8da11758c5f1c0b64484229e4ffb68167b8e5783cdbafa9628b74df",
"byte_size": 1666083,
"pixel_width": 5000,
"pixel_height": 3292,
"exif_orientation_applied": false,
"colour_profile_status": "embedded_profile_converted_to_srgb"
},
"presentation": {
"role": "web_presentation_surrogate",
"alt_text": "Black-and-white photograph of a person running through smoke at the Western Wall, with a canister in the air and a metal menorah barrier in the foreground.",
"alt_text_status": "reviewed_accessibility_description",
"public_widths": [
640,
1280,
2400
],
"derivatives": [
{
"width": 640,
"height": 421,
"mime_type": "image/webp",
"sha256": "sha256:309c2e6c1596e24b80c724fb6e2efc8559af407b73bed69739f42308c9aeda21",
"byte_size": 47316,
"repository_path": "media/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0026/a59d8624c8da11758c5f1c0b64484229e4ffb68167b8e5783cdbafa9628b74df/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/640.webp",
"url": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/museum/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0026/a59d8624c8da11758c5f1c0b64484229e4ffb68167b8e5783cdbafa9628b74df/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/640.webp",
"cache_control": "public, max-age=31536000, immutable"
},
{
"width": 1280,
"height": 843,
"mime_type": "image/webp",
"sha256": "sha256:6b1d0ff6dba21cab172942980d750071651afde187681686986c594a59afff47",
"byte_size": 169952,
"repository_path": "media/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0026/a59d8624c8da11758c5f1c0b64484229e4ffb68167b8e5783cdbafa9628b74df/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/1280.webp",
"url": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/museum/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0026/a59d8624c8da11758c5f1c0b64484229e4ffb68167b8e5783cdbafa9628b74df/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/1280.webp",
"cache_control": "public, max-age=31536000, immutable"
},
{
"width": 2400,
"height": 1580,
"mime_type": "image/webp",
"sha256": "sha256:1b1a247c35ea86fcc9273a17de91d271921954043f6d81f898c0547390651ce2",
"byte_size": 427228,
"repository_path": "media/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0026/a59d8624c8da11758c5f1c0b64484229e4ffb68167b8e5783cdbafa9628b74df/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/2400.webp",
"url": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/museum/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0026/a59d8624c8da11758c5f1c0b64484229e4ffb68167b8e5783cdbafa9628b74df/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/2400.webp",
"cache_control": "public, max-age=31536000, immutable"
}
]
}
},
{
"work_entity_id": "6529NM-W-0027",
"media_reference_entity_id": "6529NM-MED-0043",
"source": {
"role": "fixity_verified_token_source",
"url": "https://arweave.net/zLifpzu3AQWqjg59nuy9jeRqHPA5o5-LpwwBqNRcD5o",
"mime_type": "image/jpeg",
"sha256": "sha256:cf1ec75dc4e3de3bcd85cffd9954c75395d9af2bff38374468440e403352b816",
"byte_size": 1540870,
"pixel_width": 5616,
"pixel_height": 3744,
"exif_orientation_applied": false,
"colour_profile_status": "embedded_profile_converted_to_srgb"
},
"presentation": {
"role": "web_presentation_surrogate",
"alt_text": "Black-and-white photograph of an apparently young person standing with head lowered before a white wall marked by many dark spots, beneath a caged lamp.",
"alt_text_status": "reviewed_accessibility_description",
"public_widths": [
640,
1280,
2400
],
"derivatives": [
{
"width": 640,
"height": 427,
"mime_type": "image/webp",
"sha256": "sha256:07ca71fb0b6efab5b64a644e08380476d341725fe64338ceeffedae13fac34b2",
"byte_size": 22946,
"repository_path": "media/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0027/cf1ec75dc4e3de3bcd85cffd9954c75395d9af2bff38374468440e403352b816/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/640.webp",
"url": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/museum/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0027/cf1ec75dc4e3de3bcd85cffd9954c75395d9af2bff38374468440e403352b816/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/640.webp",
"cache_control": "public, max-age=31536000, immutable"
},
{
"width": 1280,
"height": 853,
"mime_type": "image/webp",
"sha256": "sha256:63bb715f267d29d0a23e3b99585c7e9c6fd0c9778ff986b0771e7af9c20fcafd",
"byte_size": 73324,
"repository_path": "media/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0027/cf1ec75dc4e3de3bcd85cffd9954c75395d9af2bff38374468440e403352b816/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/1280.webp",
"url": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/museum/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0027/cf1ec75dc4e3de3bcd85cffd9954c75395d9af2bff38374468440e403352b816/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/1280.webp",
"cache_control": "public, max-age=31536000, immutable"
},
{
"width": 2400,
"height": 1600,
"mime_type": "image/webp",
"sha256": "sha256:d27d789961c3a9883c3ae71f14ccccdf9170876e3301b1dcccda473ebd0fe327",
"byte_size": 187066,
"repository_path": "media/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0027/cf1ec75dc4e3de3bcd85cffd9954c75395d9af2bff38374468440e403352b816/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/2400.webp",
"url": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/museum/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0027/cf1ec75dc4e3de3bcd85cffd9954c75395d9af2bff38374468440e403352b816/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/2400.webp",
"cache_control": "public, max-age=31536000, immutable"
}
]
}
},
{
"work_entity_id": "6529NM-W-0028",
"media_reference_entity_id": "6529NM-MED-0044",
"source": {
"role": "fixity_verified_token_source",
"url": "https://arweave.net/oz0t0DJj2BgFCux1WXskxisxvzV2KA0ukqaVbQ1Ckco",
"mime_type": "image/jpeg",
"sha256": "sha256:49c45762f344fcc058a1f1167b01e9c298b1f4cff5e200e9033577f9c1023ad2",
"byte_size": 16871807,
"pixel_width": 5964,
"pixel_height": 4768,
"exif_orientation_applied": false,
"colour_profile_status": "embedded_profile_converted_to_srgb"
},
"presentation": {
"role": "web_presentation_surrogate",
"alt_text": "Color photograph of a soldier holding a helmet to his face while seated among pale rubble and standing columns at Palmyra under a clear blue sky.",
"alt_text_status": "reviewed_accessibility_description",
"public_widths": [
640,
1280,
2400
],
"derivatives": [
{
"width": 640,
"height": 512,
"mime_type": "image/webp",
"sha256": "sha256:717f96e39da429b7633fedaa293c8befbace1590b83d734a7bcd55396f115bd7",
"byte_size": 62624,
"repository_path": "media/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0028/49c45762f344fcc058a1f1167b01e9c298b1f4cff5e200e9033577f9c1023ad2/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/640.webp",
"url": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/museum/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0028/49c45762f344fcc058a1f1167b01e9c298b1f4cff5e200e9033577f9c1023ad2/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/640.webp",
"cache_control": "public, max-age=31536000, immutable"
},
{
"width": 1280,
"height": 1023,
"mime_type": "image/webp",
"sha256": "sha256:6e8cbeca51dc4cc75cf220053e140dca939be4c2e8d863e1cd0f2af7662707e7",
"byte_size": 221762,
"repository_path": "media/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0028/49c45762f344fcc058a1f1167b01e9c298b1f4cff5e200e9033577f9c1023ad2/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/1280.webp",
"url": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/museum/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0028/49c45762f344fcc058a1f1167b01e9c298b1f4cff5e200e9033577f9c1023ad2/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/1280.webp",
"cache_control": "public, max-age=31536000, immutable"
},
{
"width": 2400,
"height": 1919,
"mime_type": "image/webp",
"sha256": "sha256:123e1d3a47fb9b4b7252e840666eb507d81a79a7e6d9956d60d51fe86861b4b9",
"byte_size": 663788,
"repository_path": "media/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0028/49c45762f344fcc058a1f1167b01e9c298b1f4cff5e200e9033577f9c1023ad2/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/2400.webp",
"url": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/museum/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/6529NM-W-0028/49c45762f344fcc058a1f1167b01e9c298b1f4cff5e200e9033577f9c1023ad2/webp-v2-q82-m6-fixed-icc/2400.webp",
"cache_control": "public, max-age=31536000, immutable"
}
]
}
}
]
}
Source record
Technical and condition review
Technical and condition review
# Technical and condition review The five accession objects are ERC-721 tokens with photographic source images. The Museum verified each transfer receipt and matching Transfer log, read ownerOf at the common finalized Ethereum block 25741809, and retained the source metadata and image references from the proposal package. The objects are ready for credited accession-context display. Their source images are not yet asserted to be Museum preservation masters. Image-byte retention, redundant replication, rights-compliant display, and further provenance enrichment remain active stewardship actions. No executable artwork, generator, or software dependency is asserted for these photographic objects.
Technical / provenance record
Title, rights, and accession review
Accession lot: 6529NM.2026.002
Gift: Conflict at Its Edges, five photographs from Magnum Photos 75
Donor: punk6529
Status: accepted and accessioned into the permanent Collection
Title basis
The donor offered the five scheduled tokens as a full gift. The Museum maintainer instructed the Museum to record the gift as accepted and accessioned. The five transfer receipts identify delivery from the donor address to networkmuseum.6529.eth; the custody package records the receipts, their Transfer logs, and the common finalized-block ownerOf observation.
The Museum's title record therefore covers the donor's transferable interest in the five tokenized objects. This public record derives that determination from the full-gift offer and the maintainer's instruction. It does not cite a separate private instrument.
Rights position
The source records identify the photographs as All Rights Reserved and credit each artist and Magnum Photos. The gift transfers the tokenized objects and the donor's transferable interest in them; it does not transfer copyright or create a general reproduction licence. The Museum's public presentation is limited to the credited accession context and remains subject to the source rights position.
Supporting records
- Gift acceptance and accession authorization
- Accession certificate
- Finalized custody evidence
- Source and rights record
Source record
Web presentation of *Conflict at Its Edges*
Web presentation of *Conflict at Its Edges*
--- record_id: 6529NM.2026.002.DISPLAY-01 record_type: ACCESSION_DISPLAY_AUTHORITY accession_lot_id: 6529NM.2026.002 status: active effective_at: 2026-08-13T12:40:00Z supersedes: 6529NM-PG-2026-001-MEDIA-DISPLAY-2026-08-11-001 supersession_scope: proposal_stage_responsive_image_restriction_only supersession_reason: Accessioned works require proportion-preserving responsive delivery copies for practical and accessible Museum display. --- # Web presentation of *Conflict at Its Edges* The 6529 Network Museum acquired the five tokenized photographs in *Conflict at Its Edges* and interprets that acquisition as carrying the ordinary institutional right to display and publish the works in a credited Museum context. Copyright remains with the photographers and Magnum Photos. The Museum does not claim copyright ownership or a general licence to reproduce, sell, sublicense, download, alter, or train models on the images. For a practical and accessible web presentation, the Museum may produce proportion-preserving delivery copies from each fixity-verified source image. The approved technical process applies EXIF orientation, converts embedded colour profiles to sRGB or treats an untagged source as sRGB, resizes with Lanczos filtering, and encodes WebP copies at 640, 1280, and 2400 pixels wide. It does not crop, watermark, retouch, recolour, or otherwise alter the depicted content. Within this accession context, this authority supersedes the proposal-stage delivery rule that barred Museum responsive variants. That earlier rule remains part of the proposal's historical record; this authority does not alter the recorded source objects or their underlying rights. The exact Arweave image remains the recorded source object. Every web copy is identified by its source hash, transform profile, dimensions, byte size, and its own SHA-256 digest. The browser receives the smallest appropriate copy for its viewport; the source original is not the default page payload. These delivery copies are display surrogates, not preservation masters and not downloadable publication assets. Each display must retain the work's artist, title, date or place where recorded, Magnum credit, All Rights Reserved notice, and accession context. This authority applies to the Museum's own public site and records. It creates no permission for third-party reuse.
Source record
6529NM-W-0024
6529NM-W-0024
{
"$schema": "https://6529networkmuseum.org/schemas/record-envelope-v1.json",
"envelope": {
"contentHash": {
"algorithm": 1,
"canonicalizationId": "0x886c7c89c308c459ca8a626e0ef36a5ea9f4c7a7b56aaf86c71a2ddf3b4f9044",
"digest": "0x16dc83b8f386cc0a6bdbf35bb2a184cf9b92768de8309d45619c0bccd0e0df3c"
},
"effectiveAt": 1786573476,
"recordType": "PUBLIC_ENTITY",
"schemaId": "0xd8aef6592fe156c4c3c10e59de540f5cdf8b130eedca322e0e22b30764bee1a9",
"signatureHash": {
"algorithm": 2,
"canonicalizationId": "0x886c7c89c308c459ca8a626e0ef36a5ea9f4c7a7b56aaf86c71a2ddf3b4f9044",
"digest": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000"
},
"signatureScheme": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"subjectId": "0x9709c090d7059b05750ae54603caacd5c184362fb5cdc499aea26576aa18e169",
"uri": "https://6529networkmuseum.org/records/entities/6529NM-W-0024.json"
},
"payload": {
"canonical_route": "/museum/network/works/6529NM-W-0024",
"constructor": {
"id": "codex-task:magnum-completed-accession-correction-2026-08-12",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"role": "constructor"
},
"created_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"effective_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"entity_id": "6529NM-W-0024",
"entity_status": "published",
"entity_type": "WORK",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Proposed gift object",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.01.json"
}
],
"media_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-MED-0003"
],
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"page_exposure": "canonical_page",
"payload_sha256": "sha256:f09a39710dfc306cbbffc167d323af132f4ffc4987946baf03d3dcecea3f02e8",
"preferred_label": "Patrolling the border between the Negev Desert and Jordan",
"profile": {
"accession_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002"
],
"acquisition_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-CA-2026-003"
],
"collection_membership": {
"accession_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002"
],
"collection_entity_id": "6529NM-C-0001",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.01.json"
}
],
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM.2026.002.01"
],
"status": "permanent_collection"
},
"component_references": [
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.01.json"
}
],
"record_id": "6529NM.2026.002.01",
"reference_type": "component",
"registry_id": null,
"source_record_id": "6529NM.2026.002.01",
"source_status": "verified",
"target_kind": "authoritative_record",
"target_type": "WORK_DESCRIPTION"
}
],
"creation_date": {
"display": "1952",
"earliest": "1952-01-01",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Proposed gift object",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"latest": "1952-12-31",
"status": "established"
},
"creator_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-ART-0017"
],
"current_museum_relation": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.01.json"
}
],
"museum_entity_id": "6529NM-I-0001",
"relation_status": "permanent_collection"
},
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback (is_signed=true)",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Original proposal object",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.01.json"
}
],
"identity_boundary": "Work identity remains independent of the Curated Acquisition, accession lot, token manifestation, title, custody, rights, and public route.",
"lifecycle_observations": [
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Original PARTICIPATORY proposal observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"notes": "The original published proposal observation is retained as history and is not rewritten.",
"observation_id": "6529NM-W-OBS-0024",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-PG-2026-001"
],
"source_status": "PARTICIPATORY",
"status": "proposed_in_museum_wave"
},
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback (is_signed=true)",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Museum Wave drop page readback",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"notes": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback changes the Museum relationship to selection under acquisition review only; the five Works remain outside the permanent Collection.",
"observation_id": "6529NM-W-OBS-0029",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-WAVE-OBS-2026-08-08-001"
],
"source_status": "WINNER",
"status": "selected_by_museum_wave_acquisition_review_in_progress"
},
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.01.json"
}
],
"notes": "The completed gift admits the Work to the Museum's permanent Collection. Title, custody, rights, technical condition, preservation, and display remain separately documented facts.",
"observation_id": "6529NM-W-OBS-0034",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.01"
],
"source_status": "accessioned",
"status": "accessioned"
}
],
"manifestation_references": [
{
"caip19": "eip155:1/erc721:0xe628b59d34f42b16c53f4d697f1ffd4d8d987b91/127",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Proposed ERC-721 manifestation reference",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"record_id": "6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-001.TOKEN",
"reference_type": "manifestation",
"registry_id": "PUBLIC_TYPED_REFERENCE_REGISTRY_V1",
"source_record_id": "6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-001",
"source_status": "proposed",
"target_kind": "governed_typed_registry",
"target_type": "ERC721_TOKEN_MANIFESTATION"
}
],
"medium": "photograph",
"mint_fact": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Ethereum custody and token observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
}
],
"notes": "Finalized Ethereum chain evidence verifies the existing ERC-721 token manifestation independently of title, custody, rights, and accession.",
"status": "verified"
},
"profile_type": "WORK",
"program_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-AP-ENT-0001"
],
"project_or_series_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-PRJ-0006"
],
"title": "Patrolling the border between the Negev Desert and Jordan",
"work_lifecycle_status": "accessioned"
},
"public_slug": "6529NM-W-0024",
"record_id": "6529NM-W-0024",
"record_status": "reviewed",
"record_type": "PUBLIC_ENTITY",
"record_version": "1.0.0",
"references": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002",
"6529NM-AGT-0018",
"6529NM-CA-2026-003",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-001",
"6529NM-PRJ-0006",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.01",
"6529NM.2026.002.COND.01",
"6529NM.2026.002.GAA-01",
"6529NM.2026.002.RIGHTS.01"
],
"review_status": "reviewed",
"reviewer": {
"id": "codex-reviewer:vera-molnar-a9-copy-correction-independent",
"outcome": "approved",
"reviewed_at": "2026-08-23T15:10:17.867Z",
"reviewed_commit": "3eab50914a90c079fe0383624e760fc0a954e709",
"reviewed_manifest_keccak": "0xd3b728ca1bdbbf99602d626df93b6903bbacf624f2ef71e064412654e71cf313",
"reviewed_manifest_sha256": "sha256:f672c3503baa823cf4af5eac3bf0513b6b25de6e2674902273cb778f4e771080",
"reviewer_ids": [
"codex-reviewer:vera-molnar-a9-copy-correction-independent"
],
"role": "reviewer"
},
"schema_id": "0xd8aef6592fe156c4c3c10e59de540f5cdf8b130eedca322e0e22b30764bee1a9",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002",
"6529NM-AGT-0018",
"6529NM-CA-2026-003",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-001",
"6529NM-PRJ-0006",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.01",
"6529NM.2026.002.COND.01",
"6529NM.2026.002.GAA-01",
"6529NM.2026.002.RIGHTS.01"
],
"status_observation": {
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.01.json"
}
],
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"status_label": "published"
},
"subject_id": "6529NM-W-0024",
"visibility": "public"
}
}
Source record
6529NM-W-0025
6529NM-W-0025
{
"$schema": "https://6529networkmuseum.org/schemas/record-envelope-v1.json",
"envelope": {
"contentHash": {
"algorithm": 1,
"canonicalizationId": "0x886c7c89c308c459ca8a626e0ef36a5ea9f4c7a7b56aaf86c71a2ddf3b4f9044",
"digest": "0xf282de2edb68243ff9c3c9bf11c96577105bc265bb37e99e24b1c222bb67311f"
},
"effectiveAt": 1786573476,
"recordType": "PUBLIC_ENTITY",
"schemaId": "0xd8aef6592fe156c4c3c10e59de540f5cdf8b130eedca322e0e22b30764bee1a9",
"signatureHash": {
"algorithm": 2,
"canonicalizationId": "0x886c7c89c308c459ca8a626e0ef36a5ea9f4c7a7b56aaf86c71a2ddf3b4f9044",
"digest": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000"
},
"signatureScheme": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"subjectId": "0x9f21d85020494f79c68c361281989ed253833b8790df495b08f82fdc0221733a",
"uri": "https://6529networkmuseum.org/records/entities/6529NM-W-0025.json"
},
"payload": {
"canonical_route": "/museum/network/works/6529NM-W-0025",
"constructor": {
"id": "codex-task:magnum-completed-accession-correction-2026-08-12",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"role": "constructor"
},
"created_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"effective_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"entity_id": "6529NM-W-0025",
"entity_status": "published",
"entity_type": "WORK",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Proposed gift object",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.02.json"
}
],
"media_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-MED-0041"
],
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"page_exposure": "canonical_page",
"payload_sha256": "sha256:ef58bcc4a58314b600efeadb512913e34382557d777b54efecb2f9155fc504fc",
"preferred_label": "Government soldiers in a church, Suchitoto, El Salvador",
"profile": {
"accession_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002"
],
"acquisition_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-CA-2026-003"
],
"collection_membership": {
"accession_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002"
],
"collection_entity_id": "6529NM-C-0001",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.02.json"
}
],
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM.2026.002.02"
],
"status": "permanent_collection"
},
"component_references": [
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.02.json"
}
],
"record_id": "6529NM.2026.002.02",
"reference_type": "component",
"registry_id": null,
"source_record_id": "6529NM.2026.002.02",
"source_status": "verified",
"target_kind": "authoritative_record",
"target_type": "WORK_DESCRIPTION"
}
],
"creation_date": {
"display": "1986",
"earliest": "1986-01-01",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Proposed gift object",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"latest": "1986-12-31",
"status": "established"
},
"creator_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-ART-0018"
],
"current_museum_relation": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.02.json"
}
],
"museum_entity_id": "6529NM-I-0001",
"relation_status": "permanent_collection"
},
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback (is_signed=true)",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Original proposal object",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.02.json"
}
],
"identity_boundary": "Work identity remains independent of the Curated Acquisition, accession lot, token manifestation, title, custody, rights, and public route.",
"lifecycle_observations": [
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Original PARTICIPATORY proposal observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"notes": "The original published proposal observation is retained as history and is not rewritten.",
"observation_id": "6529NM-W-OBS-0025",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-PG-2026-001"
],
"source_status": "PARTICIPATORY",
"status": "proposed_in_museum_wave"
},
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback (is_signed=true)",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Museum Wave drop page readback",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"notes": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback changes the Museum relationship to selection under acquisition review only; the five Works remain outside the permanent Collection.",
"observation_id": "6529NM-W-OBS-0030",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-WAVE-OBS-2026-08-08-001"
],
"source_status": "WINNER",
"status": "selected_by_museum_wave_acquisition_review_in_progress"
},
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.02.json"
}
],
"notes": "The completed gift admits the Work to the Museum's permanent Collection. Title, custody, rights, technical condition, preservation, and display remain separately documented facts.",
"observation_id": "6529NM-W-OBS-0035",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.02"
],
"source_status": "accessioned",
"status": "accessioned"
}
],
"manifestation_references": [
{
"caip19": "eip155:1/erc721:0xe628b59d34f42b16c53f4d697f1ffd4d8d987b91/145",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Proposed ERC-721 manifestation reference",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"record_id": "6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-002.TOKEN",
"reference_type": "manifestation",
"registry_id": "PUBLIC_TYPED_REFERENCE_REGISTRY_V1",
"source_record_id": "6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-002",
"source_status": "proposed",
"target_kind": "governed_typed_registry",
"target_type": "ERC721_TOKEN_MANIFESTATION"
}
],
"medium": "photograph",
"mint_fact": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Ethereum custody and token observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
}
],
"notes": "Finalized Ethereum chain evidence verifies the existing ERC-721 token manifestation independently of title, custody, rights, and accession.",
"status": "verified"
},
"profile_type": "WORK",
"program_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-AP-ENT-0001"
],
"project_or_series_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-PRJ-0006"
],
"title": "Government soldiers in a church, Suchitoto, El Salvador",
"work_lifecycle_status": "accessioned"
},
"public_slug": "6529NM-W-0025",
"record_id": "6529NM-W-0025",
"record_status": "reviewed",
"record_type": "PUBLIC_ENTITY",
"record_version": "1.0.0",
"references": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002",
"6529NM-AGT-0019",
"6529NM-CA-2026-003",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-002",
"6529NM-PRJ-0006",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.02",
"6529NM.2026.002.COND.02",
"6529NM.2026.002.GAA-01",
"6529NM.2026.002.RIGHTS.02"
],
"review_status": "reviewed",
"reviewer": {
"id": "codex-reviewer:vera-molnar-a9-copy-correction-independent",
"outcome": "approved",
"reviewed_at": "2026-08-23T15:10:17.867Z",
"reviewed_commit": "3eab50914a90c079fe0383624e760fc0a954e709",
"reviewed_manifest_keccak": "0xd3b728ca1bdbbf99602d626df93b6903bbacf624f2ef71e064412654e71cf313",
"reviewed_manifest_sha256": "sha256:f672c3503baa823cf4af5eac3bf0513b6b25de6e2674902273cb778f4e771080",
"reviewer_ids": [
"codex-reviewer:vera-molnar-a9-copy-correction-independent"
],
"role": "reviewer"
},
"schema_id": "0xd8aef6592fe156c4c3c10e59de540f5cdf8b130eedca322e0e22b30764bee1a9",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002",
"6529NM-AGT-0019",
"6529NM-CA-2026-003",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-002",
"6529NM-PRJ-0006",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.02",
"6529NM.2026.002.COND.02",
"6529NM.2026.002.GAA-01",
"6529NM.2026.002.RIGHTS.02"
],
"status_observation": {
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.02.json"
}
],
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"status_label": "published"
},
"subject_id": "6529NM-W-0025",
"visibility": "public"
}
}
Source record
6529NM-W-0026
6529NM-W-0026
{
"$schema": "https://6529networkmuseum.org/schemas/record-envelope-v1.json",
"envelope": {
"contentHash": {
"algorithm": 1,
"canonicalizationId": "0x886c7c89c308c459ca8a626e0ef36a5ea9f4c7a7b56aaf86c71a2ddf3b4f9044",
"digest": "0x3506fa89486f8a72799ed295ed6bbb8f9d2e1bc283df886cc9ecee7f5eae07ff"
},
"effectiveAt": 1786573476,
"recordType": "PUBLIC_ENTITY",
"schemaId": "0xd8aef6592fe156c4c3c10e59de540f5cdf8b130eedca322e0e22b30764bee1a9",
"signatureHash": {
"algorithm": 2,
"canonicalizationId": "0x886c7c89c308c459ca8a626e0ef36a5ea9f4c7a7b56aaf86c71a2ddf3b4f9044",
"digest": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000"
},
"signatureScheme": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"subjectId": "0xfc548f7c5c41b61d900f9ea798b6c3db40041d0ccaa97d5229bb043e74fc9295",
"uri": "https://6529networkmuseum.org/records/entities/6529NM-W-0026.json"
},
"payload": {
"canonical_route": "/museum/network/works/6529NM-W-0026",
"constructor": {
"id": "codex-task:magnum-completed-accession-correction-2026-08-12",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"role": "constructor"
},
"created_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"effective_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"entity_id": "6529NM-W-0026",
"entity_status": "published",
"entity_type": "WORK",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Proposed gift object",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.03.json"
}
],
"media_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-MED-0042"
],
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"page_exposure": "canonical_page",
"payload_sha256": "sha256:263aa490545dee20c81440d818c16915b9c95c3932d87efc3f8b800244c1ae9f",
"preferred_label": "Demonstration, Western Wall, Jerusalem",
"profile": {
"accession_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002"
],
"acquisition_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-CA-2026-003"
],
"collection_membership": {
"accession_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002"
],
"collection_entity_id": "6529NM-C-0001",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.03.json"
}
],
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM.2026.002.03"
],
"status": "permanent_collection"
},
"component_references": [
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.03.json"
}
],
"record_id": "6529NM.2026.002.03",
"reference_type": "component",
"registry_id": null,
"source_record_id": "6529NM.2026.002.03",
"source_status": "verified",
"target_kind": "authoritative_record",
"target_type": "WORK_DESCRIPTION"
}
],
"creation_date": {
"display": "1989",
"earliest": "1989-01-01",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Proposed gift object",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"latest": "1989-12-31",
"status": "established"
},
"creator_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-ART-0019"
],
"current_museum_relation": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.03.json"
}
],
"museum_entity_id": "6529NM-I-0001",
"relation_status": "permanent_collection"
},
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback (is_signed=true)",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Original proposal object",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.03.json"
}
],
"identity_boundary": "Work identity remains independent of the Curated Acquisition, accession lot, token manifestation, title, custody, rights, and public route.",
"lifecycle_observations": [
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Original PARTICIPATORY proposal observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"notes": "The original published proposal observation is retained as history and is not rewritten.",
"observation_id": "6529NM-W-OBS-0026",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-PG-2026-001"
],
"source_status": "PARTICIPATORY",
"status": "proposed_in_museum_wave"
},
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback (is_signed=true)",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Museum Wave drop page readback",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"notes": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback changes the Museum relationship to selection under acquisition review only; the five Works remain outside the permanent Collection.",
"observation_id": "6529NM-W-OBS-0031",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-WAVE-OBS-2026-08-08-001"
],
"source_status": "WINNER",
"status": "selected_by_museum_wave_acquisition_review_in_progress"
},
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.03.json"
}
],
"notes": "The completed gift admits the Work to the Museum's permanent Collection. Title, custody, rights, technical condition, preservation, and display remain separately documented facts.",
"observation_id": "6529NM-W-OBS-0036",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.03"
],
"source_status": "accessioned",
"status": "accessioned"
}
],
"manifestation_references": [
{
"caip19": "eip155:1/erc721:0xe628b59d34f42b16c53f4d697f1ffd4d8d987b91/97",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Proposed ERC-721 manifestation reference",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"record_id": "6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-003.TOKEN",
"reference_type": "manifestation",
"registry_id": "PUBLIC_TYPED_REFERENCE_REGISTRY_V1",
"source_record_id": "6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-003",
"source_status": "proposed",
"target_kind": "governed_typed_registry",
"target_type": "ERC721_TOKEN_MANIFESTATION"
}
],
"medium": "photograph",
"mint_fact": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Ethereum custody and token observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
}
],
"notes": "Finalized Ethereum chain evidence verifies the existing ERC-721 token manifestation independently of title, custody, rights, and accession.",
"status": "verified"
},
"profile_type": "WORK",
"program_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-AP-ENT-0001"
],
"project_or_series_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-PRJ-0006"
],
"title": "Demonstration, Western Wall, Jerusalem",
"work_lifecycle_status": "accessioned"
},
"public_slug": "6529NM-W-0026",
"record_id": "6529NM-W-0026",
"record_status": "reviewed",
"record_type": "PUBLIC_ENTITY",
"record_version": "1.0.0",
"references": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002",
"6529NM-AGT-0020",
"6529NM-CA-2026-003",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-003",
"6529NM-PRJ-0006",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.03",
"6529NM.2026.002.COND.03",
"6529NM.2026.002.GAA-01",
"6529NM.2026.002.RIGHTS.03"
],
"review_status": "reviewed",
"reviewer": {
"id": "codex-reviewer:vera-molnar-a9-copy-correction-independent",
"outcome": "approved",
"reviewed_at": "2026-08-23T15:10:17.867Z",
"reviewed_commit": "3eab50914a90c079fe0383624e760fc0a954e709",
"reviewed_manifest_keccak": "0xd3b728ca1bdbbf99602d626df93b6903bbacf624f2ef71e064412654e71cf313",
"reviewed_manifest_sha256": "sha256:f672c3503baa823cf4af5eac3bf0513b6b25de6e2674902273cb778f4e771080",
"reviewer_ids": [
"codex-reviewer:vera-molnar-a9-copy-correction-independent"
],
"role": "reviewer"
},
"schema_id": "0xd8aef6592fe156c4c3c10e59de540f5cdf8b130eedca322e0e22b30764bee1a9",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002",
"6529NM-AGT-0020",
"6529NM-CA-2026-003",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-003",
"6529NM-PRJ-0006",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.03",
"6529NM.2026.002.COND.03",
"6529NM.2026.002.GAA-01",
"6529NM.2026.002.RIGHTS.03"
],
"status_observation": {
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.03.json"
}
],
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"status_label": "published"
},
"subject_id": "6529NM-W-0026",
"visibility": "public"
}
}
Source record
6529NM-W-0027
6529NM-W-0027
{
"$schema": "https://6529networkmuseum.org/schemas/record-envelope-v1.json",
"envelope": {
"contentHash": {
"algorithm": 1,
"canonicalizationId": "0x886c7c89c308c459ca8a626e0ef36a5ea9f4c7a7b56aaf86c71a2ddf3b4f9044",
"digest": "0xb7d3d2f66e3ad12c5cf50ce4db197afc6c31f501a5512e1342e0cd5f410426ab"
},
"effectiveAt": 1786573476,
"recordType": "PUBLIC_ENTITY",
"schemaId": "0xd8aef6592fe156c4c3c10e59de540f5cdf8b130eedca322e0e22b30764bee1a9",
"signatureHash": {
"algorithm": 2,
"canonicalizationId": "0x886c7c89c308c459ca8a626e0ef36a5ea9f4c7a7b56aaf86c71a2ddf3b4f9044",
"digest": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000"
},
"signatureScheme": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"subjectId": "0x1c81fb972aca2466e9cd2a1aff3c1f07e951da97b9f2292116d2677098abad04",
"uri": "https://6529networkmuseum.org/records/entities/6529NM-W-0027.json"
},
"payload": {
"canonical_route": "/museum/network/works/6529NM-W-0027",
"constructor": {
"id": "codex-task:magnum-completed-accession-correction-2026-08-12",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"role": "constructor"
},
"created_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"effective_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"entity_id": "6529NM-W-0027",
"entity_status": "published",
"entity_type": "WORK",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Proposed gift object",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.04.json"
}
],
"media_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-MED-0043"
],
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"page_exposure": "canonical_page",
"payload_sha256": "sha256:8f6fd336e04c6266beed8f82565ab029651e0763ab20cfde5e737d990165030a",
"preferred_label": "Tripoli, Libya",
"profile": {
"accession_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002"
],
"acquisition_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-CA-2026-003"
],
"collection_membership": {
"accession_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002"
],
"collection_entity_id": "6529NM-C-0001",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.04.json"
}
],
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM.2026.002.04"
],
"status": "permanent_collection"
},
"component_references": [
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.04.json"
}
],
"record_id": "6529NM.2026.002.04",
"reference_type": "component",
"registry_id": null,
"source_record_id": "6529NM.2026.002.04",
"source_status": "verified",
"target_kind": "authoritative_record",
"target_type": "WORK_DESCRIPTION"
}
],
"creation_date": {
"display": "2011",
"earliest": "2011-01-01",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Proposed gift object",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"latest": "2011-12-31",
"status": "established"
},
"creator_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-ART-0020"
],
"current_museum_relation": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.04.json"
}
],
"museum_entity_id": "6529NM-I-0001",
"relation_status": "permanent_collection"
},
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback (is_signed=true)",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Original proposal object",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.04.json"
}
],
"identity_boundary": "Work identity remains independent of the Curated Acquisition, accession lot, token manifestation, title, custody, rights, and public route.",
"lifecycle_observations": [
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Original PARTICIPATORY proposal observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"notes": "The original published proposal observation is retained as history and is not rewritten.",
"observation_id": "6529NM-W-OBS-0027",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-PG-2026-001"
],
"source_status": "PARTICIPATORY",
"status": "proposed_in_museum_wave"
},
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback (is_signed=true)",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Museum Wave drop page readback",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"notes": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback changes the Museum relationship to selection under acquisition review only; the five Works remain outside the permanent Collection.",
"observation_id": "6529NM-W-OBS-0032",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-WAVE-OBS-2026-08-08-001"
],
"source_status": "WINNER",
"status": "selected_by_museum_wave_acquisition_review_in_progress"
},
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.04.json"
}
],
"notes": "The completed gift admits the Work to the Museum's permanent Collection. Title, custody, rights, technical condition, preservation, and display remain separately documented facts.",
"observation_id": "6529NM-W-OBS-0037",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.04"
],
"source_status": "accessioned",
"status": "accessioned"
}
],
"manifestation_references": [
{
"caip19": "eip155:1/erc721:0xe628b59d34f42b16c53f4d697f1ffd4d8d987b91/44",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Proposed ERC-721 manifestation reference",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"record_id": "6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-004.TOKEN",
"reference_type": "manifestation",
"registry_id": "PUBLIC_TYPED_REFERENCE_REGISTRY_V1",
"source_record_id": "6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-004",
"source_status": "proposed",
"target_kind": "governed_typed_registry",
"target_type": "ERC721_TOKEN_MANIFESTATION"
}
],
"medium": "photograph",
"mint_fact": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Ethereum custody and token observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
}
],
"notes": "Finalized Ethereum chain evidence verifies the existing ERC-721 token manifestation independently of title, custody, rights, and accession.",
"status": "verified"
},
"profile_type": "WORK",
"program_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-AP-ENT-0001"
],
"project_or_series_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-PRJ-0006"
],
"title": "Tripoli, Libya",
"work_lifecycle_status": "accessioned"
},
"public_slug": "6529NM-W-0027",
"record_id": "6529NM-W-0027",
"record_status": "reviewed",
"record_type": "PUBLIC_ENTITY",
"record_version": "1.0.0",
"references": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002",
"6529NM-AGT-0021",
"6529NM-CA-2026-003",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-004",
"6529NM-PRJ-0006",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.04",
"6529NM.2026.002.COND.04",
"6529NM.2026.002.GAA-01",
"6529NM.2026.002.RIGHTS.04"
],
"review_status": "reviewed",
"reviewer": {
"id": "codex-reviewer:vera-molnar-a9-copy-correction-independent",
"outcome": "approved",
"reviewed_at": "2026-08-23T15:10:17.867Z",
"reviewed_commit": "3eab50914a90c079fe0383624e760fc0a954e709",
"reviewed_manifest_keccak": "0xd3b728ca1bdbbf99602d626df93b6903bbacf624f2ef71e064412654e71cf313",
"reviewed_manifest_sha256": "sha256:f672c3503baa823cf4af5eac3bf0513b6b25de6e2674902273cb778f4e771080",
"reviewer_ids": [
"codex-reviewer:vera-molnar-a9-copy-correction-independent"
],
"role": "reviewer"
},
"schema_id": "0xd8aef6592fe156c4c3c10e59de540f5cdf8b130eedca322e0e22b30764bee1a9",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002",
"6529NM-AGT-0021",
"6529NM-CA-2026-003",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-004",
"6529NM-PRJ-0006",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.04",
"6529NM.2026.002.COND.04",
"6529NM.2026.002.GAA-01",
"6529NM.2026.002.RIGHTS.04"
],
"status_observation": {
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.04.json"
}
],
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"status_label": "published"
},
"subject_id": "6529NM-W-0027",
"visibility": "public"
}
}
Source record
6529NM-W-0028
6529NM-W-0028
{
"$schema": "https://6529networkmuseum.org/schemas/record-envelope-v1.json",
"envelope": {
"contentHash": {
"algorithm": 1,
"canonicalizationId": "0x886c7c89c308c459ca8a626e0ef36a5ea9f4c7a7b56aaf86c71a2ddf3b4f9044",
"digest": "0xd8a892edc91c2569f2167d84150c10dbaaa30a209e48d88dea642ff926941d73"
},
"effectiveAt": 1786573476,
"recordType": "PUBLIC_ENTITY",
"schemaId": "0xd8aef6592fe156c4c3c10e59de540f5cdf8b130eedca322e0e22b30764bee1a9",
"signatureHash": {
"algorithm": 2,
"canonicalizationId": "0x886c7c89c308c459ca8a626e0ef36a5ea9f4c7a7b56aaf86c71a2ddf3b4f9044",
"digest": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000"
},
"signatureScheme": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"subjectId": "0x5162d69ac414c890f74513c6c2c5066b0f8cb9dc240fa7ea790852f25b40bfb8",
"uri": "https://6529networkmuseum.org/records/entities/6529NM-W-0028.json"
},
"payload": {
"canonical_route": "/museum/network/works/6529NM-W-0028",
"constructor": {
"id": "codex-task:magnum-completed-accession-correction-2026-08-12",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"role": "constructor"
},
"created_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"effective_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"entity_id": "6529NM-W-0028",
"entity_status": "published",
"entity_type": "WORK",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Proposed gift object",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.05.json"
}
],
"media_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-MED-0044"
],
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"page_exposure": "canonical_page",
"payload_sha256": "sha256:b273e07a30e0ebe59cc0689d95737d5cbde5f4c4a492e0db4da459bfa59d83ce",
"preferred_label": "Palmyra, Syria",
"profile": {
"accession_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002"
],
"acquisition_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-CA-2026-003"
],
"collection_membership": {
"accession_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002"
],
"collection_entity_id": "6529NM-C-0001",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.05.json"
}
],
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM.2026.002.05"
],
"status": "permanent_collection"
},
"component_references": [
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.05.json"
}
],
"record_id": "6529NM.2026.002.05",
"reference_type": "component",
"registry_id": null,
"source_record_id": "6529NM.2026.002.05",
"source_status": "verified",
"target_kind": "authoritative_record",
"target_type": "WORK_DESCRIPTION"
}
],
"creation_date": {
"display": "2016",
"earliest": "2016-01-01",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Proposed gift object",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"latest": "2016-12-31",
"status": "established"
},
"creator_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-ART-0021"
],
"current_museum_relation": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.05.json"
}
],
"museum_entity_id": "6529NM-I-0001",
"relation_status": "permanent_collection"
},
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback (is_signed=true)",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Original proposal object",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.05.json"
}
],
"identity_boundary": "Work identity remains independent of the Curated Acquisition, accession lot, token manifestation, title, custody, rights, and public route.",
"lifecycle_observations": [
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Original PARTICIPATORY proposal observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"notes": "The original published proposal observation is retained as history and is not rewritten.",
"observation_id": "6529NM-W-OBS-0028",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-PG-2026-001"
],
"source_status": "PARTICIPATORY",
"status": "proposed_in_museum_wave"
},
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback (is_signed=true)",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Museum Wave drop page readback",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"notes": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback changes the Museum relationship to selection under acquisition review only; the five Works remain outside the permanent Collection.",
"observation_id": "6529NM-W-OBS-0033",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-WAVE-OBS-2026-08-08-001"
],
"source_status": "WINNER",
"status": "selected_by_museum_wave_acquisition_review_in_progress"
},
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.05.json"
}
],
"notes": "The completed gift admits the Work to the Museum's permanent Collection. Title, custody, rights, technical condition, preservation, and display remain separately documented facts.",
"observation_id": "6529NM-W-OBS-0038",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.05"
],
"source_status": "accessioned",
"status": "accessioned"
}
],
"manifestation_references": [
{
"caip19": "eip155:1/erc721:0xe628b59d34f42b16c53f4d697f1ffd4d8d987b91/104",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Proposed ERC-721 manifestation reference",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"record_id": "6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-005.TOKEN",
"reference_type": "manifestation",
"registry_id": "PUBLIC_TYPED_REFERENCE_REGISTRY_V1",
"source_record_id": "6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-005",
"source_status": "proposed",
"target_kind": "governed_typed_registry",
"target_type": "ERC721_TOKEN_MANIFESTATION"
}
],
"medium": "photograph",
"mint_fact": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Ethereum custody and token observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
}
],
"notes": "Finalized Ethereum chain evidence verifies the existing ERC-721 token manifestation independently of title, custody, rights, and accession.",
"status": "verified"
},
"profile_type": "WORK",
"program_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-AP-ENT-0001"
],
"project_or_series_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-PRJ-0006"
],
"title": "Palmyra, Syria",
"work_lifecycle_status": "accessioned"
},
"public_slug": "6529NM-W-0028",
"record_id": "6529NM-W-0028",
"record_status": "reviewed",
"record_type": "PUBLIC_ENTITY",
"record_version": "1.0.0",
"references": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002",
"6529NM-AGT-0022",
"6529NM-CA-2026-003",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-005",
"6529NM-PRJ-0006",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.05",
"6529NM.2026.002.COND.05",
"6529NM.2026.002.GAA-01",
"6529NM.2026.002.RIGHTS.05"
],
"review_status": "reviewed",
"reviewer": {
"id": "codex-reviewer:vera-molnar-a9-copy-correction-independent",
"outcome": "approved",
"reviewed_at": "2026-08-23T15:10:17.867Z",
"reviewed_commit": "3eab50914a90c079fe0383624e760fc0a954e709",
"reviewed_manifest_keccak": "0xd3b728ca1bdbbf99602d626df93b6903bbacf624f2ef71e064412654e71cf313",
"reviewed_manifest_sha256": "sha256:f672c3503baa823cf4af5eac3bf0513b6b25de6e2674902273cb778f4e771080",
"reviewer_ids": [
"codex-reviewer:vera-molnar-a9-copy-correction-independent"
],
"role": "reviewer"
},
"schema_id": "0xd8aef6592fe156c4c3c10e59de540f5cdf8b130eedca322e0e22b30764bee1a9",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002",
"6529NM-AGT-0022",
"6529NM-CA-2026-003",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-005",
"6529NM-PRJ-0006",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.05",
"6529NM.2026.002.COND.05",
"6529NM.2026.002.GAA-01",
"6529NM.2026.002.RIGHTS.05"
],
"status_observation": {
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession object record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/objects/6529NM.2026.002.05.json"
}
],
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"status_label": "published"
},
"subject_id": "6529NM-W-0028",
"visibility": "public"
}
}
Source record
Caption and evidence dossier
Caption and evidence dossier
# Caption and evidence dossier *6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · [Publication record and suggested citation](../publication-record.md)* ## Purpose and method This dossier preserves the distinction between four kinds of record attached to each selected photograph: the issuer's token caption, artist or institutional catalogue records, direct visual observation of the published JPEG, and Museum interpretation. A caption is retained as a historical statement by its source; it is not silently converted into an independently verified event description. The five works are public Work projections for the completed accession and are linked to their proposal object aliases in the machine records ([S37](../sources/source-register.md)). The governed identity inventory binds them to `6529NM-W-0024` through `6529NM-W-0028`; independent review controls publication. The visitor-facing pages use a short caption history and a close reading; this dossier retains the fuller comparison and the questions that remain open. ## Work 01 — David Seymour, *Patrolling the border between the Negev Desert and Jordan* | Evidence layer | Record | Boundary | | --- | --- | --- | | Issuer/token caption | Title names the Negev, Israel, and the border between the Negev Desert and Jordan; archive `SED1952003W00003/23`; curation `2/3`. [S10](../sources/source-register.md) | Establishes the wording of the token record, not the precise site, patrol unit, or first publication. | | Artist/estate comparison | David Seymour’s estate presents a visually matching frame as `PAR116258.jpg` and adds “The King Solomon’s Mines area.” | The estate filename is not publicly cross-indexed to the Magnum archive number. | | Visible observation | A partly turned or back-facing person and long firearm occupy the foreground; a pale tent-like structure, open ground, rocks, and eroded hills recede behind. | No face, unit, flag, border marker, coordinate, or named incident is legible in the observed image. | | Museum interpretation | The rifle and posture make watchfulness bodily while the mapped border remains absent; the place is supplied by caption and archive rather than by a visible line. | Interpretation does not identify the person, route, or commission. | Research questions: the relation between `PAR116258.jpg` and `SED1952003W00003/23`; the meaning of `/23`; exact location and date; assignment; first publication; and current rights authority. See the [Work page](../works/01-david-seymour-127.md), sources S10 and S17–S19. ## Work 02 — Larry Towell, *Government soldiers in a church, Suchitoto, El Salvador* | Evidence layer | Record | Boundary | | --- | --- | --- | | Issuer/token caption | The token title reads “Suchitito, El Salvador,” 1986; archive `TOL1986003W00045/26`; curation `2/3`. Its contextual caption places the scene near the Guazapa guerrilla stronghold and connects persecution of the Catholic Church to liberation theology. [S11](../sources/source-register.md) | The spelling and causal language remain attributed issuer variants. They do not identify the church, soldiers, unit, or operation. | | Proposal/public form | The Museum uses “Suchitoto” as the preferred public place form and retains “Suchitito” as a source variant. | This is a documented editorial preference, not a silent correction of the token record. | | Institutional comparison | Art Windsor-Essex records a related gelatin silver print titled *El Salvador Series 1986–1987 (Soldiers in Church, Suchitoto, El Salvador)*. | The collection record does not publish the Magnum archive number; equivalence remains a research lead. | | Visible observation | Two armed soldiers stand inside a church beneath a large crucifix; windows and flowers frame a nearly symmetrical interior. | The image does not supply the church name, soldiers’ identities, or purpose. | | Museum interpretation | The crucifix establishes a vertical axis while rifles interrupt the symmetry, holding religious space and armed presence in the same frame. | Formal balance does not erase the civil-war context or complete it. | Research questions: church identity; soldiers and operation; assignment; first publication; neighbouring archive numbers; crosswalk to the physical print; and rights attached to the token-linked file. See the [Work page](../works/02-larry-towell-145.md), sources S11 and S20–S21, S33. ## Work 03 — Micha Bar-Am, *Demonstration, Western Wall, Jerusalem* | Evidence layer | Record | Boundary | | --- | --- | --- | | Issuer/token caption | Title, Jerusalem, 1989; archive `BAM1989009W02477/26C`; curation `2/3`. The token description refers to women’s Torah prayer, a hostile response, and police smoke grenades. [S12](../sources/source-register.md) | The exact day, event, and central person remain unverified in the reviewed record. | | Artist/archive comparison | The Micha Bar-Am Archive presents a visually matching frame as `BAM1989009W02477-26`. ICP and Museum Wales publish related title/place records; Museum Wales retains the historical “Wailing Wall” variant. | The suffix difference between `-26` and `/26C` is unexplained; catalogue variants are preserved rather than harmonized. | | Visible observation | A person moves through smoke; a canister is raised or airborne; masonry fills the background; a menorah-like metal structure cuts across the foreground. | The pixels do not identify the person, date, or event. | | Museum interpretation | Smoke turns public space into a field of partial visibility. The barrier is at once religious sign and obstruction, making the plaza specific while limiting what the scene can prove. | The reading is interpretation, not a claim about the person’s intention or the event’s complete history. | Research questions: identifier semantics; exact day and event; person; first publication; adjacent frames; and future rights authority. See the [Work page](../works/03-micha-bar-am-97.md), sources S12 and S22–S25, S34. ## Work 04 — Moisés Saman, *Tripoli, Libya* | Evidence layer | Record | Boundary | | --- | --- | --- | | Issuer/token caption | One metadata passage says that Western air strikes targeted the house and injured one woman; it attributes the account to officials and states that the claim was impossible to verify. A separate caption passage says that minders showed evidence of strikes targeting civilian areas. [S13](../sources/source-register.md) | The two claims remain separately attributed. The caption’s qualification is part of the object’s evidence; the reviewed public record supplies no identity, age, consent documentation, precise house, weapon, responsible actor, or identity for the reportedly injured woman. | | Visible observation | An apparently young person lowers the head beside a light wall with dark marks; a caged lamp occupies the upper area. | No age, identity, biography, or later life is supplied by the reviewed public record. | | Contextual sources | TIME and CPJ document the pressure, danger, and controlled access surrounding reporting in Libya in 2011. | Context explains why the caption’s limitation matters; it does not authenticate the officials’ account or the cause of the marks. | | Museum interpretation | The image makes an altered surface visible while withholding its cause. The depicted person’s apparent youth gives the uncertainty an ethical dimension: the record must not fill the gap with an invented biography. | Safeguarding language is a publication responsibility, not evidence about consent or a retroactive judgment on the photographer. | Research questions: house and date; source of the officials’ account; field notes; child-safeguarding or consent record; assignment and first publication; and token-linked display permission. See the [Work page](../works/04-moises-saman-44.md), sources S13 and S26–S29, S35. ## Work 05 — Lorenzo Meloni, *Palmyra, Syria* | Evidence layer | Record | Boundary | | --- | --- | --- | | Issuer/token record | Title, 2016; archive `MEL2016002G0401/4032`; curation `2/3`. [S14](../sources/source-register.md) | The token record supplies the title and archive reference, while the exact date is supported by the contemporary publication caption. | | Contemporary publication | TIME dates the frame to 1 April 2016 and describes a Syrian army soldier in the rubble of the former Temple of Bel after the change of control. | The report’s attributions and access conditions remain source-specific; it does not independently identify the soldier. | | Heritage record | UNESCO documents the Temple of Bel’s intentional destruction on 30 August 2015 and the heritage site’s damage and demining context after the March 2016 recapture. | UNESCO does not identify the frame or photographer. | | Visible observation | A low seated uniformed figure holds a helmet near the face among pale rubble and standing columns under a clear sky. | Face, rank, unit, and route are not independently legible. | | Museum interpretation | The photograph records an aftermath shaped by controlled access. The soldier’s pause and the surviving columns hold cultural loss, military narrative, and personal gesture together without resolving them. | The reading does not establish intention, identity, or unverified publication history. | Research questions: archive-to-negative and contact-sheet crosswalk; book and exhibition sequence; visit permission; independent identification of the route or soldier; and future rights authority. See the [Work page](../works/05-lorenzo-meloni-104.md), sources S14 and S30–S32. ## Editorial disposition The public Work pages use source-linked footnotes rather than evidence-class labels in body text. This dossier retains evidence classes in the source register and in technical and institutional records so that later corrections can identify the claim type without turning the visitor page into a control log. Any new archive reply should be appended as a dated amendment with `supersedes` where it changes an earlier caption or identity assertion.
Source record
Chronologies
Chronologies
# Chronologies *6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · [Publication record and suggested citation](../publication-record.md)* This dossier separates historical dates, publication dates, chain observations, and Museum-process observations. A date in one column does not imply an event in another. In particular, a mint block is not a listing, sale, transfer to the Museum, or accession date. ## Magnum Photos and the five photographic histories | Date | Event or context | Evidence boundary | | --- | --- | --- | | 1947 | Magnum Photos is founded in the postwar period by the four photographers named on Magnum’s current history page: Henri Cartier-Bresson, Robert Capa, George Rodger, and David Seymour. | Magnum’s current institutional history supplies this four-founder formulation. Other official Magnum biographies include William (Bill) Vandivert and Magnum’s historical profile describes him as an American who helped found the agency and soon left; the source-specific formulations remain attributed. [S01–S03, S39] | | 1951–1952 | David Seymour’s work in Israel begins in the early 1950s; the selected frame is dated 1952 and captioned to the Negev/border region. | ICP and Magnum provide the broader practice context. The 1949 United Nations armistice agreement and contemporary State Department records document the Israel–Jordan armistice line and frontier incidents; they do not identify this frame’s exact site or assignment. [S17–S19, S42–S43] | | 1986 | Larry Towell’s selected frame is dated 1986 and captioned to soldiers in a church in Suchitoto, El Salvador. | The token record supplies the caption and archive identifier; official conflict histories and Towell’s institutional records provide context, not the church or operation identity. [S11, S20–S21, S33] | | 1989 | Micha Bar-Am’s selected frame is dated 1989 and captioned to a demonstration at the Western Wall, Jerusalem. | The token, artist archive, ICP, and Museum Wales provide related records. The exact event day and the `/26C`/`-26` identifier relation remain open. [S12, S22–S25, S34] | | 2011 | Moisés Saman’s selected frame is dated 2011 and captioned to Tripoli, Libya. | The token caption identifies an official air-strike claim as impossible to verify; reporting and press-freedom sources describe the controlled access around the work without proving the cause of the marks. [S13, S26–S29] | | 30 Aug 2015 | UNESCO records intentional destruction of the Temple of Bel at Palmyra. | Heritage chronology for the site; not a frame or photographer record. [S32] | | March 2016 | UNESCO and contemporary reporting describe damage, demining, and a change of control at Palmyra. | Context for the later photograph; source-specific military language is retained. [S31–S32] | | 1 Apr 2016 | TIME dates Lorenzo Meloni’s frame to 1 April 2016 and describes a Syrian army soldier among the ruins of the former Temple of Bel. | Contemporary publication date/caption lead; it does not independently identify the soldier or establish the archive frame’s first publication. [S14, S31] | ## Magnum Photos 75: announced, published, and observed dates | Date/time | Event | Evidence boundary | | --- | --- | --- | | 28 Jun 2022 | Magnum’s archived launch page presents the first Magnum Photos 75 NFT collection, its six-drop schedule, and the Cartagena-curated project frame; it includes the Saman #44 listing. | Official launch-page statement and page observation. The page uses both 76-image and 75-image wording in different places. [S04](../sources/source-register.md) | | 28 Jun 2022, 02:51:06 UTC | Ethereum block observation for token #44 mint, block `15,037,570`. | Deterministic chain timing for mint inclusion. It does not by itself prove listing, sale, or the full six-drop schedule. [S10, S16] | | 12 Jul 2022 | The announced first-release six-drop window ends. | Schedule stated by the archived launch page, not a complete mint/sale ledger. [S04](../sources/source-register.md) | | 28 Nov 2022, 18:25:35–22:07:23 UTC | Tokens #97, #104, #127, and #145 are observed in mint blocks `16,070,265`, `16,070,363`, `16,070,886`, and `16,071,368`. | Chain mint chronology; the near-simultaneous timestamps do not establish public listing or sale timestamps. [S11–S12, S14, S16] | | 1 Dec 2022 | Digital Camera World reports the second 75-piece collection, identifies Azu Nwagbogu’s curation, and describes a six-drop schedule ending 13 December. | Reputable named-source reporting, not a recovered first-party release ledger. [S40](../sources/source-register.md) | | 13 Dec 2022 | The reported second-release drop window ends. | Reported schedule only; not completion proof for every announced work. [S05](../sources/source-register.md) | | 2 Apr 2023 | Archived Foundation collection snapshot records 148 displayed items in the retained research observation. | Platform snapshot, not a canonical total-mint count. [S06](../sources/source-register.md) | ## Publication-count observation boundary Two records retain the same number within different observation boundaries: | Observation | Exact statement retained | Status | | --- | --- | --- | | Posted proposal dossier | The published dossier reports **148 live tokens at finalized block 25,690,178**. | A local proposal/technical observation for that block and record. [S37](../sources/source-register.md) | | Foundation snapshot | The retained marketplace view displays **148 items**. | A historical platform presentation, not a complete mint or issued-token count. [S06](../sources/source-register.md) | The project’s announced or metadata-described total of 225 and three curations also remains a separate statement. No item here converts the plan, sequence numbers, Foundation snapshot, or finalized-block observation into proof that a third curation was publicly released or that all 225 works were minted ([S04](../sources/source-register.md); [S07](../sources/source-register.md); [S10–S14](../sources/source-register.md)). ## Gift formation and Museum Wave chronology | Date/time | Museum record or observation | Status meaning | | --- | --- | --- | | 5 Aug 2026, 17:20:23 UTC | Ethereum finalized block `25,690,178`, hash `0x01a42cf70ba13f1ebefa607249fd9009baadb127f2a05fcb6e7573d943cb200c`; all five selected tokens observed under owner `0x6daa633c23615a29471deafae351727867e7dad1`; no token-level approval. | Point-in-time token/control evidence in the historical proposal package. Donor authority, legal title, copyright, Museum custody, acceptance, and accession have separate records and review stages. [S37](../sources/source-register.md) | | 5 Aug 2026, 17:46:53 UTC | Local read-only verification of the finalized-block proposal observation completes. | Local technical observation timestamp. [S37](../sources/source-register.md) | | 6 Aug 2026 | The retained Wave Storm package records publication of the seven-part proposal, with the five work parts carrying their historical public upstream JPEG URLs. | Historical public Wave presentation media. The exact images may now render in credited accession, Collection, acquisition, artist, Work, and scholarship contexts; no download, zoom, fullscreen, derivative, commercial reuse, or preservation-master claim follows. [S38](../sources/source-register.md) | | 8 Aug 2026, 09:06:07.985 UTC | Live `punk6529bot` readback returns drop `002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0`, serial `1276093`, `drop_type: PARTICIPATORY`, rank `1`, realtime rating `122,969,240`, and `29` raters. | Historical governance observation at that time; it did not establish selection, acceptance, acquisition, accession, or permanent-Collection membership. The later 10:15:02 observation is canonical current status. [S37](../sources/source-register.md) | | 8 Aug 2026, 10:15:02.0167151 UTC | Signed-drop API readback, canonical at the time, returns the same drop as signed `WINNER`, rank `1`, realtime rating `121,603,214`, and `29` raters. | Historical governance observation: at that time the signed `WINNER` established Wave selection; it did not itself establish acceptance, accession, or Collection membership. The later accession record establishes the current state: **completed gift; accessioned into the permanent Collection as `6529NM.2026.002`**. The earlier 09:06:07 observation remains historical-only. [S37](../sources/source-register.md) | ## Future correction rule If Magnum, an artist, an estate, a platform archive, or a governance source supplies a later date or correction, append it as a dated amendment. Preserve the prior statement and use `supersedes` only where the new source actually changes the earlier assertion. Mint, publication, listing, transfer, title, rights, custody, acceptance, and accession dates must continue to be recorded as separate event types.
Source record
Media plan and current presentation disposition
Media plan and current presentation disposition
# Media plan and current presentation disposition *6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · [Publication record and suggested citation](../publication-record.md)* ## Current public use The downstream accession-media review of 12 August 2026 supersedes the browser-locator choice in this record. The CloudFront URLs remain exact historical Wave-publication evidence. Current display uses the corresponding fixity-verified Arweave token-source locators under the same rights, credit, context, and interface restrictions. The five photographs appear in the retained proposal package as historical public media for Wave parts 2–6. The Museum record cites those exact CloudFront Wave-upload URLs and preserves the artist/Magnum credit, `All Rights Reserved`, and the label **Wave-source historical proposal media**. Current display uses the corresponding fixity-verified token-source image with credit in accession, Collection, acquisition, artist, Work, and scholarship contexts ([S38](../sources/source-register.md)). This institutional presentation disposition creates no repository copy or new image manifestation. The correspondence among the historical URLs, Works, tokens, credits, and publication receipt is retained in the complete Museum record. The visitor record is the [Source and rights record](source-and-rights-record.md). ## Work-to-media join The table is the five-row Work/media join retained from the selected offer and continued into accession `6529NM.2026.002` ([S38](../sources/source-register.md)). | Public Work ID | Proposal alias | Wave part | Wave-upload dimensions / bytes | Token-linked source dimensions / bytes | Historical presentation record | Visitor access | | --- | --- | ---: | --- | --- | --- | --- | | `6529NM-W-0024` | `6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-001` | 2 | Upstream presentation dimensions not retained | 3,056 × 4,600 px · 2,518,674 bytes | [Wave proposal, part 2](https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0) | May render in credited accession, Collection, acquisition, artist, Work, and scholarship contexts; no download, zoom, fullscreen, derivative, commercial reuse, or preservation-master claim | | `6529NM-W-0025` | `6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-002` | 3 | Upstream presentation dimensions not retained | 5,369 × 3,601 px · 1,813,285 bytes | [Wave proposal, part 3](https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0) | May render in credited accession, Collection, acquisition, artist, Work, and scholarship contexts; no download, zoom, fullscreen, derivative, commercial reuse, or preservation-master claim | | `6529NM-W-0026` | `6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-003` | 4 | Upstream presentation dimensions not retained | 5,000 × 3,292 px · 1,666,083 bytes | [Wave proposal, part 4](https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0) | May render in credited accession, Collection, acquisition, artist, Work, and scholarship contexts; no download, zoom, fullscreen, derivative, commercial reuse, or preservation-master claim | | `6529NM-W-0027` | `6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-004` | 5 | Upstream presentation dimensions not retained | 5,616 × 3,744 px · 1,540,870 bytes | [Wave proposal, part 5](https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0) | May render in credited accession, Collection, acquisition, artist, Work, and scholarship contexts; no download, zoom, fullscreen, derivative, commercial reuse, or preservation-master claim | | `6529NM-W-0028` | `6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-005` | 6 | Upstream presentation dimensions not retained | 5,964 × 4,768 px · 16,871,807 bytes | [Wave proposal, part 6](https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0) | May render in credited accession, Collection, acquisition, artist, Work, and scholarship contexts; no download, zoom, fullscreen, derivative, commercial reuse, or preservation-master claim | The proposal part number is a Wave presentation reference. The acquisition- independent Work IDs are typed projections; proposal aliases remain labelled source references. Arweave dimensions, byte counts, and hashes are technical observations of upstream source media. No Wave-upload byte size or responsive derivative is retained. ## Rights matrix | Use | Current disposition | Required record before change | | --- | --- | --- | | Cite the exact upstream URL in the selected offer's historical Wave context | Allowed with exact URL, credit, rights label, part, token link, receipt hash, and Work relation ([S38](../sources/source-register.md)) | Current canonical record | | Render the upstream photograph or show it on a standalone Work route | Credited institutional display is permitted in accession, Collection, acquisition, artist, Work, and scholarship contexts ([S38](../sources/source-register.md)) | Current accession and display record; no download, zoom, fullscreen, derivative, or preservation-master claim | | Public Collection page | Permitted with credit for the accessioned Works ([S38](../sources/source-register.md)) | Current accession and display record | | Download or full-resolution delivery | Blocked ([S38](../sources/source-register.md)) | Explicit distribution permission and reviewed delivery policy | | Crop, thumbnail, recompression, responsive `srcset`, or other derivative | Blocked ([S38](../sources/source-register.md)) | Component-specific derivative permission and source-fixity manifest | | IIIF manifest or tiled service | Blocked ([S38](../sources/source-register.md)) | IIIF-specific permission, retained source, and reviewed rights manifest | | Preservation copy or derivative | Blocked ([S38](../sources/source-register.md)) | Preservation permission, retained source bytes, PREMIS/provenance record, and approved storage plan | No JPEG, thumbnail, AVIF, WebP, responsive derivative, or IIIF manifest is generated or committed by this corpus. A delivered upstream byte can be saved by a viewer; the interface therefore makes no download-prevention claim. It makes no download offer, uses no eager large-source load, and exposes the observed dimensions and byte counts ([S38](../sources/source-register.md)). ## Display colophon > [Artist] / Magnum Photos, [title and place], [year]. © [artist]/Magnum Photos > 2022. All Rights Reserved. Wave-source historical proposal media. The colophon identifies the historical presentation ([S38](../sources/source-register.md)). It makes no claim of download, full-resolution delivery, preservation-master status, or Museum copyright ownership ([S38](../sources/source-register.md)).
Source record
Public presentation of the five photographs
Public presentation of the five photographs
# Public presentation of the five photographs *6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · [Publication record and suggested citation](../publication-record.md)* **Record ID:** `6529NM-PG-2026-001-MEDIA-DISPLAY-2026-08-11-001` **Issued:** 11 August 2026 **Scope:** the exact five photographs published with the selected Museum Wave proposal The downstream accession-media review of 12 August 2026 preserves the historical Wave URLs as publication evidence and assigns the exact, fixity-verified token sources as the current browser display sources. The five photographs are presented on the Museum website as the accessioned group *Conflict at Its Edges*. The display allows the acquisition to be studied as a five-work argument and connects each photograph to its artist, caption, object entry, project history, and curatorial reading. The website originally used the exact image locators already published in the signed Museum Wave proposal. The 12 August technical review supersedes that locator selection after real-browser delivery failed. The current display uses the exact Arweave token-source locators already bound to the same Works and fixity records. It does not make a new repository copy, derivative, crop, download, responsive image set, IIIF service, or preservation master. Each image remains bound to the proposal part in which it appeared and to the canonical Wave publication observation. All five images remain **All Rights Reserved**. As with works held by other museums, the Museum interprets ownership as permitting ordinary, credited institutional display, publication, and accessibility uses. That position does not transfer copyright or establish a commercial or general reproduction, derivative, licensing, or AI-training right. The Museum supplies no download, zoom, fullscreen, token-source, or reuse affordance. Credits and source context remain attached to every presentation. Display is distinct from accession authority. The gift acceptance, transfer, custody, title, technical, rights, and accession records independently support the completed accession and permanent-Collection membership. The description of the Moisés Saman photograph remains non-identifying. The Museum does not assign the depicted person's age or identity and does not infer consent or other facts absent from the public record.
Source record
Rights, technical identity, and proposal provenance
Rights, technical identity, and proposal provenance
# Rights, technical identity, and proposal provenance *6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · [Publication record and suggested citation](../publication-record.md)* ## Scope This dossier records what the proposal package and public chain/metadata observations establish about the five token-linked manifestations. It keeps token identity, source-image identity, copyright, title, custody, display permission, and Museum accession as separate facts. The five photographs are public Work projections for the completed acquisition. The donor's full-gift offer, five on-chain transfers, Museum custody, accession certificate, and permanent Collection membership are recorded in the completed accession. This dossier keeps those facts distinct from continuing provenance, rights, source image, and preservation stewardship ([S37](../sources/source-register.md); [S38](../sources/source-register.md)). ## Technical identity schedule The five-row schedule reproduces the token, curation, and acquisition-independent Work bindings in the source register and machine record ([S10–S14](../sources/source-register.md)). | Public Work | Work | Proposal alias | Token / curation | CAIP-19 | Archive reference | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | `6529NM-W-0024` | David Seymour, *Patrolling the border between the Negev Desert and Jordan* | `6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-001` | `127`; `2/3`; `127/225` | `eip155:1/erc721:0xe628b59d34f42b16c53f4d697f1ffd4d8d987b91/127` | `SED1952003W00003/23` | | `6529NM-W-0025` | Larry Towell, *Government soldiers in a church, Suchitoto, El Salvador* | `6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-002` | `145`; `2/3`; `145/225` | `eip155:1/erc721:0xe628b59d34f42b16c53f4d697f1ffd4d8d987b91/145` | `TOL1986003W00045/26` | | `6529NM-W-0026` | Micha Bar-Am, *Demonstration, Western Wall, Jerusalem* | `6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-003` | `97`; `2/3`; `97/225` | `eip155:1/erc721:0xe628b59d34f42b16c53f4d697f1ffd4d8d987b91/97` | `BAM1989009W02477/26C` | | `6529NM-W-0027` | Moisés Saman, *Tripoli, Libya* | `6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-004` | `44`; `1/3`; `44/225` | `eip155:1/erc721:0xe628b59d34f42b16c53f4d697f1ffd4d8d987b91/44` | `SAM2011005H2503/5482` | | `6529NM-W-0028` | Lorenzo Meloni, *Palmyra, Syria* | `6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-005` | `104`; `2/3`; `104/225` | `eip155:1/erc721:0xe628b59d34f42b16c53f4d697f1ffd4d8d987b91/104` | `MEL2016002G0401/4032` | The Work IDs above are the acquisition-independent identities in the governed public entity inventory. Proposal aliases remain typed source-package references; they are not accession numbers and do not replace the Work records. | Work | Metadata record | Source-image record | Observed JPEG bytes | Dimensions | SHA-256 | | --- | --- | --- | ---: | --- | --- | | Seymour #127 | Governed record S10 | Exact URI retained in complete-manifest evidence; no visitor link | 2,518,674 | 3,056 × 4,600 | `65abf8b6a182bb641787a43b40d10f0b6471357e5c90777aacccf9eb73ea1453` | | Towell #145 | Governed record S11 | Exact URI retained in complete-manifest evidence; no visitor link | 1,813,285 | 5,369 × 3,601 | `e60f2d2c56b702981597606315c6c77e07dedf4dd9a95804ae2da720d0f5bcee` | | Bar-Am #97 | Governed record S12 | Exact URI retained in complete-manifest evidence; no visitor link | 1,666,083 | 5,000 × 3,292 | `a59d8624c8da11758c5f1c0b64484229e4ffb68167b8e5783cdbafa9628b74df` | | Saman #44 | Governed record S13 | Exact URI retained in complete-manifest evidence; no visitor link | 1,540,870 | 5,616 × 3,744 | `cf1ec75dc4e3de3bcd85cffd9954c75395d9af2bff38374468440e403352b816` | | Meloni #104 | Governed record S14 | Exact URI retained in complete-manifest evidence; no visitor link | 16,871,807 | 5,964 × 4,768 | `49c45762f344fcc058a1f1167b01e9c298b1f4cff5e200e9033577f9c1023ad2` | The proposal package reports that all five metadata objects and linked JPEGs were resolved and SHA-256 verified on 5 August 2026. The Museum visually inspected the five upstream images on 8 August 2026; no JPEG or derivative was added to this repository. The local observations identify retrievable upstream resources at those observation times, not Museum preservation objects ([S37](../sources/source-register.md)). ## Chain and contract observation The common ERC-721 contract is `0xe628b59d34f42b16c53f4d697f1ffd4d8d987b91`. The proposal package records the following finalized-block observation: - Ethereum block `25,690,178`, hash `0x01a42cf70ba13f1ebefa607249fd9009baadb127f2a05fcb6e7573d943cb200c`; - block timestamp 5 August 2026, 17:20:23 UTC; - all five token IDs observed under owner `0x6daa633c23615a29471deafae351727867e7dad1`; - no token-level approval at that observation; and - three successful transfer events recorded for each token: mint, transfer to an address identified by Blockscout as Foundation Market, then transfer to the observed owner ([S16](../sources/source-register.md); [S37](../sources/source-register.md)). These are point-in-time chain observations. The owner address establishes none of the publicly credited offeror's authority, copyright ownership, legal title, or Museum custody. The local proposal records themselves say that offer, repository record, Wave submission, or threshold outcome does not complete gift acceptance or accession ([S37](../sources/source-register.md)). ### Current finalized recheck A later direct Ethereum JSON-RPC recheck at finalized block `25,714,155` (`0x1885deb`), hash `0x9ec59a4b6029e30f52491f6ebfbf34c521a4338056fa1a0b9a5cff12bb9ac767`, with block timestamp `2026-08-09T01:33:11Z`, retained the same point-in-time owner and approval observations. The contract read as `Magnum Photos 75` (`MPA75`) and reported ERC-721 support through ERC-165. All five `ownerOf` reads returned `0x6daa633c23615a29471deafae351727867e7dad1`; all five `getApproved` reads returned the zero address. The tokenURI reads were: | Token | tokenURI observation at block `25,714,155` | ownerOf | getApproved | | ---: | --- | --- | --- | | `#127` | Governed record S10; exact URI retained outside the visitor corpus | `0x6daa633c23615a29471deafae351727867e7dad1` | `0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000` | | `#145` | Governed record S11; exact URI retained outside the visitor corpus | `0x6daa633c23615a29471deafae351727867e7dad1` | `0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000` | | `#97` | Governed record S12; exact URI retained outside the visitor corpus | `0x6daa633c23615a29471deafae351727867e7dad1` | `0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000` | | `#44` | Governed record S13; exact URI retained outside the visitor corpus | `0x6daa633c23615a29471deafae351727867e7dad1` | `0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000` | | `#104` | Governed record S14; exact URI retained outside the visitor corpus | `0x6daa633c23615a29471deafae351727867e7dad1` | `0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000` | All fifteen mint, market, and current-owner transfer receipts returned success (`0x1`) and the expected ERC-721 `Transfer` event. The common observed path is mint from the zero address, transfer to an address labelled “Foundation Market” by Blockscout, and transfer to the owner above. The label is an explorer annotation, not a legal identity or title instrument: | Token | Mint | Market transfer | Current-owner transfer | | ---: | --- | --- | --- | | `#127` | [tx](https://etherscan.io/tx/0x23173c71a59f9709724537b928dde8f3ffe0e3162ab8e4f2d9d9ef787e17f0f3) | [tx](https://etherscan.io/tx/0xc924996c8aa8cc17534397c75d3ce78efdd6bd44b142a9de06c6283f3e582d03) | [tx](https://etherscan.io/tx/0x95239b5d68a414bc4bcb481490be08002e7d870ce6bf86dbd0c961ed8ee21a09) | | `#145` | [tx](https://etherscan.io/tx/0xa8fecaea9a0eafbabf61a186e87f9c5ba14158e7b9422752c19994c16109a1e4) | [tx](https://etherscan.io/tx/0xd2e8e53a076699c7fbaeccd6020181b026ab1d02004cbaafabc0d0fb0e756af6) | [tx](https://etherscan.io/tx/0xc0a96ebabb74d5e4ff2c670c247b27b2a1d23f0a46dabee968401ebf91a62bc0) | | `#97` | [tx](https://etherscan.io/tx/0x17057d388846e601dba0013475dc6642869058e89f90f63d231ed1b44864913b) | [tx](https://etherscan.io/tx/0xa72cfa2c0e6e8ec7066d69216c64d0e62de90726fca35b00cce20b6e0762f078) | [tx](https://etherscan.io/tx/0xa530bc66b7f14a85cb92f73b0f424cefb9bb69683dd3554b176daa38ebe47850) | | `#44` | [tx](https://etherscan.io/tx/0x6786a3a02c43dc5334b58f416eef60e90292a43b63af00b63116c124822aaf17) | [tx](https://etherscan.io/tx/0xa5a4bbda1fb5332d5b2aee821afd0c62bfa39cd66e68cb83a551380e7af5dfa4) | [tx](https://etherscan.io/tx/0x1bd65e9320e334578f7aad039973c78566ca1b5bf84faef800d5560a89fa50d4) | | `#104` | [tx](https://etherscan.io/tx/0x455147b6272e8924d8559dd8adc8543470e83dc13cba47605afe37b3a566554f) | [tx](https://etherscan.io/tx/0xb7a7e4612bc2ceef06f7ae430cb53564e3fb0cb19a4478ad45181268903d2c8d) | [tx](https://etherscan.io/tx/0x23315ad1425c91df68019f08e1ab92adcadb10cb69d9e5299deafaf1796d1747) | The public contract page identifies an EIP-1967-style proxy and reports implementation `0xe4e4003afe3765aca8149a82fc064c0b125b9e5a`. At the same observation the implementation slot pointed to that address; the standard EIP-1967 admin slot read zero; and the verified source reported contract owner `0xd8d005f66296068a2efc240f7e5910af52a86ee1` with administrators `0xdc6f5281bc65dee2d317e140eb19c927351dd86d` and that owner. The verified implementation ABI exposed `setTokenURI` and `setBaseTokenURI`, guarded by `adminRequired`. I found no public proxy-upgrade mutator in that verified ABI at the observation, but this is not an immutability claim: token URIs and the base URI are administratively mutable. Accession processing must re-read the tokenURI values before relying on a live pointer ([S15](../sources/source-register.md); [S53](../sources/source-register.md); [S55](../sources/source-register.md)). ## Rights and use disposition Each target token metadata record carries a photographer/Magnum copyright line and `All Rights Reserved` ([S10–S14](../sources/source-register.md)). The proposal package records token transfer as asserting no copyright or reproduction grant ([S37](../sources/source-register.md)). Magnum’s terms distinguish an NFT purchase from copyright in the associated photographic file ([S09](../sources/source-register.md)). Those statements are source records, not a complete chain-of-title or license determination. Museum observation `6529NM-WAVE-PUB-OBS-2026-08-08-001` records the signed seven-part Wave publication at `2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z`, including its part-content hashes. Its payload SHA-256 is `sha256:887d527756721cae1bf758a8205d1f5f7e0d1cebee2b3f27aafcab5271132995`; the complete Museum record has raw-file SHA-256 `sha256:b1f57fa0010bdaf0f9f21854f88e446e7f20b4a1921ab6fd075d4836c5920e58` ([S56](../sources/source-register.md)). A later live read command `punk6529bot drops get 002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0 --json` at `2026-08-09T02:04:21.7672652Z` returned signed `WINNER`, serial `1276093`, and parts 1–7. Its public-safe evidence record binds the six public media URLs to their reported MIME/status values and records no media for part 7. The canonical payload hash is `sha256:93e968562297fe5acff792e027f302b938ba6fa1ac88284754c4ba684d1266a2`; the complete Museum evidence record has raw-file SHA-256 `sha256:2d102b1e5ee4c448bad0631d3bb659949456d74a342f6203b3a1dd12d5f29d6a`. The receipt’s `ready` values describe the Wave publisher’s media state; they do not grant rendering or reproduction permission ([S54](../sources/source-register.md)). The CloudFront URLs are Wave-upload presentation media. The Arweave image URLs in the technical schedule are token-source locators reached through each token’s metadata. A matching byte hash observed in memory does not collapse those publication contexts, create preservation custody, or create a rights grant. The Wave URLs remain historical publication evidence. Current presentation uses the fixity-verified token-source images with the supplied artist and Magnum credits and the label `All Rights Reserved` in accession, Collection, acquisition, artist, Work, and scholarship contexts. The Museum interprets ordinary credited institutional display, publication, and accessibility in those contexts as permissible. No copyright transfer, commercial or general reproduction, derivative, licensing, download, preservation-master, or AI-training right is asserted ([S38](../sources/source-register.md); [S54](../sources/source-register.md); [S56](../sources/source-register.md)). The [Source and rights record](source-and-rights-record.md) and [media plan](media-plan.md) define that disposition. Download offers, full-resolution delivery claims, crops or derivatives, responsive recompression, IIIF, and preservation-master claims remain outside the current authority ([S38](../sources/source-register.md)). ## Accession boundary | Record or fact | Current state | | --- | --- | | Public Work lifecycle | `accessioned_into_permanent_collection` | | Collection membership | Five Works in the permanent Collection | | Canonical Work IDs | `6529NM-W-0024` through `6529NM-W-0028` | | Curated Acquisition | `6529NM-CA-2026-003` ([S37](../sources/source-register.md)) | | Proposal record | `6529NM-PG-2026-001` ([S37](../sources/source-register.md)) | | Accession number | `6529NM.2026.002` | | Object records | `6529NM.2026.002.01` through `6529NM.2026.002.05` | | Title binding to Museum custody | Executed for the donor's transferable interest in each tokenized object | | Donor authority/legal title | Accepted on the recorded full-gift declaration and completed transfers | | Copyright/reproduction/display position | Ordinary credited institutional display, publication, and accessibility; no copyright transfer or commercial/general reproduction, derivative, licensing, or AI-training right | | Museum custody/preservation | Five tokens in Museum custody; token-source images are display sources, not declared preservation masters | Sources: proposal records and live technical boundary [S37](../sources/source-register.md), exact token metadata [S10–S14](../sources/source-register.md), contract and token observations [S15–S16](../sources/source-register.md), and the retained public proposal media [S38](../sources/source-register.md).
Source record
Source and rights record
Source and rights record
# Source and rights record *6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · [Publication record and suggested citation](../publication-record.md)* ## Historical public Wave presentation media This record identifies the exact CloudFront JPEG URLs observed in the local proposal package for *Conflict at Its Edges*. It is a public research, credit, and rights record for the historical Wave presentation. The URLs remain upstream locators; the Museum repository retains no copy of the five photographs ([S38](../sources/source-register.md)). | Public Work | Work | Proposal part | Historical Wave context | Source dimensions / bytes | Credit in historical public Wave presentation | | --- | --- | ---: | --- | --- | --- | | `6529NM-W-0024` | David Seymour, Negev, 1952 | 2 | [Wave proposal, part 2](https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0); exact media locators remain in governed machine evidence | 3,056 × 4,600 px · 2,518,674 bytes | David Seymour, Negev, 1952. © David Seymour/Magnum Photos 2022. All Rights Reserved. [S38](../sources/source-register.md) | | `6529NM-W-0025` | Larry Towell, Suchitoto, 1986 | 3 | [Wave proposal, part 3](https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0); exact media locators remain in governed machine evidence | 5,369 × 3,601 px · 1,813,285 bytes | Larry Towell, Suchitoto, El Salvador, 1986. © Larry Towell/Magnum Photos 2022. All Rights Reserved. [S38](../sources/source-register.md) | | `6529NM-W-0026` | Micha Bar-Am, Jerusalem, 1989 | 4 | [Wave proposal, part 4](https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0); exact media locators remain in governed machine evidence | 5,000 × 3,292 px · 1,666,083 bytes | Micha Bar-Am, Jerusalem, 1989. © Micha Bar-Am/Magnum Photos 2022. All Rights Reserved. [S38](../sources/source-register.md) | | `6529NM-W-0027` | Moisés Saman, Tripoli, 2011 | 5 | [Wave proposal, part 5](https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0); exact media locators remain in governed machine evidence | 5,616 × 3,744 px · 1,540,870 bytes | Moisés Saman, Tripoli, Libya, 2011. © Moisés Saman/Magnum Photos 2022. All Rights Reserved. [S38](../sources/source-register.md) | | `6529NM-W-0028` | Lorenzo Meloni, Palmyra, 2016 | 6 | [Wave proposal, part 6](https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0); exact media locators remain in governed machine evidence | 5,964 × 4,768 px · 16,871,807 bytes | Lorenzo Meloni, Palmyra, Syria, 2016. © Lorenzo Meloni/Magnum Photos 2022. All Rights Reserved. [S38](../sources/source-register.md) | Every row carries the historical public presentation's `All Rights Reserved` label ([S38](../sources/source-register.md)). The exact URLs, credits, and the label **Wave-source historical proposal media** are retained as evidence. They are not rendered as Museum presentation media. The canonical `WAVE_PUBLICATION_OBSERVATION` preserves the signed Wave publication, parts 1–7, and their content hashes as observed on 2026-08-08 ([S56](../sources/source-register.md)). A later public-safe API observation confirms the public URL, MIME, and media-status fields observed on 2026-08-09 ([S54](../sources/source-register.md)). The canonical graph joins each photograph to its Work, Media Reference, Curated Acquisition, proposal, and canonical publication observation. Neither observation nor the graph supplies copyright or reuse authority. ## Rights posture The source metadata and local proposal records identify photographer/Magnum copyright notices and record token transfer without a copyright or reproduction grant. A URL, checksum, or upstream persistence locator identifies an observed resource; it does not transfer copyright, establish Museum custody, or authorize a new manifestation ([S10–S16](../sources/source-register.md)). The Museum interprets ordinary credited institutional display, publication, and accessibility of the accessioned works as permissible in accession, Collection, acquisition, artist, Work, and scholarship contexts ([S09](../sources/source-register.md)). The historical public presentation supports citation to its source record. The canonical graph now binds the accessioned Work, Media Reference, Curated Acquisition, proposal, Wave publication observation, and accession. The accession and rights records supply the current presentation basis. Copyright ownership, commercial or general reproduction, new crops or derivatives, licensing, download offers, responsive recompression, IIIF service, preservation-master claims, and AI training remain outside that basis ([S38](../sources/source-register.md)). ## Source record The exact part numbers, token-linked metadata observations, CAIP-19 identities, source fixity observations, and canonical joins are preserved in the complete Museum record; see [S38](../sources/source-register.md). This dossier is a presentation and rights summary for accession `6529NM.2026.002`, not a transfer of copyright or a general reuse licence.
Source record
media-source-continuity-amendment
media-source-continuity-amendment
{
"$schema": "../../../../../../schemas/magnum-scholarship-machine-record.schema.json",
"record_control": {
"revision": 1,
"record_status": "constructed",
"constructor": {
"actor_id": "codex-task:magnum-accession-media-continuity-2026-08-12",
"role": "constructor",
"constructed_at": "2026-08-12T07:37:56.984246Z"
},
"review": null
},
"local_profile": "6529NM_WP3_MAGNUM_MEDIA_SOURCE_CONTINUITY_AMENDMENT_V1",
"status": "active_downstream_accession_display_source",
"amendment_id": "6529NM-MEDIA-CONT-AMD-2026-08-12-001",
"authority": {
"presentation_authority_path": "records/proposed-gifts/6529NM-PG-2026-001/public/scholarship/dossiers/public-presentation.md",
"browser_review_finding_path": "records/proposed-gifts/6529NM-PG-2026-001/public/status-amendments/2026-08-12-media-source-continuity.md",
"decision_scope": "downstream_accession_technical_review_and_public_display_delivery"
},
"effective_at": "2026-08-12T07:37:56.984246Z",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T07:37:56.984246Z",
"supersession_reason": "Real-browser staging review found that the historical Wave-upload host did not deliver the first image reliably. Preserve every historical Wave locator and use the already observed, fixity-verified Arweave token-source locator for accession-context display.",
"superseded_machine_records": [
{
"path": "records/proposed-gifts/6529NM-PG-2026-001/public/scholarship/machine/integration-map.json",
"prior_revision": 2,
"prior_file_sha256": "sha256:bf3f88f57f413d2b76a4a57700a155d4888c80b76fc12555aa73daca3fa98685"
},
{
"path": "records/proposed-gifts/6529NM-PG-2026-001/public/scholarship/machine/wave-media-join.json",
"prior_revision": 2,
"prior_file_sha256": "sha256:f4f2cd48c9ec234570ddcd7fe8a964797b2143c86df2c4ca7b8cf58193eb964b"
},
{
"path": "records/proposed-gifts/6529NM-PG-2026-001/public/scholarship/machine/work-projections.json",
"prior_revision": 2,
"prior_file_sha256": "sha256:1b228dab187ffefcaee4090e13bdf3bb11067fb81b0ad64cdd8b09cc80895ae6"
}
],
"works": [
{
"work_entity_id": "6529NM-W-0024",
"media_reference_entity_id": "6529NM-MED-0003",
"prior_media_payload_sha256": "sha256:b531e9e307b3d215e3e316ba09009c456c7daa95bbd6389db8e02df25756c6fd",
"historical_wave_uri": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/drops/author_7ee51a67-07b7-4c91-87ed-464c56446c43/d498d837-3331-4650-a30e-27ca18d53521/magnum-75-127.jpg",
"display_token_source_uri": "https://arweave.net/VE0zO2N1zVTsbEUHdUFazEgvuMbmVOi6OfaWfQOWkaM",
"sha256": "sha256:65abf8b6a182bb641787a43b40d10f0b6471357e5c90777aacccf9eb73ea1453",
"bytes": 2518674,
"width": 3056,
"height": 4600,
"fixity_verified_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"display_policy": "historical_wave_locator_preserved_token_source_used_for_accession_display"
},
{
"work_entity_id": "6529NM-W-0025",
"media_reference_entity_id": "6529NM-MED-0041",
"prior_media_payload_sha256": "sha256:928e2e00eb3d9babec42ee68f37e8e312b19a3d2b4ee6bdc84692aa6ee572cd7",
"historical_wave_uri": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/drops/author_7ee51a67-07b7-4c91-87ed-464c56446c43/3e2fbdea-cf3c-4949-b3d2-f081cb12de00/magnum-75-145.jpg",
"display_token_source_uri": "https://arweave.net/r0bUW6Mtxq897pgig0V01Ad43S_Ldwv3tARjwmjrqpE",
"sha256": "sha256:e60f2d2c56b702981597606315c6c77e07dedf4dd9a95804ae2da720d0f5bcee",
"bytes": 1813285,
"width": 5369,
"height": 3601,
"fixity_verified_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"display_policy": "historical_wave_locator_preserved_token_source_used_for_accession_display"
},
{
"work_entity_id": "6529NM-W-0026",
"media_reference_entity_id": "6529NM-MED-0042",
"prior_media_payload_sha256": "sha256:d4384a1884d366850791060d840e8b02941fce53a8859467097cdd1696ab1a4d",
"historical_wave_uri": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/drops/author_7ee51a67-07b7-4c91-87ed-464c56446c43/2146f5f7-9352-47e6-bf60-cba46e52c07f/magnum-75-97.jpg",
"display_token_source_uri": "https://arweave.net/vRmOcFJRTK84ILXp2Tkjz5KoS4iXXbMqki7rxhTYlr4",
"sha256": "sha256:a59d8624c8da11758c5f1c0b64484229e4ffb68167b8e5783cdbafa9628b74df",
"bytes": 1666083,
"width": 5000,
"height": 3292,
"fixity_verified_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"display_policy": "historical_wave_locator_preserved_token_source_used_for_accession_display"
},
{
"work_entity_id": "6529NM-W-0027",
"media_reference_entity_id": "6529NM-MED-0043",
"prior_media_payload_sha256": "sha256:91552ced630489d480a88817cf46b6148c4312531e321ed17c40956e973f16f7",
"historical_wave_uri": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/drops/author_7ee51a67-07b7-4c91-87ed-464c56446c43/5d6d9bf0-7ff3-4afd-ac69-c6b34079fbf9/magnum-75-44.jpg",
"display_token_source_uri": "https://arweave.net/zLifpzu3AQWqjg59nuy9jeRqHPA5o5-LpwwBqNRcD5o",
"sha256": "sha256:cf1ec75dc4e3de3bcd85cffd9954c75395d9af2bff38374468440e403352b816",
"bytes": 1540870,
"width": 5616,
"height": 3744,
"fixity_verified_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"display_policy": "historical_wave_locator_preserved_token_source_used_for_accession_display"
},
{
"work_entity_id": "6529NM-W-0028",
"media_reference_entity_id": "6529NM-MED-0044",
"prior_media_payload_sha256": "sha256:7e2df8958badbbc2211ea8d22fa802269e21590f2366171938846b22b011e44c",
"historical_wave_uri": "https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/drops/author_7ee51a67-07b7-4c91-87ed-464c56446c43/4526b19e-76df-493b-86ac-105782c061ea/magnum-75-104.jpg",
"display_token_source_uri": "https://arweave.net/oz0t0DJj2BgFCux1WXskxisxvzV2KA0ukqaVbQ1Ckco",
"sha256": "sha256:49c45762f344fcc058a1f1167b01e9c298b1f4cff5e200e9033577f9c1023ad2",
"bytes": 16871807,
"width": 5964,
"height": 4768,
"fixity_verified_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"display_policy": "historical_wave_locator_preserved_token_source_used_for_accession_display"
}
],
"immutable_boundaries": [
"The Wave selection and its signed publication record are unchanged.",
"The historical Wave-upload locators remain preserved as publication evidence.",
"The five Work identities, rights labels, credit lines, accessibility descriptions, and fixity observations are unchanged.",
"This downstream accession technical decision establishes no title, custody, formal accession, preservation master, or permanent Collection membership."
]
}
Source record
Publication record: *Conflict at Its Edges*
Publication record: *Conflict at Its Edges*
# Publication record: *Conflict at Its Edges* | Field | Record | | --- | --- | | Publication | *Conflict at Its Edges*: five photographs of borders, access, and afterlives, 1952–2016 | | Edition | 1.0.0 | | Edition identifier | `6529NM-RP-0003/1.0.0` | | Institutional author | 6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research | | Publication date | 9 August 2026 | | Research cutoff | 9 August 2026 | | Museum status | Completed gift; accessioned into the permanent Collection as `6529NM.2026.002` | | Permanent Collection | Five Works accessioned as one gift under accession `6529NM.2026.002` | | Stable source root | [Magnum scholarship in the Museum repository](https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/tree/main/records/proposed-gifts/6529NM-PG-2026-001/public/scholarship) | | Research apparatus | [Source register](sources/source-register.md) and linked notes, technical records, rights record, and chronology | | Visitor edition | This publication record and 22 component manuscripts | ## Edition and citation The active Museum publication catalog binds this edition to an exact reviewed source commit, its closed visitor inventory, and the SHA-256 and Keccak commitments of the release manifest. The website's **Exact source** link opens the manuscript at that immutable commit. The `main` link above remains the editable source: readers may propose corrections or additions through a pull request without changing the identity of this edition. **Suggested citation:** 6529 Network Museum, “*Conflict at Its Edges*: Five Photographs of Borders, Access, and Afterlives, 1952–2016,” edition 1.0.0, 9 August 2026, Research Publication `6529NM-RP-0003`. The visitor edition includes the acquisition profile and narrative, catalogue essay, five artist profiles, five Work entries, Magnum Photos and Magnum Photos 75 profiles, and the supporting chronology, caption, rights, technical, media, and source manuscripts. Its Research Publication entity binds the 22 component paths as one dossier. Facts and quotations are supported in the numbered notes and source register. Interpretations belong to the Museum unless another voice is expressly attributed. The public proposal credits punk6529 as offeror; the completed accession record documents the authority and title basis for the gift. Four deterministic machine records remain in the complete repository manifest as governed research apparatus. They are not visitor documents or display authority, and their restricted evidence locators are not admitted to the visitor publication bundle. ## Revision history - **1.0.0 · 9 August 2026:** First complete scholarly edition prepared after Museum Wave selection, with object-level entries, artist and institutional profiles, catalogue and acquisition essays, caption and chronology research, rights and media boundaries, and deterministic machine records. - **1.0.1, 12 August 2026:** Added an append-only downstream accession-media source-continuity record after real-browser review found the historical Wave upload URLs unreliable for visitor delivery. Current display uses the exact governed Arweave token-source locators; historical Wave locators remain publication evidence and all rights and interface restrictions remain. - **1.0.2, 12 August 2026:** Corrected the current lifecycle to the completed five-Work gift accessioned as `6529NM.2026.002` and recorded the Museum's bounded interpretation of ordinary credited institutional display, publication, and accessibility rights. - **1.0.3, 16 August 2026** (`supersedes: 1.0.2`): Replaced an abstract closing formulation in the catalogue essay with a direct statement of the four evidentiary layers the interpretation keeps separate; no object, attribution, rights, accession, or source claim changed.
Source record
Conflict at Its Edges
Conflict at Its Edges
# Conflict at Its Edges *6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · [Publication record and suggested citation](publication-record.md)* ## Five Photographs of Borders, Access, and Afterlives, 1952–2016 *Conflict at Its Edges* brings together photographs by David Seymour, Larry Towell, Micha Bar-Am, Moisés Saman, and Lorenzo Meloni. Made across sixty-four years, the five works locate conflict in spaces where its meaning remains unsettled: a desert border, a church, a sacred precinct, a domestic interior, and an archaeological site after recapture. The selected proposal brings the five photographs together across two curations in Magnum Photos 75. The Museum publishes the relation as a curatorial proposition distinct from those source curations and from the larger Magnum archive. The Museum Wave selected the five-work acquisition, which is now a completed gift accessioned into the permanent Collection as `6529NM.2026.002`. This edition contains the resulting object identification, scholarship, provenance research, rights and technical review, contextual image presentation, and accession record. The five Works remain individually catalogued within the accession; provenance, source-image, rights, and preservation stewardship continue as active Museum work. ## The acquisition - [Conflict at Its Edges: acquisition profile](entities/conflict-at-its-edges.md) - [Conflict at Its Edges: catalogue essay](essays/conflict-at-its-edges.md) - [Acquisition narrative](essays/acquisition-narrative.md) The catalogue essay considers the group as an argument in documentary form. It follows the unstable boundary between an event and its evidence: where political force enters ordinary space, what a photograph can establish, and what remains beyond the frame. ## The five works | Date | Artist | Work | | --- | --- | --- | | 1952 | [David Seymour](artists/david-seymour.md) | [*Patrolling the border between the Negev Desert and Jordan*](works/01-david-seymour-127.md) | | 1986 | [Larry Towell](artists/larry-towell.md) | [*Government soldiers in a church, Suchitoto, El Salvador*](works/02-larry-towell-145.md) | | 1989 | [Micha Bar-Am](artists/micha-bar-am.md) | [*Demonstration, Western Wall, Jerusalem*](works/03-micha-bar-am-97.md) | | 2011 | [Moisés Saman](artists/moises-saman.md) | [*Tripoli, Libya*](works/04-moises-saman-44.md) | | 2016 | [Lorenzo Meloni](artists/lorenzo-meloni.md) | [*Palmyra, Syria*](works/05-lorenzo-meloni-104.md) | Each work page separates the photograph, its published caption history, its token manifestation, and the Museum's interpretation. Token IDs establish the five digital manifestations in the accessioned group; they do not determine the chronology or identity of the photographs themselves. ## Magnum contexts - [Magnum Photos](entities/magnum-photos.md) - [Magnum Photos 75](entities/magnum-photos-75.md) Magnum Photos is the photographer-owned cooperative founded in 1947. Magnum Photos 75 was an anniversary publishing project in 2022 that placed works from the archive in a tokenized setting. Neither entity is the Museum acquisition. The acquisition consists of the five independent works listed above, brought together under a new curatorial thesis. ## Research record - [Chronologies](dossiers/chronologies.md) - [Caption and evidence dossier](dossiers/caption-evidence.md) - [Source and rights record](dossiers/source-and-rights-record.md) - [Rights, technical, and provenance dossier](dossiers/rights-technical-provenance.md) - [Media plan](dossiers/media-plan.md) - [Source register](sources/source-register.md) The research distinguishes direct chain observation, issuer and institutional records, Museum technical examination, historical sources, and curatorial interpretation. Captions remain attributed to their publishers unless independently established. Unresolved archive references and variations remain visible in the dossiers. ## Images, rights, and source records The historical Wave publication and token metadata provide source records for the five photographs. The issuer records identify the works as All Rights Reserved. The Museum interprets ordinary credited institutional display, publication, and accessibility in accession, Collection, and scholarship contexts as permissible. That interpretation does not transfer copyright or grant commercial or general reproduction, derivative, licensing, download, or AI-training rights. The repository preserves citations, credits, dimensions, hashes, and non-identifying descriptions; the token-linked renditions are not described as preservation masters. The Museum-authored proposal cover is a separate CC0 graphic and is not a substitute for any of the five works. The [public Wave publication](https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0) is bound to Museum observation `6529NM-WAVE-PUB-OBS-2026-08-08-001`, which preserves the signed seven-part publication and its content hashes. A later public-safe API observation confirms the public media states and `WINNER` status. The five Works, their Media References, the acquisition, the observation, and accession `6529NM.2026.002` are joined in the governed technical record. The Wave material documents the historical proposal presentation; the later accession records establish the Museum's current acceptance, title, custody, and Collection relation. ## Record identities - Curated Acquisition: `6529NM-CA-2026-003` - Accession: `6529NM.2026.002` - Research Publication: `6529NM-RP-0003` - Works: `6529NM-W-0024` through `6529NM-W-0028` - Proposed gift and historical decision record: `6529NM-PG-2026-001` These identifiers keep the acquisition, works, proposal, token manifestations, and completed accession records distinct. Corrections are recorded as append-only amendments so that later scholarship can improve the record without erasing its history.
Source record
WP-3 source register
WP-3 source register
# WP-3 source register
*6529 Network Museum, Curatorial Research · Edition 1.0.0 · Published 9 August 2026 · Research through 9 August 2026 · [Publication record and suggested citation](../publication-record.md)*
Access date for web sources in this register: 8 August 2026 UTC, unless a
historical access/archive date is stated. The register is a research apparatus,
not a claim that every source is retained by the Museum. A URL is a locator;
the source's authority, scope, and limitations are recorded below.
## How to read the register
`A` is a direct chain, token, or byte observation; `B` is an authoritative
issuer, artist, estate, archive, institution, or governance source; `C` is a
Museum technical observation; `D` is a reputable third-party historical source;
`E` is Museum interpretation. The source class does not make a claim true by
itself. Each publication must preserve the source's attribution and limits.
## Magnum Photos and Magnum Photos 75
### S01 — Magnum Photos history
- **Source:** Magnum Photos, “Magnum Photos,” Magnum Photos Store.
- **URL:** <https://store.magnumphotos.com/pages/magnum-photos>
- **Type / class:** institutional history / B.
- **Supports:** founding history, photographer-owned cooperative context,
relation among archive, photographers, and public circulation.
- **Limit:** current institutional self-description; it is not a neutral
history of every organizational dispute or every assignment.
### S02 — Magnum membership and cooperative governance
- **Source:** Magnum Photos, “Submissions — Join the Cooperative.”
- **URL:** <https://www.magnumphotos.com/about-magnum/submissions>
- **Type / class:** institutional governance description / B.
- **Supports:** photographer-owned and operated cooperative, self-selecting
membership, nominee/associate/full-member stages, estates and correspondent
categories.
- **Limit:** describes the current public membership process, not the full
1947 legal history.
### S03 — Magnum photographer profiles and image commerce
- **Source:** Magnum Photos Store photographer collection pages for David
Seymour, Larry Towell, and Micha Bar-Am.
- **URLs:** <https://store.magnumphotos.com/collections/david-seymour>,
<https://store.magnumphotos.com/collections/larry-towell>,
<https://store.magnumphotos.com/collections/micha-bar-am>
- **Type / class:** institutional biographies and catalogue commerce / B.
- **Supports:** photographer biographies, Magnum membership/correspondent
status, selected books and practice descriptions.
- **Limit:** shop copy is selective and should not be treated as a complete
scholarly biography or assignment record.
### S04 — Magnum 75 first release
- **Source:** Magnum Photos, archived “Magnum 75 NFT Gallery” launch page,
captured 13 August 2022.
- **URL:** <https://web.archive.org/web/20220813041356/https://www.magnumphotos.com/shop/magnum-75-nft-gallery-page-280622/>
- **Type / class:** historical project announcement / B.
- **Supports:** seventy-six-image first selection, Alejandro Cartagena,
six-drop chronology, anniversary setting, 1/1 edition language, archive-to-
blockchain project statement.
- **Limit:** preserved announcement; it does not prove every advertised work
was minted or that later releases completed the announced plan.
### S05 — Magnum 75 second release and “indecisive moment” context
- **Source:** The Guardian, “The power of simplicity: Magnum’s latest NFT
collection in pictures,” 30 November 2022.
- **URL:** <https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/gallery/2022/nov/30/the-power-of-simplicity-magnums-latest-nft-collection-in-pictures>
- **Type / class:** contemporary journalism quoting project context / D.
- **Supports:** second-release chronology and Azu Nwagbogu’s curatorial frame.
- **Limit:** secondary reporting; the exact Nwagbogu statement is retained in
the token metadata and should be cited to S10–S14 for issuer wording.
### S06 — Magnum 75 collection snapshot
- **Source:** Foundation, archived `MPA75` collection page, captured 2 April
2023.
- **URL:** <https://web.archive.org/web/20230402111542/https://foundation.app/collection/mpa75>
- **Type / class:** historical platform collection record / A-B.
- **Supports:** historical contract/collection association and marketplace
presentation of the issued project.
- **Limit:** the marketplace index displayed 148 items in the retained
snapshot. It does not establish a canonical mint or issued-token count.
### S07 — Project chronology and third-release ambiguity
- **Source:** PetaPixel, interview with Magnum President Cristina de Middel,
18 October 2022.
- **URL:** <https://petapixel.com/2022/10/18/an-interview-with-magnum-photos-president-cristina-de-middel/>
- **Type / class:** contemporary interview / D with institutional speaker.
- **Supports:** period language describing an upcoming release and the
numbering conflict around the “third collection.”
- **Limit:** interview wording is not a completion record. The absence of a
verified public third release remains unresolved.
### S08 — Magnum current licensing contact
- **Source:** Magnum Photos, Contact Us.
- **URL:** <https://store.magnumphotos.com/pages/contact>
- **Type / class:** institutional contact/rights routing / B.
- **Supports:** licensing, cultural, digital, photography, and general contact
routes for future permission requests.
- **Limit:** a contact address is not written permission and no request/reply
is represented as having occurred.
### S09 — Magnum historical terms
- **Source:** Magnum Photos, archived Terms and Conditions, captured 18
November 2022.
- **URL:** <https://web.archive.org/web/20221129181808/https://www.magnumphotos.com/terms-conditions/>
- **Type / class:** historical transaction terms / B.
- **Supports:** token purchaser/copyright distinction, personal-display and
resale language, and the need to review whether the terms were incorporated
into each sale.
- **Limit:** archived web terms do not by themselves prove contract formation,
continuing enforceability, or a Museum public-display grant.
### S10–S14 — Exact token metadata
Each source is a public token metadata object reached from the contract's
`tokenURI` response and retained in governed technical evidence. The objects
were retrieved and parsed on 8 August 2026. Their issuer captions and
attributes are evidence of what the token records say, not independent proof
of the negative, assignment, consent, or copyright chain. Direct metadata and
image locators are withheld from the visitor corpus.
| ID | Token | Record | Key evidence |
| --- | ---: | --- | --- |
| S10 | #127 | Governed token metadata record | Seymour, Negev, 1952; archive `SED1952003W00003/23`; curation `2/3`; issuer title/caption; image pointer and fixity fields |
| S11 | #145 | Governed token metadata record | Towell, issuer spelling “Suchitito,” 1986; archive `TOL1986003W00045/26`; curation `2/3`; church and Guazapa caption |
| S12 | #97 | Governed token metadata record | Bar-Am, Jerusalem, 1989; archive `BAM1989009W02477/26C`; curation `2/3`; Women of the Wall/smoke-and-canister caption |
| S13 | #44 | Governed token metadata record | Saman, Tripoli, 2011; archive `SAM2011005H2503/5482`; curation `1/3`; separate house-targeted and minder-evidence air-strike claims, with the officials’ account explicitly “impossible to verify” |
| S14 | #104 | Governed token metadata record | Meloni, Palmyra, 2016; archive `MEL2016002G0401/4032`; curation `2/3`; Temple of Bel caption |
### S15 — Contract source and implementation
- **Source:** Blockscout verified contract source/API for
`0xe628b59d34f42b16c53f4d697f1ffd4d8d987b91`.
- **URL:** <https://eth.blockscout.com/api/v2/smart-contracts/0xe628b59D34F42B16C53F4d697f1FfD4d8d987b91>
- **Type / class:** public contract/source observation / A.
- **Supports:** ERC-721 implementation, the `Magnum Photos 75` / `MPA75`
contract identity, and the administrative token-URI/base-URI mutability
boundary. The verified implementation is separately identified in S55.
- **Limit:** verified source and public functions do not establish title,
artist authorization, or rights in the photographs.
### S16 — Token instances and transfer history
- **Source:** Blockscout token instances and address transaction history.
- **URLs:** <https://eth.blockscout.com/api/v2/tokens/0xe628b59D34F42B16C53F4d697f1FfD4d8d987b91/instances>,
<https://eth.blockscout.com/api/v2/addresses/0xe628b59D34F42B16C53F4d697f1FfD4d8d987b91/transactions>
- **Type / class:** public chain explorer observation / A.
- **Supports:** token IDs, mint/market/current-owner transfer events, and
platform labeling used in the proposal package.
- **Limit:** an explorer label such as “Foundation Market” is not a legal
identity or title instrument.
## Artist, archive, and exact-image sources
### S17 — David Seymour / Chim biography
- **Source:** Magnum Photos Store, David Seymour collection profile.
- **URL:** <https://store.magnumphotos.com/collections/david-seymour>
- **Type / class:** institutional biography / B.
- **Supports:** name, dates, Magnum founding, UNICEF work, Israel work, and
presidency after Capa.
- **Limit:** not an exact assignment record for #127.
### S18 — David Seymour institutional practice and Israel context
- **Source:** International Center of Photography, “Chim: Photographs by David
Seymour,” and related ICP press material.
- **URLs:** <https://www.icp.org/exhibitions/chim-photographs-by-david-seymour>,
<https://www.icp.org/sites/default/files/exhibition/credits/sites/default/files/exhibition_pdfs/icp_chim_wewentback_press.pdf>
- **Type / class:** museum exhibition and catalogue/press record / B.
- **Supports:** humanistic postwar practice, Israel work beginning in the early
1950s, original-publication/contact-sheet research leads.
- **Limit:** the public records do not cross-index the exact Magnum archive
number `SED1952003W00003/23` to a commissioner or first publication.
### S19 — David Seymour estate image record
- **Source:** David Seymour estate, public photo album.
- **URL:** <https://davidseymour.com/photo-album/>
- **Type / class:** estate image record / B.
- **Supports:** visually matching Negev/King Solomon’s Mines frame and the
estate’s place description.
- **Limit:** the public filename is not cross-indexed to the Magnum archive
number; visual match is not a chain-of-title opinion.
### S20 — Larry Towell biography and practice
- **Source:** Magnum Photos Store, Larry Towell collection profile.
- **URL:** <https://store.magnumphotos.com/collections/larry-towell>
- **Type / class:** institutional biography / B.
- **Supports:** Central American work, Nicaragua/Guatemala context, 1988
Magnum membership, landlessness theme, books and collections.
- **Limit:** no exact church, unit, assignment, or first-publication evidence
for #145.
### S21 — Larry Towell collection record
- **Source:** Art Windsor-Essex, Larry Towell collection search.
- **URL:** <https://artwindsoressex.ca/collection/advanced-search/?artists=87344>
- **Type / class:** museum collection record / B.
- **Supports:** institutional holdings and a route for comparing Towell’s work,
not the exact Magnum 75 frame's assignment history.
- **Limit:** this stable collection-search locator replaces an unavailable
individual object URL. It remains a collection-level record; object-level
match must be verified before citation as an exact frame.
### S22 — Micha Bar-Am biography and practice
- **Source:** Magnum Photos Store, Micha Bar-Am collection profile.
- **URL:** <https://store.magnumphotos.com/collections/micha-bar-am>
- **Type / class:** institutional biography / B.
- **Supports:** 1930 birth, 1948 service, Sinai and Six-Day War coverage,
1968 Magnum correspondent status, ICP and Tel Aviv Museum roles, and the
official profile's statement that he served as curator from 1977–1993.
- **Limit:** biography does not identify the exact 1989 demonstration date or
person in #97; the curatorial date differs from the archive release's
through-1992 wording in S44.
### S23 — Micha Bar-Am Archive exact-image page
- **Source:** Micha Bar-Am Archive, “Demonstration, Western Wall,
Jerusalem, 1989.”
- **URL:** <https://michabaram.com/artworks/78-micha-bar-am-demonstration-western-wall-jerusalem-1989/>
- **Type / class:** artist/archive object record / B.
- **Supports:** title, place, year, visual match, and archive naming variant
`BAM1989009W02477-26`.
- **Limit:** the public page does not explain the suffix difference between
`-26` and token metadata `/26C`, or name the central person.
### S24 — ICP exact-image record for Bar-Am
- **Source:** International Center of Photography, “Demonstration, Western
Wall, Jerusalem.”
- **URL:** <https://www.icp.org/browse/archive/objects/demonstration-western-wall-jerusalem>
- **Type / class:** museum archive object record / B.
- **Supports:** cross-institutional identification and a public record of the
image's title/place context.
- **Limit:** the page's date/subject language must be compared with the artist
archive and issuer caption rather than silently harmonized.
### S25 — Museum Wales exact-image comparison
- **Source:** Amgueddfa Cymru / Museum Wales, “Western Wall (Wailing Wall),
Jerusalem.”
- **URL:** <https://museum.wales/collections/online/object/3fc71e82-5678-30c0-a57d-e6e7fc70bca7/Western-Wall-Wailing-Wall-Jerusalem/>
- **Type / class:** museum collection record / B.
- **Supports:** title/place variant and cross-institutional image comparison.
- **Limit:** older “Wailing Wall” terminology is preserved as historical
cataloguing language; public cataloguing retains and explains the variant.
### S26 — Moises Saman biography
- **Source:** World Press Photo, “Moises Saman.”
- **URL:** <https://www.worldpressphoto.org/moises-saman>
- **Type / class:** institutional biography / B.
- **Supports:** birth/education, Newsday, Afghanistan/Iraq work, 2010 Magnum
membership, and long-term documentary practice.
- **Limit:** not an exact #44 assignment or consent record.
### S27 — Moises Saman, Tripoli and controlled access
- **Sources:** Magnum Photos Store, “Fine Print: Tripoli, Libya, 2011”; TIME,
“Theatre of War: Inside Gaddafi’s Libya.”
- **URLs:** <https://store.magnumphotos.com/products/fine-print-tripoli-libya-2011>,
<https://time.com/3778127/theatre-of-war-inside-gaddafis-libya/>
- **Type / class:** artist/agency record and contemporary reporting / B-D.
- **Supports:** exact title/period, the official Magnum fine-print record's
statement that Saman has been a full member since 2014, Saman’s broader
practice, and the government-managed access problem described in the
retained TIME excerpt.
- **Limit:** the TIME page may change or be unavailable; the retained excerpt
is the bounded evidence for its access account. The official damage claim
remains unverified; neither source identifies the person shown or proves consent.
### S28 — Libya 2011 press conditions
- **Source:** Committee to Protect Journalists, “Libya in 2011.”
- **URL:** <https://cpj.org/2012/02/attacks-on-the-press-in-2011-libya/>
- **Type / class:** press-freedom organization report / D.
- **Supports:** risk and press-access context for the Saman caption.
- **Limit:** contextual regional reporting, not a forensic determination of the
house or weapon in #44.
### S29 — Moises Saman later practice
- **Source:** Pulitzer Prize, “Moises Saman, contributor, The New Yorker.”
- **URL:** <https://www.pulitzer.org/node/moises-saman-contributor-new-yorker>
- **Type / class:** institutional award record / B.
- **Supports:** later practice and the artist’s sustained engagement with
conflict memory and documentary evidence.
- **Limit:** later recognition does not retroactively authenticate #44’s
assignment or caption.
### S30 — Lorenzo Meloni biography and project practice
- **Source:** Magnum Photos, Lorenzo Meloni photographer profile.
- **URL:** <https://www.magnumphotos.com/photographer/lorenzo-meloni/>
- **Type / class:** institutional biography / B.
- **Supports:** historicist approach, Middle East/North Africa projects,
*We Don’t Say Goodbye*, and 2020 full membership.
- **Limit:** biography is not a scene-specific authorization record.
### S31 — Palmyra access and the photographed aftermath
- **Source:** TIME, “Inside War-Ravaged Syria,” 7 April 2016.
- **URL:** <https://time.com/4284588/inside-war-ravaged-syria/>
- **Type / class:** contemporary reporting with photographer interview / D-B.
- **Supports:** the report's account of Syrian-government permission, March
2016 recapture, Meloni’s visit, remaining structures, and the Temple of Bel
loss.
- **Limit:** contemporary journalism. The direct page is an unstable access
locator; the retained excerpt in
`notes/wip/wp-3-magnum-research/06-lorenzo-meloni.md` preserves the bounded
claims and their attribution. Do not treat a reporter’s description as proof
of the soldier’s identity or the exact route of this frame.
### S32 — UNESCO Palmyra record
- **Source:** UNESCO World Heritage Centre, Palmyra news and site records.
- **URLs:** <https://whc.unesco.org/en/news/1341>,
<https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/23/>,
<https://whc.unesco.org/document/142423>,
<https://whc.unesco.org/en/news/1488>
- **Type / class:** intergovernmental heritage record / B.
- **Supports:** Palmyra's World Heritage significance and the 2015 destruction
chronology from news/1341; the Rapid Assessment's 23–27 April 2016 control,
access, damage, and demining account; and the April 2016 mission news.
- **Limit:** UNESCO does not identify the exact frame or its photographer.
The 2015 heritage-destruction record and the March/April 2016
control/access/demining record are separate observations.
## Regional histories and caption ethics
### S33 — El Salvador peace-accord context
- **Source:** United Nations Peacemaker, El Salvador peace-agreement records.
- **URL:** <https://peacemaker.un.org/el-salvador-peace-accords>
- **Type / class:** intergovernmental peace-process record / B.
- **Supports:** civil-war chronology and peace-process context for a restrained
reading of the church/persecution caption.
- **Limit:** does not identify the church, soldiers, operation, or Towell's
assignment in #145; the issuer's Guazapa wording remains an attributed
caption, not a finding of this source.
### S34 — Western Wall / Women of the Wall history
- **Source:** Women of the Wall, public history and organization records.
- **URL:** <https://womenofthewall.org.il/>
- **Type / class:** participant organization / B with situated perspective.
- **Supports:** movement history and the importance of not collapsing a
protester's identity into an unverified caption inference.
- **Limit:** participant source; compare with contemporaneous legal and news
records before asserting the exact day or event in #97.
### S35 — World Press Photo caption guidance
- **Sources:** World Press Photo, “What is required in captions?” and “Code
of ethics.”
- **URLs:** <https://www.worldpressphoto.org/contest/what-is-required-in-captions>,
<https://www.worldpressphoto.org/contest/code-of-ethics>
- **Type / class:** documentary-photography ethics standard / B.
- **Supports:** five Ws, source attribution for unseen actions, circumstances of
making, consent disclosure, vulnerable-subject care, anti-stereotyping, and
process transparency.
- **Limit:** contest guidance is not Museum law; it is adopted here as a
reasoned editorial benchmark, not as a retroactive judgment of the artists.
### S36 — Museum and digital-photo research models
- **Sources:** MoMA, “Object:Photo: The Project” and “The Photographic Record”;
IIIF Presentation API 3.0 and rights recipe.
- **URLs:** <https://www.moma.org/interactives/objectphoto/the_project.html>,
<https://www.moma.org/collection/terms/photography/the-photographic-record>,
<https://iiif.io/api/presentation/3.0/>,
<https://iiif.io/api/cookbook/recipe/0008-rights/>
- **Type / class:** museum practice and interoperability standards / B.
- **Supports:** object/context separation, public research layers, ordered
canvases, attribution, and machine-readable rights planning.
- **Limit:** these are models and standards, not evidence of rights in the five
photographs or proof that a future IIIF service may be launched.
### S37 — Local proposal and governance evidence
- **Sources:** proposed gift `6529NM-PG-2026-001`, the retained Wave
publication package, and live signed-drop API readback. The proposal and
voting records remain in the complete Museum record rather than the visitor
corpus.
- **Live observation:** drop `002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0`, serial
`1276093`, `drop_type PARTICIPATORY`, observed by `punk6529bot` at
`2026-08-08T09:06:07.985Z` UTC. This is historical-only after the later
signed-drop API readback.
- **Historical selection observation:** the signed-drop API readback at
`2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z` UTC reports the same drop as signed
`WINNER`, rank `1`, realtime rating `121603214`, and `29` raters. Its public
status was **Selected by Museum Wave**. The result records the Museum Wave's
selection of the exact five-Work proposal. The later accession record
`6529NM.2026.002` establishes formal acceptance, title transfer, Museum
custody, rights and technical review, accession, and permanent Collection
membership. Preservation and provenance enrichment continue after accession.
- **Type / class:** Museum constructed proposal plus live governance source / A-B.
- **Supports:** exact decision unit, five objects, proposal boundary, retained
block observation, package fixity, media labels, and historical selection.
- **Limit:** the proposal and Wave observations do not establish accession. The
10:15:02 observation superseded the earlier `PARTICIPATORY` readback for the
selection event; both are now historical beside accession `6529NM.2026.002`.
### S38 — Historical public Wave presentation media
- **Source:** [the seven-part Wave publication](https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0),
published to the 6529 Network Museum Wave on 6 August 2026 and retained in
the complete Museum record.
- **Type / class:** historical public publication record / B-C.
- **Supports:** historical work-part numbers, URL strings, credit lines, and
`All Rights Reserved` labels recorded in the local proposal package. The
machine join preserves the CloudFront URLs as historical URL evidence and
retains the Arweave URLs separately as token-linked source-image locators.
- **Historical Wave presentation:** [the exact seven-part Wave proposal](https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0) is the visitor-facing context. The five exact Wave-upload URL strings and token-linked source-image locators are retained only in the governed machine and evidence records.
- **Limit:** the retained Storm is historical proposal evidence. The
canonical enveloped publication observation in S56 binds the signed
seven-part publication and its content hashes. The later public-safe API
evidence in S54 confirms the exact part/media URL, MIME, and
publisher-status fields, but retains no raw media bytes or per-part content
hashes. `ready` is a Wave publication state, not display permission. Separate
accession-media continuity record retains those Wave locators as historical
evidence and selects the exact fixity-verified token-source images for
credited display in accession, Collection, acquisition, artist, Work, and
scholarship contexts. No copyright transfer, commercial or general
reproduction, derivative, licensing, download, preservation-master, or
AI-training right is inferred.
### S39 — Independent institutional history of Magnum
- **Source:** International Center of Photography, *Magnum Manifesto* and
related photobook symposium records.
- **URLs:** <https://www.icp.org/exhibitions/magnum-manifesto> and
<https://www.icp.org/browse/archive/media/magnum-photos-now-the-magnum-founders-first-books>
- **Type / class:** independent museum exhibition and curatorial/scholarly
program record / B-D.
- **Supports:** the founding and development of Magnum as a cooperative, the
relationship between its ideas and the visual memory of the second half of
the twentieth century, the exhibition’s use of prints, books, magazines,
video, and archival documents, and the photobook as a continuing concern of
Magnum membership.
- **Limit:** ICP’s exhibition and program are an institutional interpretation;
they are not a complete legal or social history of Magnum and do not resolve
any proposed object’s title or rights.
### S40 — Digital Camera World second-release report
- **Source:** Sebastian Oakley, “Magnum Photos drops its second 75-piece NFT
collection,” *Digital Camera World*, 1 December 2022.
- **URL:** <https://www.digitalcameraworld.com/news/magnum-photos-drops-its-second-75-piece-nft-collection>
- **Type / class:** contemporary project reporting / D.
- **Supports:** the reported second 75-image release, Azu Nwagbogu’s dialogue
with Magnum, and the six-drop schedule ending 13 December 2022.
- **Limit:** reporting is not a first-party release ledger and does not prove
that every announced image was minted or that a third curation was released.
### S41 — AFP Palmyra access account
- **Source:** Maher Al-Mounes, “Writing history in Palmyra,” Agence France-Presse,
1 April 2016.
- **URL:** <https://correspondent.afp.com/writing-history-palmyra>
- **Type / class:** contemporary eyewitness agency report / D.
- **Supports:** the reporter’s account of an army minder, mined ruins, mine
warnings, and permission to enter on the condition that journalists follow
army directions.
- **Limit:** this is AFP’s reporter account of access, not a caption or proof
that every described condition belongs to Meloni’s exact frame. The direct
page is a weak or unstable locator; the retained excerpt in
`notes/wip/wp-3-magnum-research/06-lorenzo-meloni.md` preserves the bounded
wording. TIME’s separate report remains the source for Meloni’s
permissioned visit and shadowing of government forces.
### S42 — United Nations Israel–Jordan armistice agreement
- **Source:** United Nations Acting Mediator, “Israel-Jordan General Armistice
Agreement,” 3 April 1949.
- **URLs:** <https://www.un.org/unispal/document/auto-insert-181069/>;
<https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/486014/files/S_1302_Rev.1-EN.pdf>
- **Type / class:** intergovernmental primary agreement / B.
- **Supports:** the date and terms of the 1949 General Armistice Agreement and
its armistice-demarcation framework.
- **Limit:** it does not identify Seymour’s location, patrol, assignment, or
the incident depicted in the selected frame.
### S43 — United States Department of State 1952 border records
- **Source:** Office of the Historian, *Foreign Relations of the United States,
1952–1954, The Near and Middle East*, documents on the Israel–Jordan frontier.
- **URLs:** <https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1952-54v09p1/d406>;
<https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1952-54v09p1/d606>
- **Type / class:** contemporary diplomatic primary record / B.
- **Supports:** documented 1952 frontier conditions and the broader record of
Israel–Jordan border incidents after the 1949 armistice.
- **Limit:** diplomatic reports are source-specific accounts and do not prove
the proposed photograph’s exact site, patrol, unit, or named incident.
### S44 — Micha Bar-Am Archive biography and date clarification
- **Source:** Micha Bar-Am Archive, press release for *The Last Photograph*,
July 2022.
- **URL:** <https://michabaram.com/usr/documents/exhibitions/press_release_url/6/the-last-pohotograph-proposal_july2022.pdf>
- **Type / class:** artist-archive biography / B.
- **Supports:** establishment of the Tel Aviv Museum of Art photography
department in 1977 and service as Senior Curator of Photography through 1992;
the archive separately dates his Enrique Kavlin Lifetime Achievement Award to
1993.
- **Limit:** a press release is not a complete employment file. The 1993 award
date must not be converted into a 1993 end date for the curatorial role.
### S45 — Larry Towell, *Gifts of War* exhibition record
- **Source:** Art Gallery of Windsor / e-artexte, *Larry Towell: Gifts of War*.
- **URL:** <https://e-artexte.ca/id/eprint/191/>
- **Type / class:** institutional exhibition record / B-D.
- **Supports:** organizer, exhibition scope, Canadian itinerary, and the
16 April 1988–14 October 1989 interval.
- **Limit:** the public record does not list individual photographs and does
not prove display of token #145.
### S46 — Larry Towell CV
- **Source:** Stephen Bulger Gallery, Larry Towell CV.
- **URL:** <https://www.bulgergallery.com/usr/library/documents/main/artists/110/towell-cv.pdf>
- **Type / class:** artist curriculum vitae / B.
- **Supports:** *Gift of War* (1988), *El Salvador* (1997), and exhibition and
publication history.
- **Limit:** a CV does not supply a page or plate crosswalk for #145.
### S47 — Larry Towell, *El Salvador* bibliographic record
- **Source:** Open Library, *El Salvador* by Larry Towell.
- **URL:** <https://openlibrary.org/books/OL655244M/El_Salvador>
- **Type / class:** library catalogue record / B-D.
- **Supports:** 1997 publication, 127-page extent, and the book's historical
subject context.
- **Limit:** catalogue copy does not establish the selected frame's inclusion
or assignment.
### S48 — Lorenzo Meloni, *We Don't Say Goodbye*
- **Source:** GOST Books, *We Don't Say Goodbye*.
- **URL:** <https://gostbooks.com/products/we-dont-say-goodbye>
- **Type / class:** publisher book and artist statement / B.
- **Supports:** 2013–2019 Iraq/Syria/Libya project, 2022 publication, fragmented
sequence, objects and writing recovered from rubble, and the project's
historical framing.
- **Limit:** the publisher page does not establish this exact Palmyra frame's
page, plate, or exhibition inclusion.
### S49 — Lorenzo Meloni, *The Collapse of the Caliphate*
- **Source:** Visa pour l'Image, 2017 press material.
- **URL:** <https://www.visapourlimage.com/files/a4c041c3/press_release_2017.pdf>
- **Type / class:** festival press release / B.
- **Supports:** the 2017 project/exhibition context and its cross-border
geography, including Kobanî, Palmyra, Sirte, and Mosul.
- **Limit:** the direct PDF may redirect or change state; retained research
notes record the page-state caveat and no exact-frame checklist was found.
### S50 — Micha Bar-Am, *Israel Diary, 1956–1982*
- **Source:** International Center of Photography exhibition record.
- **URL:** <https://www.icp.org/exhibitions/micha-bar-am-israel-diary-1956-1982>
- **Type / class:** museum exhibition record / B.
- **Supports:** Bar-Am's long photographic and institutional practice and the
exhibition's historical framing.
- **Limit:** it does not identify the exact 1989 demonstration date or person.
### S51 — Moisés Saman, *Discordia*
- **Source:** WARM Foundation, *Discordia* project record.
- **URL:** <https://warmfoundation.org/projects/discordia/>
- **Type / class:** artist/institution project and exhibition record / B.
- **Supports:** Saman's 2011–2014 Arab Spring project, 2016 self-published book,
exhibition history, and practice statement.
- **Limit:** the record does not establish that token #44 appears in the book
or an exhibition, and it is not a child-consent record.
### S52 — Larry Towell membership-date comparison
- **Source:** Henri Cartier-Bresson Foundation, Larry Towell dossier.
- **URL:** <https://www.henricartierbresson.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/Dossier-Larry-Towell.pdf>
- **Type / class:** institutional artist dossier / B.
- **Supports:** the dossier's “since 1989” Magnum membership wording and
Towell's Central American practice and publication history.
- **Limit:** the date differs from Magnum's public 1988 biography in S20; the
discrepancy is preserved rather than resolved here.
### S53 — Pre-accession finalized Ethereum observation, 9 August 2026
- **Source:** direct read-only Ethereum JSON-RPC observation through dRPC,
cross-linked to the public block explorers.
- **URLs:** <https://eth.drpc.org>, <https://etherscan.io/block/25714155>,
<https://eth.blockscout.com/block/25714155>
- **Type / class:** finalized chain-state observation / A.
- **Supports:** the pre-accession state at finalized block `25,714,155`
(`0x1885deb`), hash
`0x9ec59a4b6029e30f52491f6ebfbf34c521a4338056fa1a0b9a5cff12bb9ac767`,
timestamp `2026-08-09T01:33:11Z`; contract name `Magnum Photos 75`, symbol
`MPA75`, ERC-165 ERC-721 support; the five exact tokenURI reads; all five
`ownerOf` reads then returning
`0x6daa633c23615a29471deafae351727867e7dad1`; and zero token-level
approvals. The fifteen linked transfer receipts each returned status `0x1`
with the expected `Transfer` event.
- **Safe recheck commands:**
```powershell
curl.exe -sS https://eth.drpc.org -H "content-type: application/json" --data-raw '{"jsonrpc":"2.0","id":1,"method":"eth_getBlockByNumber","params":["0x1885deb",false]}'
curl.exe -sS https://eth.drpc.org -H "content-type: application/json" --data-raw '{"jsonrpc":"2.0","id":2,"method":"eth_call","params":[{"to":"0xe628b59d34f42b16c53f4d697f1ffd4d8d987b91","data":"0x6352211e000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000007f"},"0x1885deb"]}'
```
- **Limit:** this is a historical pre-accession observation, superseded for
current custody by S38. The block and calls are time-bound chain observations.
They do not
establish donor authority, legal title, copyright, Museum custody, formal
acceptance, accession, Collection membership, or display permission. An
explorer market label does not establish legal title.
### S54 — Live public-safe Wave publication observation
- **Source:** live authenticated `punk6529bot` drop read, filtered in memory to
the public publication fields only.
- **Evidence ID:** `6529NM-WAVE-PUB-OBS-2026-08-09-001`; retained in the
complete Museum record.
- **Type / class:** live governance/publication observation with Museum
technical filtering / A-C.
- **Source command:** `punk6529bot drops get
002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0 --json`
- **Receipt SHA-256:**
`sha256:2d102b1e5ee4c448bad0631d3bb659949456d74a342f6203b3a1dd12d5f29d6a`.
- **Canonical payload SHA-256:**
`sha256:93e968562297fe5acff792e027f302b938ba6fa1ac88284754c4ba684d1266a2`.
- **Supports:** Wave `6529 Network Museum`, drop
`002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0`, serial `1276093`, signed `WINNER`
state observed at `2026-08-09T02:04:21.7672652Z`, and parts 1–7 with only
their public media URL, MIME, and `ready` status bindings; part 7 has no
media. The canonicalization is recorded in the evidence JSON and excludes
author/profile, rater/profile/reaction, address, credential, and other
non-media response fields.
- **Limit:** this receipt records Wave publication metadata and public URL
bindings only. `ready` is not a rights or display grant. WINNER/signed state
does not establish donor authority, legal title, copyright, custody,
acceptance, accession, Collection status, or permission to render, download,
zoom, fullscreen, derive, or preserve the images. The CloudFront URLs remain
Wave-upload presentation media; the Arweave URLs in S10–S14 remain separate
token-source locators.
### S55 — Proxy, implementation, and URI mutability boundary
- **Source:** Blockscout verified contract/proxy API and implementation source.
- **URLs:** <https://eth.blockscout.com/api/v2/smart-contracts/0xe628b59D34F42B16C53F4d697f1FfD4d8d987b91>,
<https://eth.blockscout.com/api/v2/smart-contracts/0xe4E4003afE3765Aca8149a82fc064C0b125B9e5a>
- **Type / class:** public verified source and proxy observation / A.
- **Supports:** the explorer's EIP-1967-style proxy classification and
implementation `0xe4e4003afe3765aca8149a82fc064c0b125b9e5a`; the observed
implementation-slot match; a zero standard EIP-1967 admin slot; contract
owner `0xd8d005f66296068a2efc240f7e5910af52a86ee1`; administrators
`0xdc6f5281bc65dee2d317e140eb19c927351dd86d` and that owner; and verified
`setTokenURI` / `setBaseTokenURI` functions guarded by `adminRequired`.
- **Limit:** no public proxy-upgrade mutator was found in the verified ABI at
the observation, but this is not a contract-immutability guarantee. URI and
base-URI state can be administratively changed; future records must re-read
tokenURI values. Verified source does not establish title, authorization, or
photograph rights.
### S56 — Canonical signed Wave publication observation
- **Source:** enveloped Museum `WAVE_PUBLICATION_OBSERVATION` recorded from the
signed 6529 Network Museum Wave publication.
- **Observation ID:** `6529NM-WAVE-PUB-OBS-2026-08-08-001`; retained in the
complete Museum record.
- **Observation:** `6529NM-WAVE-PUB-OBS-2026-08-08-001`, recorded at
`2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z` for drop
`002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0`, serial `1276093`.
- **Payload SHA-256:**
`sha256:887d527756721cae1bf758a8205d1f5f7e0d1cebee2b3f27aafcab5271132995`.
- **Record SHA-256:**
`sha256:b1f57fa0010bdaf0f9f21854f88e446e7f20b4a1921ab6fd075d4836c5920e58`.
- **Supports:** the signed `WINNER` publication, exact parts 1–7, part content
hashes, and the canonical publication identity used by the Work, Media
Reference, proposal, and Curated Acquisition graph.
- **Limit:** this is a publication observation, not a copyright, display,
donor-authority, legal-title, custody, acceptance, accession, preservation,
or Collection-membership record. The later public-safe observation in S54
supplements it with a fresh API read of public media fields; it does not
supersede this canonical observation.
## Open source requests
The following are deliberately not represented as facts because no public
reply is retained:
1. Magnum archive/rights/digital teams: assignment sheets, caption cards,
contact sheets, source-file/negative dates, first publication, token-edition
authorization, and current Museum/public-display licensing.
2. David Seymour estate: cross-index from `PAR116258` and the King Solomon’s
Mines frame to `SED1952003W00003/23`, exact sequence, assignment, and
publication.
3. Larry Towell or archive: church identity, unit/operation, assignment,
first publication, and spelling correction for “Suchitito.”
4. Micha Bar-Am Archive: meaning of `/26C`, exact day, event description,
subject identity, and any prior caption history.
5. Moises Saman/Magnum: exact date/house, access conditions, source of the
official account, and child-protection/consent record.
6. Lorenzo Meloni/Magnum: exact sequence, source/caption history, permission
terms for Palmyra, and identity/status of the soldier.
7. Donor: signed statement of five-work group formation, title, public credit,
title authority, and intended gift instrument.
Absence of a reply is not evidence for or against any claim.
Source record
wave-status-observation-2026-08-08
wave-status-observation-2026-08-08
{
"$schema": "https://6529networkmuseum.org/schemas/record-envelope-v1.json",
"envelope": {
"contentHash": {
"algorithm": 1,
"canonicalizationId": "0x886c7c89c308c459ca8a626e0ef36a5ea9f4c7a7b56aaf86c71a2ddf3b4f9044",
"digest": "0x3bd4700866ef0b026d22de02eb5776d1058a3c41b6574affa27d7f409a579003"
},
"effectiveAt": 1786184102,
"recordType": "WAVE_STATUS_OBSERVATION",
"schemaId": "0xfe0b5244859ffb994766ff3aeace88f12961e07bb97941c647044327737c9be1",
"signatureHash": {
"algorithm": 2,
"canonicalizationId": "0x886c7c89c308c459ca8a626e0ef36a5ea9f4c7a7b56aaf86c71a2ddf3b4f9044",
"digest": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000"
},
"signatureScheme": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"subjectId": "0x5fad62701f87c63609c73c36dcf333934f311a75bfc3625b8abc2f509b79a7ba",
"uri": "https://6529networkmuseum.org/records/proposed-gifts/6529NM-PG-2026-001/wave-status-observation-2026-08-08.json"
},
"payload": {
"constructor": {
"id": "codex-task:magnum-completed-accession-correction-2026-08-12",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"role": "constructor"
},
"created_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"drop_id": "002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0",
"drop_type": "WINNER",
"effective_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Original PARTICIPATORY proposal observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback (is_signed=true)",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"non_effects": [
"acceptance_not_established",
"transfer_not_established",
"title_not_established",
"custody_not_established",
"rights_not_established",
"technical_not_established",
"preservation_not_established",
"accession_not_established",
"collection_membership_not_established"
],
"observation_id": "6529NM-WAVE-OBS-2026-08-08-001",
"observation_method": "signed_drop_api_readback",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"payload_sha256": "sha256:c6ba375faf6f4dc7b77cd183cd434470aa3ff2771aef0de1117d17d1c6768cb9",
"prior_observation": {
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"source_record_id": "6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"source_record_path": null,
"source_repository_visibility": "complete_manifest_only",
"source_status": "PARTICIPATORY",
"source_url": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
"proposal_id": "6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"rater_count": 29,
"rating": 121603214,
"realtime_rating": 121603214,
"record_id": "6529NM-WAVE-OBS-2026-08-08-001",
"record_status": "reviewed",
"record_type": "WAVE_STATUS_OBSERVATION",
"record_version": "1.0.0",
"references": [
"6529NM-PG-2026-001"
],
"review_status": "reviewed",
"reviewer": {
"id": "codex-reviewer:vera-molnar-a9-copy-correction-independent",
"outcome": "approved",
"reviewed_at": "2026-08-23T15:10:17.867Z",
"reviewed_commit": "3eab50914a90c079fe0383624e760fc0a954e709",
"reviewed_manifest_keccak": "0xd3b728ca1bdbbf99602d626df93b6903bbacf624f2ef71e064412654e71cf313",
"reviewed_manifest_sha256": "sha256:f672c3503baa823cf4af5eac3bf0513b6b25de6e2674902273cb778f4e771080",
"reviewer_ids": [
"codex-reviewer:vera-molnar-a9-copy-correction-independent"
],
"role": "reviewer"
},
"schema_id": "0xfe0b5244859ffb994766ff3aeace88f12961e07bb97941c647044327737c9be1",
"selection_effect": "selected_by_museum_wave_acquisition_review_in_progress",
"serial_no": 1276093,
"signed": true,
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-PG-2026-001"
],
"source_status": "WINNER",
"source_url": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0",
"subject_id": "6529NM-WAVE-OBS-2026-08-08-001",
"visibility": "public",
"wave_id": "5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d"
}
}
Source record
6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002
6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002
{
"$schema": "https://6529networkmuseum.org/schemas/record-envelope-v1.json",
"envelope": {
"contentHash": {
"algorithm": 1,
"canonicalizationId": "0x886c7c89c308c459ca8a626e0ef36a5ea9f4c7a7b56aaf86c71a2ddf3b4f9044",
"digest": "0x4fde8fb2c97edc7f49d95dadac5720ded007548101fbb2bc7d2e68cc1acf93a1"
},
"effectiveAt": 1786573476,
"recordType": "PUBLIC_ENTITY",
"schemaId": "0xd8aef6592fe156c4c3c10e59de540f5cdf8b130eedca322e0e22b30764bee1a9",
"signatureHash": {
"algorithm": 2,
"canonicalizationId": "0x886c7c89c308c459ca8a626e0ef36a5ea9f4c7a7b56aaf86c71a2ddf3b4f9044",
"digest": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000"
},
"signatureScheme": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"subjectId": "0x1bc59c4e2aec7f20fe947781742b9e3aaf7d1367bd212fda48849c9e75ae306f",
"uri": "https://6529networkmuseum.org/records/entities/6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002.json"
},
"payload": {
"canonical_route": null,
"constructor": {
"id": "codex-task:magnum-completed-accession-correction-2026-08-12",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"role": "constructor"
},
"created_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"effective_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"entity_id": "6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002",
"entity_status": "published",
"entity_type": "ACCESSION",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Magnum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Magnum accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
}
],
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"page_exposure": "relational_only",
"payload_sha256": "sha256:32a06f5a3e084bd6a61b8a2445cb8552c1d417d43b6e0c561b4265e52cd610cb",
"preferred_label": "Conflict at Its Edges accession 6529NM.2026.002",
"profile": {
"accession_number": "6529NM.2026.002",
"accession_status": "complete",
"admitted_work_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-W-0024",
"6529NM-W-0025",
"6529NM-W-0026",
"6529NM-W-0027",
"6529NM-W-0028"
],
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Magnum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Magnum accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
}
],
"profile_type": "ACCESSION",
"source_accession_record_id": "6529NM-ACC-2026-002"
},
"public_slug": null,
"record_id": "6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002",
"record_status": "reviewed",
"record_type": "PUBLIC_ENTITY",
"record_version": "1.0.0",
"references": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM-W-0024",
"6529NM-W-0025",
"6529NM-W-0026",
"6529NM-W-0027",
"6529NM-W-0028",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.GAA-01"
],
"review_status": "reviewed",
"reviewer": {
"id": "codex-reviewer:vera-molnar-a9-copy-correction-independent",
"outcome": "approved",
"reviewed_at": "2026-08-23T15:10:17.867Z",
"reviewed_commit": "3eab50914a90c079fe0383624e760fc0a954e709",
"reviewed_manifest_keccak": "0xd3b728ca1bdbbf99602d626df93b6903bbacf624f2ef71e064412654e71cf313",
"reviewed_manifest_sha256": "sha256:f672c3503baa823cf4af5eac3bf0513b6b25de6e2674902273cb778f4e771080",
"reviewer_ids": [
"codex-reviewer:vera-molnar-a9-copy-correction-independent"
],
"role": "reviewer"
},
"schema_id": "0xd8aef6592fe156c4c3c10e59de540f5cdf8b130eedca322e0e22b30764bee1a9",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM-W-0024",
"6529NM-W-0025",
"6529NM-W-0026",
"6529NM-W-0027",
"6529NM-W-0028",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.GAA-01"
],
"status_observation": {
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Magnum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Magnum accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
}
],
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"status_label": "published"
},
"subject_id": "6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002",
"visibility": "public"
}
}
Source record
6529NM-CA-2026-003
6529NM-CA-2026-003
{
"$schema": "https://6529networkmuseum.org/schemas/record-envelope-v1.json",
"envelope": {
"contentHash": {
"algorithm": 1,
"canonicalizationId": "0x886c7c89c308c459ca8a626e0ef36a5ea9f4c7a7b56aaf86c71a2ddf3b4f9044",
"digest": "0xc62ed02f44f0d20c38c6bd8cb2eacfe626891980c16faa4b80e0ad4d6c1359a6"
},
"effectiveAt": 1786573476,
"recordType": "PUBLIC_ENTITY",
"schemaId": "0xd8aef6592fe156c4c3c10e59de540f5cdf8b130eedca322e0e22b30764bee1a9",
"signatureHash": {
"algorithm": 2,
"canonicalizationId": "0x886c7c89c308c459ca8a626e0ef36a5ea9f4c7a7b56aaf86c71a2ddf3b4f9044",
"digest": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000"
},
"signatureScheme": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"subjectId": "0xcf4156a3b9c7c3c5fe6426af4171b9a5a4c7c41280004028f96970f089e76954",
"uri": "https://6529networkmuseum.org/records/entities/6529NM-CA-2026-003.json"
},
"payload": {
"canonical_route": "/museum/network/acquisitions/conflict-at-its-edges",
"constructor": {
"id": "codex-task:magnum-completed-accession-correction-2026-08-12",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"role": "constructor"
},
"created_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"effective_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"entity_id": "6529NM-CA-2026-003",
"entity_status": "published",
"entity_type": "CURATED_ACQUISITION",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback (is_signed=true)",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Original proposed gift record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "E",
"label": "Curated acquisition thesis",
"observed_at": "2026-08-09T00:00:00Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/proposed-gifts/6529NM-PG-2026-001/public/scholarship/essays/conflict-at-its-edges.md"
},
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Completed public accession status",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/proposed-gifts/6529NM-PG-2026-001/public/status-amendments/2026-08-12-accession-completed.md"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Completed accession status",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/proposed-gifts/6529NM-PG-2026-001/public/status-amendments/2026-08-12-accession-completed.md"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Contextual public presentation authority",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/proposed-gifts/6529NM-PG-2026-001/public/scholarship/dossiers/public-presentation.md"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession-media source continuity amendment",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T07:37:56.984246Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/proposed-gifts/6529NM-PG-2026-001/public/status-amendments/2026-08-12-media-source-continuity.md"
}
],
"media_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-MED-0004"
],
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"page_exposure": "canonical_page",
"payload_sha256": "sha256:b296ee15028640250df66669e7d487ef88228743b56dea9ce66af622df5adeef",
"preferred_label": "Conflict at Its Edges",
"profile": {
"acquisition_method": "donation",
"collection_effect": "permanent_collection",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback (is_signed=true)",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Original proposed gift record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "E",
"label": "Curated acquisition thesis",
"observed_at": "2026-08-09T00:00:00Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/proposed-gifts/6529NM-PG-2026-001/public/scholarship/essays/conflict-at-its-edges.md"
},
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Completed public accession status",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/proposed-gifts/6529NM-PG-2026-001/public/status-amendments/2026-08-12-accession-completed.md"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Completed accession status",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/proposed-gifts/6529NM-PG-2026-001/public/status-amendments/2026-08-12-accession-completed.md"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Contextual public presentation authority",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T23:15:00Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/proposed-gifts/6529NM-PG-2026-001/public/scholarship/dossiers/public-presentation.md"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession-media source continuity amendment",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T07:37:56.984246Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/proposed-gifts/6529NM-PG-2026-001/public/status-amendments/2026-08-12-media-source-continuity.md"
}
],
"independent_acquisition_facts": {
"custody": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
}
],
"notes": "Finalized Ethereum observations place all five token manifestations in the Museum Safe.",
"status": "verified"
},
"display": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Source record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/rights/6529NM.2026.002.RIGHTS.01.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "C",
"label": "Source record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/technical/6529NM.2026.002.01.json"
}
],
"notes": "The five works are ready for credited, contextual Museum display subject to their recorded rights and source conditions.",
"status": "verified_with_conditions"
},
"mint": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Ethereum custody and token observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
}
],
"notes": "Finalized Ethereum chain evidence verifies the existing ERC-721 token manifestations independently of title, custody, rights, and accession.",
"status": "verified"
},
"payment": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Source record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/gift-acceptance-authorization.json"
}
],
"notes": "The completed acquisition is a gift; no Museum purchase is recorded.",
"status": "not_applicable"
},
"preservation": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "C",
"label": "Source record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/technical/6529NM.2026.002.01.json"
}
],
"notes": "Source-image retention, redundant replication, and continuing provenance enrichment are active stewardship work.",
"status": "in_progress"
},
"rights": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Source record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/rights/6529NM.2026.002.RIGHTS.01.json"
}
],
"notes": "The works remain All Rights Reserved. Credited, contextual Museum display is documented; copyright transfer and broader reuse rights are not claimed.",
"status": "verified_with_conditions"
},
"technical": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "C",
"label": "Source record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/technical/6529NM.2026.002.01.json"
}
],
"notes": "Token identity, transfer receipts, ownership, metadata, source-image fixity, and display conditions are documented for the accession.",
"status": "verified_with_conditions"
},
"title": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Source record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/gift-acceptance-authorization.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Source record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
}
],
"notes": "The donor's full-gift offer, formal acceptance, and object schedule bind title to the five token manifestations. Copyright is not transferred.",
"status": "verified"
}
},
"lifecycle": {
"as_of": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
}
],
"status": "accessioned_into_permanent_collection"
},
"lifecycle_observations": [
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Original PARTICIPATORY proposal observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"notes": "The original PARTICIPATORY proposal observation remains part of the append-only lifecycle history.",
"observation_id": "6529NM-CA-OBS-0003",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-PG-2026-001"
],
"source_status": "PARTICIPATORY",
"status": "proposed_in_museum_wave"
},
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback (is_signed=true)",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Museum Wave drop page readback",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
}
],
"notes": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback selects the proposed identity for Museum acquisition review only; it creates no accession or Collection membership.",
"observation_id": "6529NM-CA-OBS-0004",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-WAVE-OBS-2026-08-08-001"
],
"source_status": "WINNER",
"status": "selected_by_museum_wave_acquisition_review_in_progress"
},
{
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "A",
"label": "Finalized Museum custody observation",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/evidence/magnum-75-custody/summary.json"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Accession certificate",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/accessions/6529NM.2026.002/accession-certificate.json"
}
],
"notes": "The completed gift is formally accepted and its five Works are accessioned into the permanent Collection.",
"observation_id": "6529NM-CA-OBS-0005",
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.GAA-01"
],
"source_status": "accessioned",
"status": "accessioned_into_permanent_collection"
}
],
"profile_type": "CURATED_ACQUISITION",
"program_or_pathway": {
"entity_ids": [
"6529NM-AP-ENT-0001"
],
"kind": "acquisition_program",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-WAVE-OBS-2026-08-08-001"
]
},
"public_credit": "Gift of punk6529",
"source_work_record_ids": [
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-001",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-002",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-003",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-004",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-005",
"6529NM.2026.002.01",
"6529NM.2026.002.02",
"6529NM.2026.002.03",
"6529NM.2026.002.04",
"6529NM.2026.002.05"
],
"thesis": "Five photographs made between 1952 and 2016 approach conflict through borders, religious and domestic space, smoke, ruins, and the uncertain aftermath of violence. Accessioned together from two Magnum Photos 75 curations, they test what documentary evidence can show and what remains unresolved.",
"title": "Conflict at Its Edges",
"work_entity_ids": [
"6529NM-W-0024",
"6529NM-W-0025",
"6529NM-W-0026",
"6529NM-W-0027",
"6529NM-W-0028"
]
},
"public_slug": "conflict-at-its-edges",
"record_id": "6529NM-CA-2026-003",
"record_status": "reviewed",
"record_type": "PUBLIC_ENTITY",
"record_version": "1.0.0",
"references": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-001",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-002",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-003",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-004",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-005",
"6529NM-W-0024",
"6529NM-W-0025",
"6529NM-W-0026",
"6529NM-W-0027",
"6529NM-W-0028",
"6529NM-WAVE-OBS-2026-08-08-001",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.01",
"6529NM.2026.002.02",
"6529NM.2026.002.03",
"6529NM.2026.002.04",
"6529NM.2026.002.05",
"6529NM.2026.002.GAA-01"
],
"review_status": "reviewed",
"reviewer": {
"id": "codex-reviewer:vera-molnar-a9-copy-correction-independent",
"outcome": "approved",
"reviewed_at": "2026-08-23T15:10:17.867Z",
"reviewed_commit": "3eab50914a90c079fe0383624e760fc0a954e709",
"reviewed_manifest_keccak": "0xd3b728ca1bdbbf99602d626df93b6903bbacf624f2ef71e064412654e71cf313",
"reviewed_manifest_sha256": "sha256:f672c3503baa823cf4af5eac3bf0513b6b25de6e2674902273cb778f4e771080",
"reviewer_ids": [
"codex-reviewer:vera-molnar-a9-copy-correction-independent"
],
"role": "reviewer"
},
"schema_id": "0xd8aef6592fe156c4c3c10e59de540f5cdf8b130eedca322e0e22b30764bee1a9",
"source_record_ids": [
"6529NM-ACC-2026-002",
"6529NM-ACC-ENT-0002",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-001",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-002",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-003",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-004",
"6529NM-PG-2026-001.OBJ-005",
"6529NM-W-0024",
"6529NM-W-0025",
"6529NM-W-0026",
"6529NM-W-0027",
"6529NM-W-0028",
"6529NM-WAVE-OBS-2026-08-08-001",
"6529NM.2026.002",
"6529NM.2026.002.01",
"6529NM.2026.002.02",
"6529NM.2026.002.03",
"6529NM.2026.002.04",
"6529NM.2026.002.05",
"6529NM.2026.002.GAA-01"
],
"status_observation": {
"evidence_refs": [
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Signed-drop API WINNER status readback (is_signed=true)",
"observed_at": "2026-08-08T10:15:02.0167151Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "B",
"label": "Original proposed gift record",
"observed_at": "2026-08-06T13:19:30.726Z",
"uri": "https://6529.io/waves/5f207393-5418-4a75-8738-e40edb44a94d?drop=002bfa4f-8416-48bf-b35e-38f354e9a9f0"
},
{
"evidence_class": "E",
"label": "Curated acquisition thesis",
"observed_at": "2026-08-09T00:00:00Z",
"uri": "https://github.com/6529-Collections/6529networkmuseum/blob/main/records/proposed-gifts/6529NM-PG-2026-001/public/scholarship/essays/conflict-at-its-edges.md"
}
],
"observed_at": "2026-08-12T22:24:36.387Z",
"status_label": "published"
},
"subject_id": "6529NM-CA-2026-003",
"visibility": "public"
}
}
Acquisition context
Part ofPatrolling the border between the Negev Desert and Jordan
Status Accessioned into the permanent CollectionStatus as ofDavid Seymour, Negev, 1952. © David Seymour/Magnum Photos 2022.Part ofGovernment soldiers in a church, Suchitoto, El Salvador
Status Accessioned into the permanent CollectionStatus as ofLarry Towell, Suchitoto, El Salvador, 1986. © Larry Towell/Magnum Photos 2022.Part ofDemonstration, Western Wall, Jerusalem
Status Accessioned into the permanent CollectionStatus as ofMicha Bar-Am, Jerusalem, 1989. © Micha Bar-Am/Magnum Photos 2022.Part ofTripoli, Libya
Status Accessioned into the permanent CollectionStatus as ofMoisés Saman, Tripoli, Libya, 2011. © Moisés Saman/Magnum Photos 2022.Part ofPalmyra, Syria
Status Accessioned into the permanent CollectionStatus as ofLorenzo Meloni, Palmyra, Syria, 2016. © Lorenzo Meloni/Magnum Photos 2022.- Part ofMagnum Photos 75
- Project originatorMagnum Photos